Eating Meat Is Wrong, But Why?

[RajanSingh]

Well said hardeep singh!!!

to the sangat: if you are going to reply, plase try not to get angry or say anything i offensive way, because i do not want this topic to get closed. kirpa karke please talk nicely and get your points across safely. hehe

I do not believe anthing what the akaal takht say, i never even knew who they were till last year!! as long as the answer is in gurbani, which it always is, i will only follow the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj Jee. Akaal Takht are not our gurur's, i just wanted to tell this to 'khalsa fauj', thanks anyway.

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa,

vaaheguroo jee kee fateh.

(no offence)

remember, kirpa karke please try not to get this topic closed by making it argumentative in a bad way. fateh jee.

[RajanSingh]

Well said hardeep singh!!!

to the sangat: if you are going to reply, plase try not to get angry or say anything i offensive way, because i do not want this topic to get closed. kirpa karke please talk nicely and get your points across safely. hehe

I do not believe anthing what the akaal takht say, i never even knew who they were till last year!! as long as the answer is in gurbani, which it always is, i will only follow the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj Jee. Akaal Takht are not our gurur's, i just wanted to tell this to 'khalsa fauj', thanks anyway.

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa,

vaaheguroo jee kee fateh.

(no offence)

p.s. another thing to 'THE KHALSA FAUJ', if the akaal takht said go cut your hair, would you do it? its just as bad for them to say eat meat.

And 'RAJU123', your ancestors only ate meat from the start because they were full of greed, they were full of lobh!!! you know the 5 evils- kaam/lust, krodh/anger, lobh/greed, moh/anttachment, hankaar/ego....

remember, kirpa karke please try not to get this topic closed by making it argumentative in a bad way. fateh jee.

[Pakandi baba]

shako shako raj raj kay :TH:

LOL!! Bottalan sharab di vi khol lo...

Follow the Akal Takht Rehat Maryada and everything is clear. As the veers on the bheva thread keep saying Dhan Guru Hargobind Ji told us the truth will come from the Akal Takht and the Rehat Maryada is pretty clear on the meat issue.

Every single hukamnaamaa written by Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji starts with: "guru guru japna janam savar sangat dee kamnaa guru pooree karraygaa. Sangatee da ruzgaar hog, ik daasee rahinaa. Maas muchee day naray nahee avanaa."

What is mass? Flesh? Don't go near flesh? Where do you go them? If you go home, you see flesh. If you go out, you see flesh. If you run ti jungles, you see flesh. Everywhere you go, you meet species of flesh. Fake hukamnama. Doesn't make sence. Akaal Takht rehat maryada says not to eat halal. Case closed. You know more than Akaal Takht? Have you done more research than the Panth? If Panthic marayda says you can eat, you can. If you think you got better research and you know what you are talking about. Take your case to Akaal Takht, if they agree to your point and change the maryada, I will accept it.

Let me say, Yes I know more than Akal Takht, I know more than the panth, if your allowed to eat flesh, then us humans can be consumed too, let me consume you, let me chop ur head of and boil it in the pan. The people of Akhal takht are robbers , cheaters, liars and will be sent to hell, I have said many a times, I do and never will follow Akal Takht in my life, until the people behind it are all vanished, because they are themselves cheats and attack their own sikhs.

And many a times, when Gurbani said never argue over meat and non veg, is because fools like me and everyone else will get in to tangle, thats why Guru ji has said it, "BEVcoooooof" people!

And to add to it, I have heard from the Guru himself and he said to me "putra, these people who quarell over "meat" why do you participate, and I said to Guru ji, mero kolo reh nehi hundha, then Guru ji goes to me, Putra "maas" Khana bhohath paap heh, Khakhe manukh nu churasi lakh joon dhe vich jahna pendhay, maafi mungo, teh "NAAM" japoo, hor kisay nehi kam nehi ona, jeenay vee Akhal Thakt dhe beadbi karn gay us manukh nu dargah dhi jagha nehi milsakn gi"

and I would with my hands together accepted Guru's hukum

I mean I am laughing at you guys, can you imagine Guru Nanak Dev ji killing a goat for his own consumption HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, he himself did farming and tried to make a living, why would he want top consume, wake up!

