Magzine Spokesman?

[sunny_love_kirtan]

Do any body knew about the controvery over magzine SPOKESMAN?????

Why SGPC cheif ordered to boycott it?

i never read this magzine. :

but i listened that this magzine publish worng about BHAI RANDHEER SINGH JI( STARTER OF AKJ)

And also published about the incident of rejecting to drink soft drink in the commonly used cups

made up of glass.

plz share ur views.

ALSO IF WE DONT READ IT THEN THEY WILL CONTINUE PUBLISHING WRONG THINGS ABOUT SIKHS

AND WE WIILL NOT BE AWARE OF IT.

I HAVE A SPECIAL LETTER WROTE TO THE EDITOR OF SPOKESMAN BY A VERY GURMUKH SINGH OF

AKJ FROM HANDIGARH WHO IS A RETIRED FLYING OFFICER KULDEEP SINGH 'MATWALA'

I WILL ALSO SHARE THAT LETTER WITH U.

[Guest PunjabSingh]

Sunny,

Have a look at the online edition of spokesman and decide for yourself :

http://www.***anti-sikh website not allowed***

Im neither in favour nor against this newspaper but I personally feel that prakash badal has some personal problems with this paper .

May be badal and Co dont like the outspoken way spokesman does it's reporting.

But I may be wrong.

You decide yourself

[sunny_love_kirtan]

Sunny,

Have a look at the online edition of spokesman and decide for yourself :

http://www.***anti-sikh website not allowed***

Im neither in favour nor against this newspaper but I personally feel that prakash badal has some personal problems with this paper .

May be badal and Co dont like the outspoken way spokesman does it's reporting.

But I may be wrong.

You decide yourself

VEER JI

NO DOUBTS ABOUT THE CORRUPTION CASES OF BADAL AND SGPC.

BUT I WAS TALKING ABOUT THE CASE OF AKHAND KEERTANI JATHA AND ABOUT THE WRONG

WORDS ABOUT BHAI SAHIB BHAI RANDHEER SINGH JI.

CAN ANY ONE JUSTIFY THIS CASE????

[Guest PunjabSingh]

Veeray ,

I dont know about the Akhand Kirtani jatha case with spokesman.

If he said anything wrong about AKJ or any sikhism related matter then it is very wrong

I told you Im not a supporter of spokesman.

[sunny_love_kirtan]

ok

i will tell u the whole event after some days.

[Guest PunjabSingh]

ok

i will tell u the whole event after some days.

I suppose now you will ask someone about the controversy.

I would say believe in what you see yourself rather than what you are told by others.

So far as Spokesman controversy with Shri Akaal Takht Sahib is concerned I think it's a personal fight between Sokesman and Jathedar Vedanti and not Akaal Takht but I may be wrong.

So far as my experience with Spokesman is concerned it is a very bold newspaper which says the truth whether someone likes it or not .

For example see the special report below :

Has any other newspaper mentioned these manmat practices and corruption in SGPC ?

'Tusi kuj na likhiyo,mein hal kadan de koshish karaanga'...shame on this SGPC member.

Bhul chuk maaf,

das nimana

[S1ngh]

Spokesman is corrupt and they should not be supported by sangat at all. Most of us know the spokesman support for Kala Afghana who is consider to be the sick man.

[kurtas]

Spokesman is corrupt and they should not be supported by sangat at all. Most of us know the spokesman support for Kala Afghana who is consider to be the sick man.

This spokesman issue has nothing to do with what has been written about the AKJ or any other panthic group. Vedanti is a stooge and as the spokesman have written against, badal, vedanti and many pakhandi sadhs he has taken vindictive action. There is nothing panthic about what Vedanti has done. In fact he has gone against the glorious traditions of the Akal Takht by getting involved in political manouvering by Badal and co (remember the Sarna case a few months ago).

Leaving aside the sick actions of Kala, we need to look at why he was excommunicated. All the SGPC wale and Jathedar of the Akal Takht should have resigned. Kala Afghana sent his books for approval and all these people read a few pages and said everything was fine. They were complicit in the books being published. They have no oral authority to contie in office. Vedanti himself co-authored a book which he later had to ban as it was full of lies.