Jump to content

The Relationship Between Sikh Religion And Sikh Ethnicity


Balkaar
 Share

Recommended Posts

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh,

The Sikh religion is self-admittedly universal. I do not believe any Sikh would disagree.

The Sikhs of the diaspora (and, it may be said, in India) have fought tooth and nail for a long time in order to be recognized as a distinct ethnic group. The argument which is used most commonly to refute this proposition is that Sikhism is a religion, theoretically open to anyone.

In order to be described as an ethnic group a people must share a common language, culture, history, religion, and geographical origin. As is currently stands we fulfill all these criteria. But if Sikhi were spread and converts to be made to such an extent that, in the future, a large proportion of of Sikhs did not trace their origins to the Punjab, speak Punjabi and did not share in the history which flows through our veins in the form of the blood of our forefathers, then we could never again advance the idea that we are an 'ethnic group' because the definition of this term would no longer apply to us. In other words, the more converts are made to the Sikh religion, the more the cause of a distinct Sikh ethnicity is undermined and undone.

Does the self determination of the Sikh people (the desire to be recognized as a separate ethnic group) conflict with the proliferation of the Sikh religion? Which of these causes do you consider to be more important? I cannot yet decide. I love our people and our traditions and the greatest way to protect the integrity of these traditions would be Sikh self-determination. But I also don't like the idea of denying the Jot of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj to the world and its people, who sorely need it in the blackness of Kaljug.

May any offence I might have caused be forgiven,

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

“Converts”. Is that what panj piare were? They gave their heads. The first to stand up and come forward? Our Guruji bowed before them. Were they “our” people? They were converts. What does that make the rest of us? Think about that for a moment.

Surely the suggestion is not that Guru Gobind Singh Ji undermined Sikh “ethnicity” at the outset? In fact, that day in 1699 is a core of Sikh ethnicity.

What does that make any who make a claim to being proud “ethnic” punjabi Sikhs? That makes them as people who challenge Guru Gobind Singh Ji with our CASTE/RACE/ETHINIC ridden mentality.

Sikhs share a common humanity. A people who see commonality as a social spiritual human experience beyond race, geography, or language. How can ethnicity get greater than a group of people who believe in a human ethnicity? Not only is that Ethnicity, it is the richest Ethnicity in the world.

Sikh punjabis are trying hard and having a massive struggle with understanding the preservation and promotion of Sikh culture. It’s a positive thing, absolutely. However, despite many who take the lead sincerely, the core drive of the masses behind that preservation is Punjabi CASTEIST, RACIST mindsets.

We may be well intentioned, but that racism is the same as the vibrant accepted western racism of decades past. We started absorbing our racism and castesim, like the rest of India, when we learned to walk and talk.

Therefore getting rid of our racism/casteism it is not a mere mental decision. A deep, deep reflection and serious challenge to our make up and our core beliefs about “cultural” identity over time is required.

The very fact that Sikhi has not already spread through the world is a black mark on us as ethnic punjabi’s who have turned Sikhi into a caste birth right. Amongst us there are Sikh warriors who walk the walk of 1699. The bulk of us punjabi’s, perhaps less on this forum, are just lighter versions of deras, fake babas, cults, sects who point to those crazier, so we feel sane and "sikh".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Jacfsing2

I guess the question I would ask is that if I were to convert to Sikhism, being a white man, would I ever be fully accepted and trusted because I was not Punjabi?

Excellent thread.

Well, I would accept you as a brother of mine. Even though you are a Christian, I would still respect you, what we don't like is insincere converts, (key word insincere).

"Recognize the whole of human race as one." Also Guru Sahib would accept you as well, just as there are some Christians who may be racist as are some Sikhs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

“Converts”. Is that what panj piare were? They gave their heads. The first to stand up and come forward? Our Guruji bowed before them. Were they “our” people? They were converts. What does that make the rest of us? Think about that for a moment.

Surely the suggestion is not that Guru Gobind Singh Ji undermined Sikh “ethnicity” at the outset? In fact, that day in 1699 is a core of Sikh ethnicity.

It may not have begun as an ethnicity in 1699, but it has become one over the course of 300 odd years. All ethnic groups have to have their beginnings somewhere, cultures and nations don't just spontaneously materialize. Sikhi didn't even start off as a distinct religion (Bhai Mardana referred to himself as a Muslim Sikh), it only became one through the centuries because of the continuous assault and persecution which necessitated a separate identity , hence the conception of Miri-Piri by Guru Hargobind Sahib, and the founding of the Khalsa by our Dashmesh Pita, among other things. Neither of these developments would have taken place if not for Mughal persecution. And without these developments, the Tisar Panth, Sikhi, would never have distinguished itself from Bhakti Hinduism or Sufi Islam.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah :) I don't get what the problem is to say your ethnicity though.. ethnicity and religion is different lol. Saying Punjabi Sikh would just mean a Sikh from Punjab, or would it be better to say (for example your name) balkaar Sikh Punjab wala/wali :p

Lol as much as I like that title I don't suppose I would actually adopt it.

