Meat, Sikhi, And Common Sense

[Khalsa4ever]

Meat, sikhi, and common sense

http://khalsa4ever.blogspot.com/2007/03/me...mmon-sense.html

One of the topics that I hear a lot from sikh youth these days questions the concept of meat. There are a few general questions that always come up:

1. Why can't we eat meat?
   
2. Plants are living too, why can we eat them?
   
3. What about eggs? What about fish? Insects? Mushrooms?
   

The problem is, that a lot of us don't understand the fundamental concepts behind sikhi, and so we don't understand how and why our rehat is important. I myself, have started by following what I was taught, and worked backwords to try to understand some of the reasons behind it. Here are my thoughts:

So why can't we eat meat?

As raj_karega_khalsa put it: "We dont refrain from eating meat for 'non-violent' reasons or something or because something is being killed. We refrain from eating meat for merciful reasons." Its wrong to cause pain. Simple. As much as we can try, all animals suffer when they are put down, especially in our modern slaughter house facilities. The halal preparation of meat is especially prone to causing pain. Killing a cow is just as bad as a chicken, a pig, or anything else that we term as "edible".

So the answer is simple: As a vegetarian, I don't eat anything with a nervous system. Why? Because the nervous system allows an animal/person to feel pain. Its the beginnings of consciousness. So cows? They can feel pain. Insects? They can feel pain too. Fish? Same thing. Celery? No nervous system, so bring it on!

This is important also because fungi, which are evolutionarily closer to animals than plants, are usually considered a vegetarian product for this very same reason.

But can't plants feel pain?

Plants can react to stimuli (like light, heat, etc.), but they can't feel pain, because they don't have nerves (which pick up pain signals) or a 'brain' (that can process those signals). Others reasons that people give for vegetarianism, saying that fruits and vegetables can regenerate are simply not true as things like carrots, yams, radishes, when eaten, destroy the plant.

So again, its a common-sense model of sikhi: mercy is a fundamental concept that is enshrined in sikhi, from our concept of vegetarianism to our kirpan which means literally "to allow mercy".

[Balait_da_Sher]

As you know very well that Meat discussion is not allowed on Sikhsangat, still however i am going to leave this topic here for information purposes. Any one wishing to discuss this should go on the blog and discuss it there.

[Guest Narinder Singh]

Where's the "mercy" when it comes to making tablas that we use in our gurdwareh, wearing shoes on our feet, wearings belts and sitting on leather sofas? The list goes on and on.

I guess this whole "wrong to cause pain" jargon only applies to 'eating' flesh, that makes a lot of sense! :wub:

Fateh.