Makkar,Jathedars,Jathedar Damdami Taksal Atttend Funeral Of Surinder Kaur Badal

[Only five]

You are comparing apples and oranges here... anyway got one perfect example of bhai ghaniya ji feeding the enemies, bandaging them on the battlefield...here we got an dead woman who probably died of her karams (it just show no one is immune from karam and lekh),...also this is an woman who not in the battle field nor she declare an war against panth but indirectly harm the panth because of badal influence on her,,, so going to her funeral is understandable just like how gyani thakur singh ji patialawale (student of sant kartar singh bhindranwale) went to rulda rss dude funeral asking for sarbat da bhalla...if bhai ghaniya ji didn't gave up his gyan of sarbat da bhalla towards enemy in the battle field then why should we?. Sikhi is more than just following bunch of ultra orthodox youths running around on here or on panthic.org making an issue of nothing.

Its not comparing apples and oranges. Actually with your Bhai Ghaniya ji example you just said Sant ji didn't have the concept of sarbat da bhalla down. Your saying Bhai Ghaniya ji helped the enemy afterwards and Sant ji didn't even have the decency to attend the funeral of the Khalsa Panth enemy. Did Sant Nihal Singh ji attend the funeral of Indira Gandhi? Did Sant Baba Thakur Singh ji attend Indira Gandhi funeral? I guess they don't have the concept of sarbat da bhalla down like Bhai Ghaniya ji did.

YOu have no place saying this woman did nothing wrong. What makes this womans funeral so important for Harnam Singh to attend. If they didn't attend for Badal, then shes just like every other woman in the world, but Harnam Singh doesn't attend the other woman funerals.

[Only five]

It is reported that mukhi taksal went there but did anyone ask him did he went there representing jatha or went there as a human being?

First of all Dhumma is not the mukhi of Taksal. But if he was then he could never put that title aside and be just a human being. Once a person is given a title like mukhi of Taksal then it's with you until the person passes it on to the next person. Being the mukhi of taksal is not a job, where you take the uniform off at the end of the day and put on regular clothing. Its all day, all week, and all year around position where sangat gives the Jathedar respect because they follow Gurmat all day, all week, and all year around. Lastly if he went as a human being then he should take off the 5 Kakkar and dastaar before he goes. Only Sikhs wear the 5 kakkar with dastaar.

[zoltansingh]

At least some people are opening their eyes now. I was reading old posts on the forum and came across several which pointed to the fact that Dhumma was a tool for the Badals, someone should link to the videos and interviews he did after the Ludhiana killing (ashutosh). He clearly claimed he would take on the akali Dal. He soon changed his tune as some sort of deal was done over the calendar and Dhumma given a few sgpc committee roles. Again rode has been exposed more than once but he still has people who back him, his son has been acting like a thug in Jalandhar as his dad has akali backing.

[VanHelsingh]

Are we talking about the same Jathedars who were in the UK last week?