shastarSingh

Yes sikh boys join army due to lack of other decent paying job options. More than 80% of Punjabi farmers hv less than 5 acres of agricultural land. There must be some bhappe in army too as even in bhappaas u can find middle class or lower middle class.

I met this guy in 2008. He is a businessman from Ludhiana. Has one of his restaurants in Sarabha Nagar market in Ludhiana. He is pro Indian army and like all bhappaas will never speak against GOI. This is kaliyug. Money or Maya is the top priority of most people.

https://www.thesikhencyclopedia.com/biographical/famous-sikh-personalities/tansukh-lahaurl/

I agree.

Dallysingh veerji What do you make of this?

In Chandi charitar 2 of Dasam Granth Sahib, there is mention of guns which means Chandi charitar is an adaption and not a translation of markandey puran. https://www.sikhitothemax.org/ang?ang=109&source=D

Gobind Gita is not a translation of Bhagwad Gita. It's an adaption. In 11th chapter, under 'arjun vaach' , the last line of 42nd chhand reads: Kayee bisan tum bapp maahi This means there are many vishnus(krishans) in the body of Akal Purakh. This means Gobind Gita is an adaption and not a translation.

I was mistaken when I wrote this post. Satnaam and gurmantar are the same. Only Vaheguru is gurmantar. Only Vaheguru is satnaam. Vahguru is neither satnaam nor gurmantar.

https://youtu.be/HZbpOfKbwQg

I mean we don't need converts for the sake of doing translations. Gyanis in a taksal hv levels. The ones at the top level hv lots of vidya. They can easily understand braj bhasha.

We don't need Hindu converts. We hv great vidvaans in our taksals. We also hv nirmalas who are vidvaans in Sanskrit too.

I will contact Panjab digital library if they could digitalize it?

Yes I hv seen quite a few biharis become sardars

Veerji How can we bring this great brij bhasha work in print? Where are it's manuscripts ?

I was talking about the brij bhasha work of lakhan rai. It shud be brougjt in print. It shud be studied just as taksali students study saruktavali, vairag shatak, parbodh Chander natak etc. May be a steek shud be prepared for general sikh audience. Short stories with morals are a simple way and entertaining way of studying wisdom.( not necessarily agreeing to all the wisdom.)

The video on you tube is private

Looks very interesting piece of literature. Shud be brought to print.

No veerji Heard for the first time

Hari Chand was doing great damage to Guru Gobind Singh ji's army. But Guru Sahib gave him 3 vaars. 3rd vaar hit Guru Sahib in kamarkassa. Then Guru Sahib spoke "jabai baann lagiyo tabai ros jagiyo' Then Guru Sahib killed hari Chand with just 1 shot from teer kamaan. I feel krishan lied and used deceit. He did the same to kill dronacharya. What's your view on that?

While doing face to face battle with the enemy, should a brave warrior speak a lie to distract the enemy? I agree in life , sometimes a person has to lie for the larger good to happen but lying during a face to face battle duel?????

Speech therapy is all about altering your original speech which has stammer. So slowing your speech also comes in the category of altering your speech. If one can find a good speech therapist, just in 30-40 sittings, one can get cured.

Jai tegang veer Do you think it was a fine battle tactic or was it deceit?

https://www.livemint.com/Sundayapp/lvfgnLAQlYonkkKObhBmVN/The-moral-imperatives-to-a-lie.html Krishna, the eighth avatar of Vishnu, the supreme god, tells Yudhisthira this is a war that must be won. And that if a lie ought to be told to win it, then the lie must be told. In this instance, Krishna knows Drona’s only weakness is his son Ashwathama. So, he asks Yudhisthira to spread the word that Ashwathama is dead. But Yudhisthira has a problem with that. His morality and reputation do not permit him to lie. He despises it as dishonest. But even as Yudhisthira is thinking through Krishna’s proposition and its implications, Bhima, one of the Pandava brothers, kills an elephant named Ashwathama and screams: “Ashwathama is dead". Word reaches Drona. The man thinks it is his son Bhima is talking of. Stunned, he refuses to believe the news until he hears it from Yudhisthira and summons him. Krishna’s words still ringing in his ears, Yudhisthira goes over to his uncle’s camp. “Is it true," Drona asks him, “that Ashwathama is dead?" “Yes," Yudhisthira says. And then trails off inaudibly, “Ashwathama the elephant." Technically, Yudhisthira did not lie. But Drona doesn’t catch the words, lays down his weapons and bows his head in grief. In that very instant, on Krishna’s instructions, Dhrishtadyumna, Yudhisthira’s brother-in-law, chops his head off.

So krishan used chall? He spoke something from his mouth which was not true? In Mahabharata, krishan also asked yudhistar to lie. Would that be also called battle tactic?