Tell Akhal Takht to make meat in Darbar Sahib Langar, they would not do it, because they will get beats. Go on tell them, to make meat in Gurdwara's.

Khalsa ji, i agree with you. We have historical facts on the Guru's lives, but only one mere mention of Guru Nanak 'Eating' a bukra.....

I say (so does the Guru) kar lain de jo karde, 'Aape Bheej Appe Kha' (You reap what you sow)

Also, if they all were in the Hukam, then they'd be a shortage of people in the charasi lakh joon.... :D

Gur Fateh Veera

[Hardeep__singh]

shako shako raj raj kay :TH:

LOL!! Bottalan sharab di vi khol lo...

Follow the Akal Takht Rehat Maryada and everything is clear. As the veers on the bheva thread keep saying Dhan Guru Hargobind Ji told us the truth will come from the Akal Takht and the Rehat Maryada is pretty clear on the meat issue.

Every single hukamnaamaa written by Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji starts with: "guru guru japna janam savar sangat dee kamnaa guru pooree karraygaa. Sangatee da ruzgaar hog, ik daasee rahinaa. Maas muchee day naray nahee avanaa."

What is mass? Flesh? Don't go near flesh? Where do you go them? If you go home, you see flesh. If you go out, you see flesh. If you run ti jungles, you see flesh. Everywhere you go, you meet species of flesh. Fake hukamnama. Doesn't make sence. Akaal Takht rehat maryada says not to eat halal. Case closed. You know more than Akaal Takht? Have you done more research than the Panth? If Panthic marayda says you can eat, you can. If you think you got better research and you know what you are talking about. Take your case to Akaal Takht, if they agree to your point and change the maryada, I will accept it.

Let me say, Yes I know more than Akal Takht, I know more than the panth, if your allowed to eat flesh, then us humans can be consumed too, let me consume you, let me chop ur head of and boil it in the pan. The people of Akhal takht are robbers , cheaters, liars and will be sent to hell, I have said many a times, I do and never will follow Akal Takht in my life, until the people behind it are all vanished, because they are themselves cheats and attack their own sikhs.

And many a times, when Gurbani said never argue over meat and non veg, is because fools like me and everyone else will get in to tangle, thats why Guru ji has said it, "BEVcoooooof" people!

And to add to it, I have heard from the Guru himself and he said to me "putra, these people who quarell over "meat" why do you participate, and I said to Guru ji, mero kolo reh nehi hundha, then Guru ji goes to me, Putra "maas" Khana bhohath paap heh, Khakhe manukh nu churasi lakh joon dhe vich jahna pendhay, maafi mungo, teh "NAAM" japoo, hor kisay nehi kam nehi ona, jeenay vee Akhal Thakt dhe beadbi karn gay us manukh nu dargah dhi jagha nehi milsakn gi"

and I would with my hands together accepted Guru's hukum

I mean I am laughing at you guys, can you imagine Guru Nanak Dev ji killing a goat for his own consumption HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, he himself did farming and tried to make a living, why would he want top consume, wake up!

Tell Akhal Takht to make meat in Darbar Sahib Langar, they would not do it, because they will get beats. Go on tell them, to make meat in Gurdwara's.

Khalsa ji, i agree with you. We have historical facts on the Guru's lives, but only one mere mention of Guru Nanak 'Eating' a bukra.....

I say (so does the Guru) kar lain de jo karde, 'Aape Bheej Appe Kha' (You reap what you sow)

Also, if they all were in the Hukam, then they'd be a shortage of people in the charasi lakh joon.... :D

Gur Fateh Veera

Oh cigarette wi pillo! :TH:

[Pakandi baba]

Oh cigarette wi pillo! :TH:

Ahoo kion ni. je kara-na fer karo dab ke.....Kanjarian vi sadlo Massa Rangar vang....

[RajanSingh]

aae hae..... kehri gal banaa ke rakh diti

[Pakandi baba]

aae hae..... kehri gal banaa ke rakh diti

Well it all leads down to that path.