Complete Ghagga Discussion Online Now

[akjforever]

http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2816/2006-10-11.html

[Guest PRITAM SINGH KHALSA]

I need it translated

[Akaali]

Firstly, Ghagga isnt really willing to change his views, and guru sahib tells us in asa di vaar, moorkhe naal na lujhiye, it comes back to us so many times, and he also says vaad virodh salaahne vaade aavan jaan, they claim to talk and glorify their disputes but they have no clue and wander in reincarnation. Like one of this singhs said, if Ghagga isnt willing to change his views, he should not be able to sit on stage and do parchaar, theres cant be a compromise in some of his views.

[Surajsingh]

It doesn't matter if he changes his views or not but it should not stop us from refuting his wrong views.

[Akaali]

I'm sorry, did I say we shouldn't refute his wrong views?

[Manjot_13]

Ghagga is a con artist. He tells people these false things because he has no clue himself as to what he's saying. He's stupid and should change his veiws or not be allowed to kaatha or parchar.

:D :D

[randip singh]

The article said he looked nervous and his hands were perpiriing....he looked very calm to me......is this the same debate reported in "Panthic" Weekly?

[Hardeep__singh]

Yeh....I didnt see him heavily sweating or anything..ok he did wipe his face a few times...but nothing much..it was a very good debate with out any physical violence....this is what you call a debate....this proving GHAGGA GHUGGU was wrong. :TH:

[Bhujangan]

THe debate in Panthic Weekly's first article was the first debate. That one was not recorded. THis is the follow up debate to that one.

[Surajsingh]

I request everyone to not involve into slandering Sardar Inder Singh Ghagga. He may have hurt sentiments with his book but still he is well educated and Sikh at the end. We should allow free debates and give people chance to improve themselves. We are not following extremists Islam but tolerant Sikh path, so lets keep the difference. He should be challenged more and more not just him but others who have written books like him.

Can someone bring his book online in PDF format?