Jump to content

GuptSinghani

Members
  • Posts

    27
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by GuptSinghani

  1. I though the paath of sikhi was to remember Waheguru Maharaj 24/7, so how can doing alot of Baani be a bad thing, or compare to black magic (we dont live in cuckoo land, do we?). There are tons of sant mahapursh that spent so much of their time doing Bhagti to the point were each of their roam was reciting Baani. We should aspire to be like them, so naturally we do actually need to pull our fingers out and read Grbani.

    And if you not going to join in with the sewa keep ur snidey lil comments to yourselves!

    Agree with the two above thers a helluve lot of lazy ppl, Maharaj Kirpa kare!

  2. You have made a very good suggestion, especially about Giani's.

    I have been involved in work with the UKBA they govern the immigration procedures for getting Giani's into the country. They have made new tighter systems when calling Giani's over and also what to do if something goes wrong. They have stated that any Giani who goes AWOL from work or is found doing anti Gurmat activities even if they are not doing a criminal act-smoking,drinking etc. should be reported to them. If they cannot stay within the requirements of their jobs they can be deported.

    If anyone does come across any Giani's doing something anti-Gurmat they should be reported to UKBA so that they can take action.

  3. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

    A while back in December Veer Manpreet Singh did some katha to do with the shabad of Tuhi Tuhi. The kirtan and most of the katha was recorded but not th epart where he talks about Tuhi Tuhi. I vaguely remember it was about Guru Gobind Singh Ji maharaj reciting the bani of linking all things to Waheguru and one of his diciples(forgot the name) started to write down what Maharaj was saying. In the end Maharaj opened his eyes and saw that the SIngh was sittting and writing what he had recited. He asked the Singh what have you written, he replied I have written Tuhi Tuhi, some 13000 times.

    I was looking for the details of this saakhi and full Tuhi Tuhi shabad.

    Thanks in advance, bhul chuk maaf as I am not too sure of the details of the saakhi.

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

  4. I think some people are slightly confused.

    The girl who wanted to be given a place in the uni was asking for a reserved seat for Sikhs, the rest of the places for non sikhs etc were already taken. She was denied that seat on the basis that she doesnt keep kesh.

    She doesnt deserve the seat if she cant follow one of the basic tenents of Sikhi, surely she must show some dedication to the faith as an entrance criteria?

  5. The thread is about 'NO HUMAN GURU. NO GURU AFTER DHAN GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI' the whole thread focuses on this topic on so called fake babas and gurus saying the they are the successors to Guru Gobind Singh Ji.

    I simply mentioned the kookay and the flaws in them using the chaubis avtaar theory.

    I follow Gur Dasam Darbar as being writings of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj as take the writings to be Satbachan.

    So who does this apply to?

  6. I posted this in a previous topic but got no reply so posted as a topic itself...

    "I always see people say 'NO HUMAN GURU. NO GURU AFTER DHAN GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI' on these forums but cant find this quoted anywhere can someone tell me where this is written in SGGSji or anywhere else."

    When I read SGGSji I feel that this is not the case, I cant read punjabi and rely on English translations and wonder whether im losing the meaning of the message in translation.

    This can work both ways, where have you seen it been written that there is another Guru after Guru Granth Sahib Ji?

    One of the other posters have already said that from the time of Guru Amardas Ji all the Guru sahibs have been in the same bloodline, this was due to the request of Bibi Bhani. Why would they Guru sahibs break that promise?

    I have said it before through the life of all Das Guru Sahibs, all their works and bachan were compiled as well as other holy men and Gur Granth Sahib Ji was created. As Guru Granth Sahib Ji has been COMPLETED why is there a need for baba x to come in and steer his oar?

    This is going to seem a bit 'taboo' but was there a need for Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale? Because I'm sure he has Sant and Baba in front of his name?

    Yes Sant Giani Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa does have Sant and Baba in front of his name.

