Young Bloodz

well will they still be bhangra dancers n singers etc.. as usual???

i might have interpreted this wrong but are u saying the nosies are a way of expressing their pyaar ?? well what about what naamdharis do when they dance? would dancing be exceptable in the Darbar of Guru Granth Sahib if dancing was the way of expressing love?

Simran is to remember. so in theory i guess you can do it in anyway as long as u remember god. But saying that to distort the Gurmantar in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib is wrong in my view, clearly in Guru Granth Sahib it tells you waht the gurmantar is , which is Waheguru. and in the recordings they are not doing that at all. Even when people do "saas giraas" u can tell they are japping waheguru but in a different way. The recording however is not either.

People follow paths which suite them some choose Hinduism, some Islam, and some Sikhism as well as many others. According to ones own needs they will follow a path. In this case people have a problem with the beliefs of Niddar Singh. Now how can this be solved ? The obvious is a formal debate online or in person. i have seen whenever someone questions a specif belief of a group it usually ends up in name calling etc... i would suggest start a new thread where we can all of a formal discussion on this instead of putting down others views we should try and understand each other and the diversity of this world. in the words of Saint Thomas Aquinas "Because of the diverse conditions of humans, it happens that some acts are virtuous to some people, as appropriate and suitable to them, while the same acts are immoral for others, as inappropriate to them. "