Waja and Tabla

[chatanga]

She said if u want to learn only to do kirtan then u dont need to learn whole classical music

Dear, as i said earlier, classical rendition is not the same as Gurmat Sangeet. It can be a part of it, whether the performer wants it to be or not.

You can sing Bani in accordance to the great tradition started by our Guru's with very simple notes(as I do).

Dont set yourself a non-existent bar.

[jasdeepsingh2k125]

Dear, as i said earlier, classical rendition is not the same as Gurmat Sangeet. It can be a part of it, whether the performer wants it to be or not.

You can sing Bani in accordance to the great tradition started by our Guru's with very simple notes(as I do).

Dont set yourself a non-existent bar.

veerji,dass obey u on the thing that guruji wrote gurbani in raags but there is no compulsion to sing bani in raags.. ok daas agree that its better to sing in raags...but singing without raags is better than not singing at all

[Gurpreet14]

Dear, as i said earlier, classical rendition is not the same as Gurmat Sangeet. It can be a part of it, whether the performer wants it to be or not.You can sing Bani in accordance to the great tradition started by our Guru's with very simple notes(as I do).Dont set yourself a non-existent bar.

Ok dear sure... Let me atleast begin from somewhere...

U do kirtan ryt... Let me have some experience I will surely ask u again wether I m on a ryt track or nt

[chatanga]

veerji,dass obey u on the thing that guruji wrote gurbani in raags but there is no compulsion to sing bani in raags.. ok daas agree that its better to sing in raags...but singing without raags is better than not singing at all

bhaji what if sikh guy with a hairstyle said, "at least i dont cut all my hair off my head, i still have some on..."

[jasdeepsingh2k125]

bhaji what if sikh guy with a hairstyle said, "at least i dont cut all my hair off my head, i still have some on..."

veerji, generalisation of things is good but it may not be correct every time.. daas is not against doing kirtan in raag but there is a beginning point..let bhenji learn some simple shabad and after that she can learn raags

[Gurpreet14]

bhaji what if sikh guy with a hairstyle said, "at least i dont cut all my hair off my head, i still have some on..."

Cutting hair is bedbi...n trying to learn some ways to utter name of lord is divine...

Kabir just use to write dohe.... He never read any holy book......

That does not mean he never uttered the lord's name

I dont want to learn that...aaaaaaa wala kirtan..... I have many other ways to make it interesting....

If required will use guitar...even babag will feel good with some difference :D

[Gurpreet14]

Hey learnt my first shabad.... Sangat g thanks for ur suggestions

Sun sajjan preetam mereya its easy to learn mission begins :D