Help Review This Sikhiwiki Page

[UKGupt Kaur]

Sangat Jio please help review this link for a friend.

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Guru_Nanak_in_Mecca

p/s: she did not write it. she just thinks there is something wrong in the information.

[S1ngh]

On that website.. It should read out as Guru Nanak Dev Ji instead of just "Guru Nanak"

SikhiWiki is very cool and visitor controlled.. So change it once you get time.

[Shaheed_Fauja]

now THIS is interesting!!

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Guru_Na...Mecca_was_Vedic

[B4ND4]

I haven't read the whole article but these lines don't seem right to me.

He had travelled so long and so far, but he was not yet satisfied. He now decided to go towards the west. His aim was to visit Muslim countries. He wanted to visit also, the Muslim mosques in those countries. He chose Mecca as the first such place to visit. Mecca is in Saudi Arabia. It contains the most sacred Muslim mosque called the "Kaaba" or the House of God. A visit to Mecca by a Muslim is called hajj. A Muslim visitor to Mecca is called a hajji. Guru Nanak decided to go on hajj.

That shows Guru Ji as muslim. Doesn't it :D ?

[Shaheed_Fauja]

Thus, Nanak dressed in Neela Bana: Neel Bastar lai kaprey pahirey, Turk -pathani amal kiya (adorned navy-blue dress adopting Turki form). Later, as the Tenth Nanak (Guru Gobind Singh), discarded it by saying: Neel bastar lai kaprey faare, Turk pathani amal giya (adorned blue-attire torn, discarding the Turk Pathani form). Out of this form the NIHANG sect originated.

now what part of gurbani that comes from?!

asa di //:

nIl bsqR ly kpVy pihry qurk pTwxI Amlu kIAw ]

[randip singh]

Sangat Jio please help review this link for a friend.

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Guru_Nanak_in_Mecca

p/s: she did not write it. she just thinks there is something wrong in the information.

Hmm. sikhiwiki is a good site is you agree with the doctrines of the 3HO and GNNSJ cult views. If you disagree with them you will be edited.

Poor site to be avoided at all costs by anyone actually interested in Sikh History.