    The term Sant is defined in Sukhmani Sahib Ji da Paath and so is given to people who can demonstrate those qualities.

    But there are fundamental differences he NEVER gave himself a higher status than Guru Granth Sahib Ji. He NEVER sat at the same level or higher than Guru Maharaj. He ALWAYS preached that Guru Granth Sahib Ji is our father and we should bow only to them. He did not say he is the next Sikh Guru or call himself Guru.

    Can my questiosn be answered now?

  7. exactly - why wait for the attack to happen in our most holiest of shrines?

    You are saying the attack was planned, the group inside had time to fortify themselves - did it not occur to them the implications of lying in wait in the Gurdwara?

    should they not have taken the battle away from the Gurdwara complex??

    Just because they knew it was happening does not mean that they could have done anything to move it or prevent it. Where could they have taken it? (any suggestions)

    Let me ask you if GOI were attacking Harmander Sahib for a particular purpose what was the need to attack the other 50 Gurughar?

    To be honest you seem to be saying why did the Singhs not surrendar to the GOI outside the Gurughar.

  8. I posted this in a previous topic but got no reply so posted as a topic itself...

    "I always see people say 'NO HUMAN GURU. NO GURU AFTER DHAN GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI' on these forums but cant find this quoted anywhere can someone tell me where this is written in SGGSji or anywhere else."

    When I read SGGSji I feel that this is not the case, I cant read punjabi and rely on English translations and wonder whether im losing the meaning of the message in translation.

    This can work both ways, where have you seen it been written that there is another Guru after Guru Granth Sahib Ji?

    One of the other posters have already said that from the time of Guru Amardas Ji all the Guru sahibs have been in the same bloodline, this was due to the request of Bibi Bhani. Why would they Guru sahibs break that promise?

    I have said it before through the life of all Das Guru Sahibs, all their works and bachan were compiled as well as other holy men and Gur Granth Sahib Ji was created. As Guru Granth Sahib Ji has been COMPLETED why is there a need for baba x to come in and steer his oar?

  9. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

    You still are not answering the question, Guru Nanak Dev Ji wrote Aarti for Sikhs whether or not hindu's etc have the same or similar practice does not matter.

    We shouldnt dwell on what other faiths do or practice instead need to focus on what Guru Sahib has given to us. How can you preach the importance of Bani etc. and then slander Aarti that is Bani aswell?

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

  10. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

    Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh,

    Yes I agree, and you've just stated my point, so what part does ritualism play within Bani? Why do we have the need for rituals and approaches to Sikhi which just ARE NOT Sikhi, when we're young like 5 or 6 yeah ok we accept what happens at Guru Ghar because we know no better, but now we as Sikh adults, don't we have the right to question these rituals that are taking place in Guru Ghars all over the world, is this really Sikhi? or are we just adopting approaches to seem more like an 'orthodox' belief system, rather than giving Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj our full vishwaas? Extremist views and nonsensical belief is not Sikhi, blind faith is no faith at all, its lacking the ability to interpret, learn and question. There are several stories within Sikhi which fully support this view as well as Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, so why in this day and age are we still reverting to following practices which have no place in a monotheistic equal righteous humanitarian religion such as Sikhi, which places no value on superstitions!

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

    I am slightly confused which practices are we supposed to be questioning?

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

  11. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh

    You mentioned that interpretation of reading bani is not the exact or actual meaning of it.

    Bani is written to apply to all yet we all are different and are at different stages of life. This means that as we interpret bani we are able to apply it to our lives. Bani or Sikhi is not textbook, we cant pick up a book and say yep that is what bani/Sikhi means. On the other hand there is translated versions of Bani that Attempt to explain Bani but there is not one concrete entity that has been able to explain Bani, Bhai Gurdas ji's vaars are considered the key to Gurbani. We should look to them for guidance.

    Katha is also a good way to understand Bani, the kathavachak will tell you in plain language what Bani is saying. However it is for you to interpret the message and apply it to your life.

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use