Mahraaj

[god is great]

Fateh ji

Just wanted sangats views. When we take mahraaj somewhere is it important to have 5 Singhs or can it be 5 Amritdharis?

Fateh

[Sarbat da Pala]

If you go somewhere you need Guru Roop Panj Pyaare ( 5 Singhs)

[Guest Kizarny]

<br />

If you go somewhere you need Guru Roop Panj Pyaare ( 5 Singhs)

<br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br />What about women!? I am sick of singhs doing everything. Get some damn equality in sikhi!

[Harjeet.Singh]

<br />

If you go somewhere you need Guru Roop Panj Pyaare ( 5 Singhs)

<br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br />What about women!? I am sick of singhs doing everything. Get some damn equality in sikhi!

There is an explanation for this....

[SarabhaPanjab]

Punj Pyaare have to be Singhs. its not inequality its just the way it happened.

[Singhstah]

panj can be man or woman, jeevan that matters.

[Sarbat da Pala]

panj can be man or woman, jeevan that matters.

Well Man and Woman are similare but not equal. To have or to make a good jiwan is important for both. But Jiwan makes you not a Singh or a Kaur. Even if you do an operation to convert to the other gender you will allways be that what god made you. If women could do the same thing as men or men could do the same thing as women, then Guru Sahib ji would just creat only "Singh" in my opinion, because they could do the same things...

From Kudrat (nature) there are different tasks for men and women. 5 Pyaare (Not 5 Pyaarian) This is a Maryada made by Guru Gobind Singh ji. Even the thing to do Kirtan in Harmandir Sahib. Since Guru Sahib ji made Harmandir Sahib, in that time of Guru Sahib ji it never happend, that Women are doing sewa there. They did somewhere else but not in Harmandir Sahib. Same as for Amritsanchar. It never happend during the time of Guru Gobind Singh ji and after it. Only nowdays... Didn't we have Chardikala women on that time who could do sewa? Mata Sahib Kaur, Mai Bhago ji or others why it never happened?

Or for Harmandir Sahib Mata Ganga ji she was the Mahan wife of Guru Arjan Dev ji. If she haven't done sewa like this why should we demand theses days?

It's Guru Roop Panj Pyaare, Panj Singh and not panj pyaariaan or panj "Singhnia"

Women have a bigger task in the Panth given by Guru Sahib ji...

Benti to let the Maryada be as Guru Sahib ji made it

bhul chuk maaf karne ji wjkk wjkf ji

[Matheen]

For taking Guru Sahib somewhere, 5 Singhs or Singhnia is ok. Amrit sanchaar is a different matter.