Historical Evidence For Dasam Granth

[Trying to be Khalsa]

http://sikh-reality....sam-granth.html

Bhul chuk maaf . I dont want to sound offensive or insulting ....

This is not correct in my opinion . No granth can be kept aside Guru Granth Sahib ji maharaj .

And dasam granth is dasam granth sahib only . Not Guru Dasam granth .

Guru Gobind Singh jee gave gurgaddi to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee only .

They are creating more confusions .

Guru Nanak dev ji is saying in aarti shabad that "Gagan mei thaal rav chand deepak bane .... ...."

Then , how can we follow bahmanwaad .

Are we sikhs or poojaris ? doing aarti with lamp and thaal ?

REMEMBER , Guru Gobind Singh jee has said

" Jab lag khalsa rahe nyaara , tab lag tej diyo mei saara .

Jab eh gaye Bipran ki reet . Tab mei na inki karo parteet ."

We have to respect and consider Sri Dasam granth because most of banis in it is indeed by Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaj .

3 banis out of our daily 5 banis of nitnem is from dasam granth sahib .

But , who are we to add "guru" to dasam granth . Are we clever than Guru Gobind Singh jee ?

BHUL CHUK MAAF !!

[SunSingh]

The confusion, veerji, is there b/c you are judging without understanding.

btw, Dasam Guru ka Granth Sahib was the original title, and some people shortened it to Dasam Guru Granth. I think they should not, as it creates confusion and plays into the hands of the propagandaists.

[hkaurP]

http://sikh-reality....sam-granth.html

Bhul chuk maaf . I dont want to sound offensive or insulting ....

This is not correct in my opinion . No granth can be kept aside Guru Granth Sahib ji maharaj .

And dasam granth is dasam granth sahib only . Not Guru Dasam granth .

Guru Gobind Singh jee gave gurgaddi to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee only .

They are creating more confusions .

Guru Nanak dev ji is saying in aarti shabad that "Gagan mei thaal rav chand deepak bane .... ...."

Then , how can we follow bahmanwaad .

Are we sikhs or poojaris ? doing aarti with lamp and thaal ?

REMEMBER , Guru Gobind Singh jee has said

" Jab lag khalsa rahe nyaara , tab lag tej diyo mei saara .

Jab eh gaye Bipran ki reet . Tab mei na inki karo parteet ."

We have to respect and consider Sri Dasam granth because most of banis in it is indeed by Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaj .

3 banis out of our daily 5 banis of nitnem is from dasam granth sahib .

But , who are we to add "guru" to dasam granth . Are we clever than Guru Gobind Singh jee ?

BHUL CHUK MAAF !!

Veerji this is exactly my point. I wanted to say this. But I just didnt have enough resources to back it up so I didn't.