Jump to content

NaamTiharoJoJape

Members
  • Content Count

    218
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Everything posted by NaamTiharoJoJape

  1. hmm I sent a message thanking you but topic moderators don't let me release stuff as fast but its been almost three hours now anyhow, appreciate your feedback, the reason for my sankoch and caution on this matter is primarily because there isn't any historical reference to someone doing rehraas with full anand sahib, not even nihang singhs one of my friends said bhai mani singh gutka sahib might have done it that way but he isn't too sure, and I thought taksali nitnem was based off of bhai mani singh ji and akali baba deep singh ji's gutka sahibs so I'm not sure why they would deviat
  2. wasn't steve scalise shot at by a deranged bernie fan again, nothing to do with bernie or politics, deranged is deranged lol
  3. how are tarna dal and budha dal gutka sahib different?
  4. appreciate the work the reason for my sankoch and caution on this matter is primarily because there isn't any historical reference to someone doing rehraas with full anand sahib, not even nihang singhs one of my friends said bhai mani singh gutka sahib might have done it that way but he isn't too sure, and I thought taksali nitnem was based off of bhai mani singh ji and akali baba deep singh ji's gutka sahibs I have found only one example of a sikh doing this (9) Sri Rehras Sahib with Anand Sahib (40 Pauria) - Giani Mahinder Singh "Khalsa Ji" at Home Dudley - YouTube
  5. yes, bhai jugraj singh said some valuable things when he gets to the dasam bani part of rehraas that katha playlist is a rattan we have of him
  6. I have said before, mental health plays a big part in this the shastar is there, but the person's dimaagi santulant is the x factor often colorado I believe had plenty of regulations dems wanted, but the boulder shooting occured nonetheless unfortunately there is no count of rapes, abuses, murders/homicides prevented with weapons and evidently more people are killed with blunt objects, and in the urban hoods where all these regulations are in place, crime is super high and people are often too regulated to access a gun when living in such dangerous places I am current
  7. waheguru ji there are examples of both but yeah, white young mentally challenged male is usually the factor in these instances, and often they are sjw and many a times MAGA crackheads lol
  8. its the effect of mental health detoriation here in the states waheguru jio lot of these shootings are either woke sjw liberal college students, or veterans suffering ptsd, and many others suffering from mental health issues
  9. Yeah I have done it a few times that way careless of what people thought, and I don't know either how it can be bad but apparently some folks believe it to be manmat to be adding bani onto rehraas
  10. what confuses me sometimes is how the dynamic of guru panth co-existing with guru granth sahib pardhaan shabad I hope someone can help me understand that a bit more as well
  11. but yes, even all nihang dal singhs I have heard of and from agree that nirmala panth was established by guru sahiban (I can't comment on that sakhi to be frank) I am not sure if guru sahib instructed them to partake in amrit di daat, khande bata di pahul but I would assume so (not much historical source to back my claim I admit) nirmalay were an important ang of the broad nanakpanth and very important to parchar, but I guess since they were mostly doing parchar in eastern lands of hindus (and centers of brahmanism with haridwar, benares, and holy ganga, etc.) they slowly conformed
  12. intrigued but taksal is sort of influenced by nirmala tradition in past century or so it is the modern day nirmalay who have become accustomed to bipran ki reet but there are still virle kathavachik like swami ram singh or balbir singh seechewal activist and many even become amritdhari same goes for naamdhari sikhs with some sense who do not regard baba raam singh ji as a dehdhari guru modern day taksali would have been considered nirmalay back in 1700s as they have taken the mantle of parchaar back in the day, taksal and tarna dal/nihang khalsey would be indistingu
  13. hanji but the longer versions have more dasam bani, none of the versions incorporate the full anand sahib It just feels weird to skip so much of it, so I am not sure whether it would be beadbi somehow for me recite the full anand sahib instead of the "chhota anand sahib" dhanvaad for feedback
  14. dasvandh of our swaas is a very good idea ji have you seen one of bhai jagraj singh BoS's last videos on every nitnem bani having a friend to go along with it
  15. I was wondering if it is okay for me to recite the full anand sahib within rehraas sahib?
  16. 1Anonymous1 so bhai sahib, you agree with the nihang singh side of this? we are lucky enough to have some singhs in dals still alive from the 30s and 40s and 50s if not those times, so research and preservation of the dal's side of the history is atiant jaruri. I feel like this event is central to the broad traditionalist vs. reformist schism throughout history which has been as llight as mutual respect between Akali Phula Singh ji and Maharaja Ranjit Singh, and as raging as singh sabha movements of Amritsar and Lahore, to the eroded history between Baba Binod Singh/tat khalsa a
  17. Waheguru ji, this might be my first question on here, but I always feel weird skipping 85% of Anand Sahib during rehraas. Is it okay to include those 34 pauris when I do rehraas? (I have done this a few times before). I am aware that several sampardayi include more and more dasam bani, but chhota anand sahib is something every dal and sampardayi agrees on (as far as this agianee is aware of) so I am not sure whether it is okay for me to bring this up or do on a personal basis either.
  18. I am confused, this is a underrated event in history where Jathedar Baba Sahib Singh ji Kaladhari was kicked out of Sri Akal Thakt by SGPC, there are so many accounts of it.He is said to have been ousted with Kartar Singh Chibbar and SGPC using bibian to abuse him and he is said to have been hurt badly. The SGPC have a totally different account of them being intoxicated and taking over Akal Thakt even other Nihang jathedbanian joining in. Who were the baddies? And is it true Baba Sahib Singh Ji support shastar puja and that's why there were differences between him and SGPC? What contributions
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use