Kala Afgan

[navjotsingh]

hahaha yo nice

[Jkaur]

virji mkhalsa thumbs up to u... well wuts is wrong wid ppl today.. first that so called baba burning sri guru granth sahib.. and nw this kala fella calling guru gobind singh ji a " .... " this people are just seeking of attention and of course money... sheesh... :umm:

[Ryu Hayabusa]

I don't know who that Kala Afghana guy is but he and his protege is trying to sling some mud against Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, I was just reading this:

http://www.punjabheritage.com/9_2003/bhai_randhir.html

[gmb_sim]

does he have links with rss ?? and how bigs his organisation ?? isit something to be worrying about ??

[Sarbloh Soulja]

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

leh, cant say nowt about bhai sahib randhir singh, he roks!

[Mkhalsa]

Kala afghana was a punjab police officer/spy. He was with Baba Jarnail Singh Jee in the early 80's and had a room at darbar sahib where he stayed. I beleive its in a book about Baba Jarnail Singh where he is mentioned. Baba Jee found out about him and sent some singhs to bring him to him. He said "Bring Gurbaksh Singh Here" and when the singhs went to his room he was gone along with all his stuff, only an empty room was left.

He resurfaced at the end of the 90s out of nowhere and somehow became a "scholar" on sikhi. Yeah right... he cant even answer questions about his book, has no idea wahts in them half the time. They were written in india by a team probably.

[jagjit_waheguru]

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

Pyare jio, I have read many of his books, Bipran Ki reet, etc. Kala Afgana is taking sikhi from an intellectual, or probably more accurate from an athiest view. Some of his stuff in his first books was very interesting, but some of what he says is very scandalous.

In particular his book Maas Maas kar Moorak Jaguray. This is a very sad book, in which shows the complete lack of balance in his thinking. He spends so much time slagging off Bhai Randhir Singh, Baba Gurbachan Singh Bindrawale, Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara, and Baba Jarnail Singh Bindra wale, that one feels like asking has this person any shame. He is so desperate in his bid to get people to accept meat, that most of his arguments are without base, his use of Gurbani is out of context.

His so called intellectialism shows a complete lack of faith and practice of Naam abyass.

As for this link by one of his protoges. From all of Bhai sahib 30-40 books, that is all he could say. The quotes have been manipulated. For example the first point about the sadhu. Bhai sahib saw no man with a white beard. The author added this himself. The actual moral of that story is only follow the Guru and never a person, because all people have flaws. Again I could go through each point. But this person seems to have little respect for the truth.

Lastly, one point which really illustrates everything about Kala afgani. In one of his books, he says, my biggest criticism of Bhai Randhir Singh is that he only quotes gurbani and gives his views on it. He never shows where he gets these views from." Basically he is saying, that Bhai Sahib never source

s his writings as all western people do in thesis and disertations, etc. What he fails to understand is that Bhai Randhir Singh was a Pooran Gursikh, he quoted Gurbani, the Primal Source, and explained it. His Knowledge came form abyass, and practical experience. He did not need to use any other person source because he spoke the truth, not any opinions. The problem with Kala Afgani type of intellectuals is that they have no idea of the truth through there own abyass and jeevan, and practical living. So what they do is get gurbani, and see what this person has said, and that person has said, and bring them together with their own opinions, and come to some conclusions as to what that gurbani shabad says.

Bhai sahib went to the source and brought out the truth. For example, if Bhai sahib was an historian, he would have been the one to do the hard work and interview the people at the time. Kala afgani types are people who do not do the hard work, take a few books, taking this person version, and that person version, and make up their own version.

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh