laxman

Who claimed to be Hindu? Gautama? Brahma? Vishnu? Mahesh? Ram Chandan? Guru Nanak? I think you’ll find None of them did. *EDITED* While debating and discussion is fine, we will not tolerate rudeness, insulting posts, personal attacks or purposeless inflammatory posts.

well thats wat you say your leadership says otherwise himat sohi says sikhs are hindu and so does the your vedenthi and badal and every other jatha namdhari, radha soami and nirankari and etc.you have no right or athority.

*EDITED* Admin Note: Last Warning Given. Direct attack/mockery on Sikh kaum will be not be tolerated and automatically deleted by Moderators and Administrators. We respect freedom of speech but we cannot allow hatred against any religion. Direct banned will be applied to those who violate this rule but we are going easy on you by putting your id under moderation for 30 days.

Whats wrong in saying all Sikhs are Hindus? ‘Hinduism’ has millions of branches/philosophies and the word itself is an umberella term coined by parsis to understand the composite culture of India. Rather than every fringe group calling themselves as ‘independent of hinduism’ and proactively working towards segregation, they should first learn about their roots and unite under the ‘hindu’ umberella - which literally provides infinite freedom. The first sikh guru WAS INDEED a ‘Hindu’, just like Gautama Siddharth was a ‘Hindu’ and so is Sri Sri, Mata Amritanandamayi, Vivekananda, Rama Krishna etc. Their followers would do more justice to their Master’s teachings by reognizing their rooots and adhering to the spirit the teachings [DERIVED from the ocean called ‘Hinduism’] - staying united rather than segregating with the fear of ‘losing identity’!! i will like to have answer to it instead of just abuse.