Vegetarians

[GuruDaJeet]

I dont eat meat becuase i think it is wrong to kill an animal and eat its flesh, and expecially in these times where they breed animals just to eat.

My question is if I want to get a dog, can i feed it meat?

If I can then I am supporting meat right?

If I cant then what about the other animals, like lions and tigers. Should we stop them or leave them? Can those animals even survive without meat? Where do the meat eating animals stand in all this??

Can i be healty without eating meat and any kind of vitamin or supplement.

If not then isn't man suppose to eat meat?

@

I know I sound very confused because I dont eat meat, but still argue points for the meat-eaters, but this is what people ask.

[soldier_khalistani]

paji i am veggie the rest of me family except me mum all eat meat, i have a dog i feed it meat cos thats thier diet. and yes you can stay healthy even without eating meat i also body build and use no supplements and i still out do all the rest who eat meat and take supplements strenght wise :TH: . and i find i recover much more quicly from things like cuts, bruses, wounds etc than my meat eating friends . from a moral point of view i dont eat meat cos its cruel to animals and its not as though we dont have anyfink else to live on. i dont really know where meat eating animals stand its mother nature let them survive on thier natural diets.

[Khalsa4ever]

Waheguroo jee ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!

Waheguroo made dogs carnivores, so thats who they are!

For us, we were given the blessing of choice: we can eat whatever we want, and so the best choice for us (and the choice promoted by Sikhism) is vegitarianism.

Waheguroo jee ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!

[randip singh]

Waheguroo jee ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!

Waheguroo made dogs carnivores, so thats who they are!

95437[/snapback]

RIGHT! 100%

For us, we were given the blessing of choice: we can eat whatever we want, and so the best choice for us (and the choice promoted by Sikhism) is vegitarianism.

Waheguroo jee ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!

95437[/snapback]

WRONG! 100% - Sikhism does not promote that choice.

PS Admin. Can we get rid of all these stupid Vegetarian vs Meat Posts.

Thanks

[Khalsa_starr]

PS Admin. Can we get rid of all these stupid Vegetarian vs Meat Posts.

Thanks

95772[/snapback]

PS Khalsa Starr: there are others who need to know about this. We don't need a debate, but we do need to know the facts.

[Gupt daasan daas]

guru jes bird went hinting for animals

watever the body needs it needs

a dog needs meat

thas was best for it

thas how its designed

the main rason meat isnt eaten is its effect on bhagthi

wat bhagthis a dog gonna do

?

sall gud, go ahead and feed it

bhula chuak maf

[kurtas]

This very same topic has been discussed on Tapoban (I think it was the same poster).

Some copy and pasting from the Tapoban posts.

>>The Akal Takht Jathedar Sandhu Singh Bhaura issued a hukumnama dated February 15th 1980 that Gursikhs can eat meat as long as it is jhatka meat and that eating meat does not go against the code of conduct, Kurehit, of the Sikhs. Thus a Sikh cannot be excommunicated for eating meat.

So there is a Hukumnama which makes the issue quite clear as far as Sikhs go.

Maybe we need to contact the Akal Takht and see what the situation is with regards to animals kept by Sikhs i.e. does the ban on Halal apply to animals as well. Of cause we could just use our common sense else next we will have someone posting a thread about their German Shepard dog mating with next door neighbours Japanese Akita etc etc and if this is ok or wrong.

The veggie lobby are going to tell you dogs are omnivores so can survive on veggie food. Then there is the carnivore lobby who will say give it meat.

I have seen dog sin the wild and they certainly do not eat vegetables. They hunt prey and eat meat as such I would back the carnivore lobby.

[Pheena]

For us, we were given the blessing of choice: we can eat whatever we want, and so the best choice for us (and the choice promoted by Sikhism) is vegitarianism.

Waheguroo jee ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!

95437[/snapback]

WRONG! 100% - Sikhism does not promote that choice.

PS Admin. Can we get rid of all these stupid Vegetarian vs Meat Posts.

Thanks

re-read his post again veer, you just said Sikhism does not promote the choice of being a vegitarian.

and NO this does not need to be locked. If this is discussed in a Civil, Mature manner there is no need to lock this topic. Just because its 'controversial' does not mean it does not need to be discussed. We broaden our level of knowledge because we DO discuss such topics.

Mods should MODERATE such topic and delete the unnecessary posts (attacks, abusive language etc.)

[randip singh]

re-read his post again veer,  you just said Sikhism does not promote the choice of being a vegitarian. 

and NO this does not need to be locked.  If this is discussed in a Civil, Mature manner there is no need to lock this topic.  Just because its 'controversial' does not mean it does not need to be discussed.  We broaden our level of knowledge because we DO discuss such topics.

Mods should MODERATE such topic and delete the unnecessary posts (attacks, abusive language etc.)

95900[/snapback]

Hi Bro..........I for one am tired of this debate.........

Sikhism does NOT promote Vegetarianism..............it does NOT promote Meat Eating.........

The rest I leave for you to figure out

[Pheena]

Hi Bro..........I for one am tired of this debate.........

Sikhism does NOT promote Vegetarianism..............it does NOT promote Meat Eating.........

The rest I leave for you to figure out

95937[/snapback]

i think i see now what you were trying to say.