That's exactly the sort of thing I wanted to understand in posting this question. Is the Sikh ethnicity separate from the Sikh religion, or is it one and the same? Does the Sikh ethnicity, if there is one, really matter when compared to our sacred duty to spread the Jot of Guru Nanak to all corners of the Earth? I can't say that any of my doubts have been allayed just yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think as Sikhs we are seen as one community, but what's wrong with saying where your genes are from right?

I agree entirely, I can't sympathize with this insistence by some Sikhs that for me to even say that I am of a certain racial descent, that I am of Jatt descent for instance, is anathema to the principles of Sikhi and that I am a casteist fool at the root of all Sikhi's problems for speaking thusly. I don't think my being of Jatt ancestry makes me better than anyone else, its whats written in my genes, it cannot be changed.

I guess the question I would ask is that if I were to convert to Sikhism, being a white man, would I ever be fully accepted and trusted because I was not Punjabi?

Excellent thread.

That's just the thing. The idea of denying somebody entry into the Sikh religion on the basis of their color fills me with revulsion. Sikhi IS open to all.

But on the other hand, I also do not like the idea that our traditions, many with explicitly Punjabi connotations, particularly with regards the script and poetry of our sacred scriptures, might have to be discarded in order to accommodate converts from vastly different cultures. Am I a chauvinist for thinking this way?

In India, Sikhism and Sikh traditions are routinely attacked by the establishment and by the government of India. The best way to repel their efforts would be self-determination for the Sikh people, but that will only be achieved if we can make the case to the rest of the world that we are an ethnic group and that any devolution of powers is taking place on the basis of nationhood/ethnicity. Not on the basis of religion - as with the creation of Pakistan, which should never have happened.

I am conflicted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • An update on the Gurdwara Sahib building.  please donate and forward the donation link to contacts 🙏    
    • So I wrote this thread out a few years ago, And Im going through the same same thing again, In the end I did email her it was an embarassing mess. This is how it started 5 years a go, I had a dream about her and when I woke up the first thing I said was Waheguru, I didnt feel right in my heart or my head, felt like there was somehing pulling me or not letting me sit still. Then I had another 4 dreams one day after the next. After a while I did email her, it was embaressing, a complete mess, I cant describe to you how bad it was.  I didnt tell her about the dreams it sounded weird like I was losing my mind, tbh it probably still came across like that.   In the end I knew something was not right with me, And I got up and went to India, to matha tekh at the Gurudwara, I went to see Mahapuhrsh[SP]. I showed them a photo of her, and to keep it simple they told me she didnt have a good heart. But when I saw them it felt like a huge weight was being lifted off me.  It took me about 2 years to sort of get myself back to how I was. At the time I was under a lot of pressure because I was buying a business and I had 30 day completion, and I was really stressed out, I think I had or was on the verge of a mental breakdown. Anyway time passed and then last year my dad died, he was 59 and just went instantly, spent the day with him at work, and he went home my mum was getting him food and by the time she went to tell him his food was ready he had passed away. I have found coming to terms with this very hard, I feel like he was stolen away from us. I dont understand what need there was for him to go. I know he was fed up, the world had drunk enough of his blood.  Anyway way last Friday I woke up again after having a dream about her, And again I been typing out emails, Ive deleted them because I dont want to do another round of doing my besthi. I am buying a house at the moment so I can move mum closer to me as I need to take care of her now. I am feeling the pressure, Im the only man left in my family now. I feel like its all on me, and Im going to <banned word filter activated> up everything my dad made. Basically I think somone has done something to me. I know I probably sound like Im losing my mind, and I probably am. But Im closer to the end than I am to the beginning, there not enough time left to keep making mistakes and recovering from them. I keep saying to God just tell me what you want and Ill give it to you, what ever it is I dont mind, what ever you want I will happily give to you. cant believe he wants me to commit a sin, or do something I know I shouldnt be doing.
    • So we find out who killed Hardeep Singh Nijjar. What we are going to do about it?  Me personally I try to avoid the whole Khalistan fiasco since religion and politics get mixed. That's a messy situation to be in. 
    • *bump I firmly believe that one quote in regards to cannabis is not written by Guru Nanak Dev Ji (O'lord the fear of thee). B/c nasha is nasha. But cannabis is a bit a different since it was used for medicinal purposes in India also. 
    • I feel gurdwaras are maybe somewhat getting back to their functions as dharmsalas containing schools and learning centres. With panjabi schools, gurmat classes, santhiya, martial arts, keertan training, with sikhi camps occasionally in towns, there is somewhat some functions connected to traditional gurdwaras of the past.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use