Gurbax Singh Kala Afghana!

[Surajsingh]

Do you think Gurbax Singh Kala afghana wrote all his books? Does he has any previous experience of writing religious books? It just makes me curious that how all of sudden he came up with gigantic work in very short period of time. Does anyone on this forum knows his background and if he was involved in religious scholarship?

[singhmota]

It seems Kala was helped by sikh missionaries as ghagha is also doing same parchar.

posibly some comrades also wrote some sections as you find all typical comrade style logic and questioning in those books

[Surajsingh]

Yes his writings are highly influenced with comrade bias. It can't be his own work and definitly someone else helped him on large scale. I think this is the reason he avoids open debates.

[akjforever]

http://panthkhalsa.org/kala/kala.php

http://www.khalsaalliance.org/index.php?pa...&article=12