Bhai Surinder Singh Ji Sodhi

[10th regiment]

i dont think hes biased inherently, he may be biased due to lies fed to him by the government

im not wholly sure about him, but since he was born and bred in india, he is likely to have an attachement to india as a whole and so maybe biased against khalistan but not sikhs as a people

i have listened to the bbc programmes and there is a degree of untruth in it

[sher-e-panjab]

a degree of truth? from what i hear in his programes its him just putting together a lot of propaganda against sikhs then adding one or 2 facts in favour of sikhs so that he doesnt appear to be biased.

also when you make programmes about operation bluestar u dont jus go on what the government tells u, u need to go deep to find out ther real truth, ll he does is get goverment statistics and presents them.

[10th regiment]

untruth i said!

but one has to remember he is going to be fed by the government, they wouldnt allow him to do a pro khalistan broadcast

and also he has to give both sides of the story as that is what journalism is about and also any broadcast has a degree of subjectivity based on the authors views about it so i dont think we can be too harsh on him

i dont think its realistic to expect him to do a pro khalistan braodcast based on his previous background and his books

[Balwinder Singh]

Sant Bhindranwalee ji's character was of highest order.He cannot do the thing u (10th regiment veer ji)wrote.This is a pure lie.Tully book is very very biased.He tried to prove that Indra was not against sikhs.He showed Indra in a very positive light.

Tully does tell the story of sodhi ji but I dont think he mentions the "br**st" thing anywhere.In his story he himself mentioned that sant ji was very strong at character.

[10th regiment]

im not saying sant ji did the killing etc but he did order it and was happy about it

read tullys book, amrtisar, mrs gandhu last battle

pages 131 and 132 and 133

they outline what i have just said

surinder singh aka shinda was the one who killed sodhi with his girlfiriend baljit kaur along with malik singh bhatia who was killed as well

tullys says and i quote : her breasts had been cut off and she had been tortured'

p133 2nd paragrpah

im not sure if it true, tully wrote it thats all

[Guest r k]

I've also heard bad things about "Tully." Do you have any other actual evidence of what you're saying? There's no point in giving information like that unless you're sure it's true, right ji? :wub:

you said Surinder Singh Sodhi was killed

due to jealousy or government funding, that is unclear

Are you aware veerji that Surinder Singh Sodhi was a maha pursh?... He was like a Brahm Giani... He was more than a Soorma. "Jealousy" is out of the question, veerjee, pleeease don't disrespect Sodhi and lay false accusations on him <_<

[SSB]

yeh man! he is a mahaan shaheed dont disrespct him and i've never heard of tully ?

[10th regiment]

first of all where have i disrespected sodhi ji??????????

do u people actually read my posts in context or do u just assume i am disrespecting??

evidence of what exactly>??? i quoted from his book, which is world famous

do some reading mate

i said sodhi ji was killed due to jealousy or givernment ie gurbabchana gen sec of the sgpc had him killed due to jealousy on his part

man some of u people are so poorly read on khalistan, its shocking

cant believe u just said who is tully>?!!!!

[sher-e-panjab]

singh the reason others dont know about tully is cause not all of them live in UK, and tully's book, its not exactly the most reliable source is it

[SSB]

10th regiment i will ask for mafi as i made a mistake while readin ur post and the tully fing i 've never heard of it :wub:: but som of the stuff u've written that is in the book looks real biased