Jump to content

Bhia Bala Not In Purtan Janamsakhi


Recommended Posts

Sadh Sangat Jee,

Scholars have said the Bhai Bala Janamsakhi is a fabrication and was actually created after Guru Gobind Singh Ji's time.

Bhai Gurdas has left out mentioning him.

Refer to Karam Singh's conclusions in "Kartik or Baisakh" -

  • Historical places are called by their new(later) names.
  • Shabads that were revealed later(of Sri Guru Amardas Ji and Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji) are used(when the Janamsakhi is said to be have written before)
  • It talks about the Masand system(which was introduced later by Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji)
  • The Khalsa Fateh is used

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are lots of fors and against. Alot of people make such a mentions as to the works of Bhai Gurdas Not having his name within it. Depends who is translating them as Bhai Vir Singh and Bhai Hazara Singh mention Bhai Bala Ji. Just because Bhai Bala Ji might not be mentioned in the vaars does not make him a mythical person. Bhai Sahib did not cover certain events or things or contain the names of every individual linked to th Gurus.

Can you metion which vaar does bhia gurdas mentions bhia bala ji's name that would change everything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you metion which vaar does bhia gurdas mentions bhia bala ji's name that would change everything.

Here is link in which Sant Hari Singh Randhawe wale clears all misconceptions abt Bhai Bala Ji

I would recomend everyone to watch this entire debate but if someone wants to listen to Bhai Bala Ji explanation, skip to 15:40

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sadh Sangat Jee,

Exactly, there are many things for it and many against it(Bala Janamsakhi).

Bhai Bala may well have existed, but the Janamsakhi has many things that are clearly wrong.

Even Kavi Santokh Singh said he felt it(Bala Janamsakhi) was corrupted by the Hindalis.

The late Prof. Sahib Singh talks about Janamsakhis here -

ADI BIRH BARAI - Puratan Janamsakhi

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scholars have said the Bhai Bala Janamsakhi is a fabrication and was actually created after Guru Gobind Singh Ji's time.

These are prob scholars of the missionary college, who may have seen aline or 2 that they couldnt understand, and hence label it as fabrication. The best thing to do is to read it for yourslef and see how you feel. You like it read it again! You dont like it dont!. Job done.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • There is nothing wrong with starched pagg. The Guru is omniscient (all-knowing). You think he doesn't know our intentions? If somebody wears a starched pagg but still respects it as a crown then whats wrong with that? People think that starch automatically makes people lose their respect for their pagg but thats just false.  And dont make this a caste thing I’m Rajput Jatt sikh (not an ounce of Tarkhan or anything else) and we all starch our INDIAN style punjabi paggs (patiala shahi), but respect them as our crowns and our literal lives. A respected starch pagg is better by far than a freshly tied one which people just disrespect. And people forget that these are not ready made or pre-tied turbans. You still tie them initially but just of course not as frequently. What’s wrong with that?  When your relationship is that strong with the Guru then you know what he means. Speak to him directly, explain why and ask him if it’s okay. Btw I know people who dont starch their turbans (all punjabi/morni style btw) and they just wear it again the next day without tying it if they have toed it really nicely the day before. 😂 You cant really even tell who had tied it and who just wore it again without starch. At least we’re open about it. Bhul chuk maaf    
    • Its called a “fifty” becuase when Singhs were fighting in the British army, they would recieve an 8 metre pagg, with a cour four base, because the base layer was half (50%) of the main turban, it’s called a fifty. The practise of tying a keski under your main one is now seen as pretty weird (except for a patka), but the small coloured strip inder the pagg is still used as a fashion statement since its pretty visually appealing. And so, people now just tie a small little “kung-fu strip” sort of thing under their pagg to imitate that effect.
    • Found how to do it. For anybody else wondering, heres how. No one even helped me btw. So much for Guru Ji’s lhalsa always ready to help (and having their Singhs’ backs smh). (Notes: Aim to do this on a hot summer’s day, and dedicate a full day to this, since you only have to do this once every 4 months at least (normally the turban will stay in shape until you wish to untie it and physically pull it open again). This helps it to dry faster, since you have to starch it, HALF DRY IT, pooni it, tie it and then wear it for around four hours for the rest of it to dry, all in the same day. It’s a one day process but it serves you for months). This works for both the UK/Kenyan style (starch is best for this style) as well as the normal Punjabi paghs (such as Patiala shahi, wattan wali and morni paghs). Not sure about dumallas though. Probably not . Pagg Starch: 1) Boil 6 cups of water in a saucepan on low heat (always low heat) 2) Seperately dissolve 4 tablespoons of maida (all purpose flower) with a little water until it is 100% smooth.  You could also use rice or corn starch. Add more water if it is not a smooth liquid 3) Once completely smooth, pour this mixture through a strainer (to make it even smoother) into the boiling water. 4) Now continuously stir it until it goes completely see through. Keep on stirring it on the low heat until it goes totally transparent (it can take a little while to cook, but the pagg will last you for months!) It will at become a thick paste first, but keep stirring until it becomes see through and thinner.    5) Once it’s transparent, pour the starch (again through a strainer) into a big enough, clean bucket to cool down. 6) Once cool, take a clean, dry turban and completely and mix it in with the starch for around 5 minutes. Make sure that it is all evenly and completely soaked and wet with the starch. (Most people use mal-mal material, but I use full voile and I have used Rubia too. They’re all fine. Maybe use Rubin for smaller turbans and mal mal for larger ones) 7) Leave it out in the sun to HALF DRY ONLY!!!!!!! (Don’t ever let your starched turban fully dry before you tie it. If you do, then you will have to spray/ sprinkle water on it which will weaken the starch and ruin the turban) ONLY HALF DRY THE TURBAN IN THE SUN!!! 😎 Once HALF DRY ONLY take the now semi damp turban, and fold/pooni and then tie it like normal (straight on your head, with no base layer such as a Keski or patka underneath). Leave it on your head for around 4 hours just to fully dry and it will be ready and set for months now. Like I said, do try to tie your dastar every day, but if you can’t or really don’t want to, I hope this helps! Like I said this works on both the traditional Punjabi/Indian style paggs, and the more recent UK/Kenyan style paggs. It does for my morni pagg, but the first larr slips up in to the pagg. This is normal dw. Wjkk, Wjkf
    • I guess easier ways of learning have taken precedence. There are so many Youtube channels and podcasts available that people are more ready to listen for knowledge at their own leisure. There are so many great kathas available online that take months to listen, so that people may not really get the time to come here and write.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use