Guru Nanak Vedas

[guptveer1469]

Nothing anti-Hindu, but how can we trust the writings of a group that think it is okay to change their religious texts with time? They have re-written Ramayan and Mahabharat more than ten times. First time Mahabharat was written was 4-5-6 centuries before christ with the title Jai Ithias (The (hi)story of Victory) and the now Mahabharat are two poles apart. So much has been changed in texts and there are so many versions of each event in those 'books' its difficult to trust them.

[anom7]

i dunt kno bout tha rewriting thing, can u provide some clear facts or something veera

but im more intrested in wats said bout guru je

im guessing since no one actually can confirm the quotes

its a lie?

cuz tha be a pretty serious lie to make up

[guptveer1469]

i think... dont get me wrong or be angry at me

but brahmins did it in somewhere in 18th century during Ranjit Singh kingdom...... Just to show that hinduism is great and all predictions in 'religious' books come true.... dunno its just a mere guess

Mod note: Just a word of advice - if you're not sure, 'dunno' and are merely guessing, then try to make sure your argument has some substance or evidence to it. Otherwise it will make people angry at you, and it suggests that you are generalising entire communities.

[kam1825]

If the Bhavishat Puran foretelling of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji was not written before the advent of Maharaj then what about the katha and uthanika of the shabad at Kurakshetar and the shabad Maas Maas Kar Moorakh Chagarde. Also the Uthanika on the Sahaskritee Salok!

????????????????????????

[anom7]

ok kam 1825, i dunt kno wa u posted

but i dunt think the quotes exist

i TRIED to find em in the vedas

there wasnt really antyhing...

[kam1825]

Bhavishat Puran is not in the Vedas. If you want to know what the quotes are i suggest you pick up te Damdami Taksal Steek and turn to pages 12 and 13. You will find quotes from the gopal taapnee upanishad, Surtee Parmaan, Sri Madh Bhagvat Da Puran and the Bhavikhat Puran

[anom7]

ye i kno purana arnt the vedas

im sorry i dunt got the taksal steek, if u cud just post the quotes here

and so at least it can be said the veda quoted were false??

[kam1825]

No there are alot more qutes i just need to go through other steeks books and katha. I will try to post the pages.