Do You Believe In The Dasam Granth

[virk20]

cause it conterdicts the guru granth sahib

[Inder Singh]

cause it conterdicts the guru granth sahib

Please show us where? If you put a question mark you should be forthcoming with a specific query also.

[kh@ls@]

Please close this topic

[Jag_Singh]

to topic starter,

Anything Guru maharaaj touches becomes amrit. Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh ji wrote the Dasam Granth, just imagine how amazing and lucky we are to see and experience the true writings from guru sahib himself.

[Bundha]

I fully support the previous closure of a similar thread by the moderators.

These people are trying to create a controversy where none exists, time and time again these dushts are starting new threads on the same subject over and over again.

This is a concerted effort by these people to make mud stick.

I urge the mods to close every thread started by these people on Dasam Granth Ji.

[Inder Singh]

I fully support the previous closure of a similar thread by the moderators.

These people are trying to create a controversy where none exists, time and time again these dushts are starting new threads on the same subject over and over again.

This is a concerted effort by these people to make mud stick.

I urge the mods to close every thread started by these people on Dasam Granth Ji.

Bundha ji

You are right. This man is new on the forum and has 4 posts only.

He is here for mischief and should be put on moderation.

[K. SINGH DEEP]

DASAM GRANTH IS THE COLLECTION OF BANI OF DASAM PATSHAH JI

(HIS ORIGINAL SCRIPTS like JAAP SAAHIB; AKAAL USTAT; GYAN PRABODH

SHABAD HAZAARE; BACHITTAR NAATAK etc )and translations of the

VARIOUS PURANS of Sanskrit as CHANDI CAHARITAR(translation of

MAARKANDE PURAAN into simple language) ,CHOBEES AVTAAR,TRIYA CHARITAR

etc.LANGUAGE. DASAM GRANTH HAS BEEN COPILED BY BHAAI MANI SINGH JI

from various POTHIS wich were preserved by various SIKHS with them.

No doubt the BANI of DASAM GRANTH can be said to have been composed

by DASAM PATSHAH but some so called VIDVAANA who have always been

criticizing it , may be due to TRANSLATION PART but the should know

that before start of such TRANSLATION PARTS , GURU SAHIB has given

hints as before start of CHANDI CHARITATRA ,GURU SAHIB added as

ATTHH MARKANDE PURAN BILAS KATHHATE mean s now the translation of

MAARKANDE PURAN is being told.Why so called VIDVAANS ignore such

hints and are unnecessarily involving KHALSA PANTH in endless

dispute. So please stop giving odd remarks about DASAM GRANTH JI.

Please study and read and serve KHALSA PANTH in CHARHDI KALA.

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

[Inder Singh]

DASAM GRANTH IS THE COLLECTION OF BANI OF DASAM PATSHAH JI

(HIS ORIGINAL SCRIPTS like JAAP SAAHIB; AKAAL USTAT; GYAN PRABODH

SHABAD HAZAARE; BACHITTAR NAATAK etc )and translations of the

VARIOUS PURANS of Sanskrit as CHANDI CAHARITAR(translation of

MAARKANDE PURAAN into simple language) ,CHOBEES AVTAAR,TRIYA CHARITAR

etc.LANGUAGE. DASAM GRANTH HAS BEEN COPILED BY BHAAI MANI SINGH JI

from various POTHIS wich were preserved by various SIKHS with them.

No doubt the BANI of DASAM GRANTH can be said to have been composed

by DASAM PATSHAH but some so called VIDVAANA who have always been

criticizing it , may be due to TRANSLATION PART but the should know

that before start of such TRANSLATION PARTS , GURU SAHIB has given

hints as before start of CHANDI CHARITATRA ,GURU SAHIB added as

ATTHH MARKANDE PURAN BILAS KATHHATE mean s now the translation of

MAARKANDE PURAN is being told.Why so called VIDVAANS ignore such

hints and are unnecessarily involving KHALSA PANTH in endless

dispute. So please stop giving odd remarks about DASAM GRANTH JI.

Please study and read and serve KHALSA PANTH in CHARHDI KALA.

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

It was not exact translation of markandey and bhagwat puranas. These writings

were altered to mould them into sikh philosophy. There were major alterations.

[K. SINGH DEEP]

The too little knowledge of the misinterpreters about the

reality can be judged from the fact that many a times in

various publications the Sanskrit scripture written as

"SAMAAPATAM AST SHUBHAM AST"( means that this topic ends

gracefully) is being written and also pronounced as

" SAMAAPAT MAST SUBH MAST"

[virk20]

i don't know to much about the dasam granth but some things that ive bin told have left me puzzled, is it true their is talk of hindu gods in the dasam granth and what it says about them

i started a similar topic about how to debate ppl who claim sikhism is a mix of hinduism and islam, its a debate im having with someone at work and they have brought up the dasam granth trying to use this book as evidence that sikhism is a mix