Was Muhammad A Good Logician?

[Guest Jacfsing2]

Yes it does... You've found me out. My real name isn't in fact Balkaar Singh, but Balkaar Khan.

I live in a cavernous underground lair two miles below the Ka'bah, where I sit atop a throne of Sikh skulls, and drink their blood (Halal of course) from a chalice made of melted down Nazi war gold decorated with Islamic/Satanic imagery.

And I cackle maniacally as I subvert their religion from within using the Sikhsangat forum...

In case it escapes your mental capabilities, allow me to clarify that I am being sarcastic.

My appraisal of you stands Dr_c. You are an unspeakable buffoon.

You don't have to go that far into sarcasm, it just sounds gross.

Yes it does... You've found me out. My real name isn't in fact Balkaar Singh, but Balkaar Khan.

I live in a cavernous underground lair two miles below the Ka'bah, where I sit atop a throne of Sikh skulls, and drink their blood (Halal of course) from a chalice made of melted down Nazi war gold decorated with Islamic/Satanic imagery.

And I cackle maniacally as I subvert their religion from within using the Sikhsangat forum...

In case it escapes your mental capabilities, allow me to clarify that I am being sarcastic.

My appraisal of you stands Dr_c. You are an unspeakable buffoon.

You don't have to go that far into sarcasm, it just sounds gross.

[Balkaar 1,340]

You don't have to go that far into sarcasm, it just sounds gross.

You don't have to go that far into sarcasm, it just sounds gross.

I meant no offense, I'm sorry.

[Dr_c 14]

Certainly

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/77363-quran-by-allah-jibril-or-muhammad/

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/77267-tunisia-beach-attack/

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/77275-biggest-answer-to-muslims/

I thought that went without saying. What respectable subterranean Muslim lair doesn't have its own madrassa?

So what are those posts supposed to tell me?

[Balkaar 1,340]

So what are those posts supposed to tell me?

That the likelihood of my being a secret Muslim is quite low indeed.

That said, I actually regret having taken you up on that ludicrous point at all. I allowed my pride to cloud my judgement. I don't have to justify myself to you, or dignify your silly suspicions.

[Dr_c 14]

That the likelihood of my being a secret Muslim is quite low indeed.

That said, I actually regret having taken you up on that ludicrous point at all. I allowed my pride to cloud my judgement. I don't have to justify myself to you, or dignify your silly suspicions.

Yes you don't have to justify yourself to me no more than i have to justify to you about my posting a comment on a thread where all this started from. The only difference is that unlike you and your swallowed dictionary "one" doesn't have to resort to petty name calling. Twice you called me a buffon in as many posts!. Shame on you that your manners don't equal your very cunning and clever posting styles!

Thankfully the school holidays don't last that long!

[Balkaar 1,340]

Shame on you that your manners don't equal your very cunning and clever posting styles!

Thankfully the school holidays don't last that long!

And by calling me an Islamic mole, you effectively accused me of being a liar and of not being a Sikh. This was before I ever considered being rude to you, bear in mind.

How did you expect I was going to respond to that offensive and totally unsubstantiated allegation?

We have taken up the better part of two pages with our argument. If you are determined to say anything else, I needn't remind you that you are free to PM me, otherwise, I'm not going to post again here.

[Dr_c 14]

And by calling me an Islamic mole, you effectively accused me of being a liar and of not being a Sikh. This was before I ever considered being rude to you, bear in mind.

How did you expect I was going to respond to that offensive and totally unsubstantiated allegation?

You are extremely passionate about defending your alleged status as a Sikh, are you sure there is nothing you wish to share with the sangat? I seem to have hit a raw nerve with the suggestion that perhaps (based on your very quick defence and justification of the said topic on this forum) you may be a Muslim mole. Now all of a sudden "one" has to go to extreme lengths to justify ones religious status. Of course if you were a true Sikh as "one" likes to portray "one" as, then "one" would learn that all Sikhs need to overcome the 5 vices of which Krodh (aka anger just in case you don't comprehend) is one of them.

[Dr_c 14]

We have taken up the better part of two pages with our argument. If you are determined to say anything else, I needn't remind you that you are free to PM me, otherwise, I'm not going to post again here.

If you think i would want a private conversation with you, you are so sadly mistaken.!

[MisterrSingh 5,225]

It's safe to say Balkaar Singh is a Sikh. Let's not get completely paranoid.

[Dr_c 14]

It's safe to say Balkaar Singh is a Sikh. Let's not get completely paranoid.

Would you care to enlighten us all with some support of that statement. Personally i really don't care what he is i have already made up my mind. However curiosity is getting the better of me.

[MisterrSingh 5,225]

Would you care to enlighten us all with some support of that statement. Personally i really don't care what he is i have already made up my mind. However curiosity is getting the better of me.

Call it a hunch. Blind faith.

[Kira 1,441]

Would you care to enlighten us all with some support of that statement. Personally i really don't care what he is i have already made up my mind. However curiosity is getting the better of me.

I've been having some interesting discussions with him in PM. I've not found anything remotely anti-sikh in them.

[Dr_c 14]

I've been having some interesting discussions with him in PM. I've not found anything remotely anti-sikh in them.

I've been having some interesting discussions with him in PM. I've not found anything remotely anti-sikh in them.

What’s this the Balkaar defence brigade :lol2: . Perhaps one of the Balkaar fan club could teach him some manners.

[Kira 1,441]

What’s this the Balkaar defence brigade :lol2: . Perhaps one of the Balkaar fan club could teach him some manners.

hardly lol. You claim he's not a sikh and he's getting too defensive about it. I'm sure you would have a similar response if it had been you

[Singhni MiriPiri 318]

What’s this the Balkaar defence brigade :lol2: . Perhaps one of the Balkaar fan club could teach him some manners.

Will you calm down. Balkaar Singh is a sikh and even if he wasn't so what! Get over it. You're making a clown of yourself.