Sikh videos - Intermediate

[ipledgeblue]

SO a quick question.

 

Why does the intermediate link go to a jatha based yotube page with jatha biased views?

 

Would it not be better to go towards a link like Nanak Naam which the whole sikh sangat can go to, something the whole sikh sangat can agree on instead of doing the jatha bias this website is still known for?? Gurmat Bibek youtube can be weird sometimes, and just lack any enthusiasm compared to basics of sikhi and nanak naam! Seriously why don't they smile on that channel, why is there a lack of glow on their faces that normal human beings have, I have so many questions??!! I can't take them seriously, they look they are going to cry any second!

 

Also they commit beadbi of Benti Chaupai on their channel by reading the Teja Bhasauria-cut version, cutting bani before Arril!

If they read Benti Chaupai according to an excommunciated sikh, then how can their channel be called Gurmat bibek.

Basics of sikhi and Bhai Jagraj Singh have santhiya and a higher understand of bani and gurmat. A sikh who has done santhiya will never cut out benti chaupai.

 

It clearly shows the lack of sikhi understanding and spreading manmatt on their channel, please use good judgment before posting channels as intermediate!

[GurjantGnostic]

5 hours ago, ipledgeblue said:

SO a quick question.

 

Why does the intermediate link go to a jatha based yotube page with jatha biased views?

 

Would it not be better to go towards a link like Nanak Naam which the whole sikh sangat can go to, something the whole sikh sangat can agree on instead of doing the jatha bias this website is still known for?? Gurmat Bibek youtube can be weird sometimes, and just lack any enthusiasm compared to basics of sikhi and nanak naam! Seriously why don't they smile on that channel, why is there a lack of glow on their faces that normal human beings have, I have so many questions??!! I can't take them seriously, they look they are going to cry any second!

 

Also they commit beadbi of Benti Chaupai on their channel by reading the Teja Bhasauria-cut version, cutting bani before Arril!

If they read Benti Chaupai according to an excommunciated sikh, then how can their channel be called Gurmat bibek.

Basics of sikhi and Bhai Jagraj Singh have santhiya and a higher understand of bani and gurmat. A sikh who has done santhiya will never cut out benti chaupai.

 

It clearly shows the lack of sikhi understanding and spreading manmatt on their channel, please use good judgment before posting channels as intermediate!

Those are pretty committed Sikhs bro. What on their channel is objectionable?

[ipledgeblue]

On 1/15/2021 at 6:50 PM, GurjantGnostic said:

Those are pretty committed Sikhs bro. What on their channel is objectionable?

I will just re-

 

On 1/15/2021 at 12:51 PM, ipledgeblue said:

Also they commit beadbi of Benti Chaupai on their channel by reading the Teja Bhasauria-cut version, cutting bani before Arril!

If they read Benti Chaupai according to an excommunciated sikh, then how can their channel be called Gurmat bibek.

Basics of sikhi and Bhai Jagraj Singh have santhiya and a higher understand of bani and gurmat. A sikh who has done santhiya will never cut out benti chaupai.

quote part of what I wrote.

 

Also I feel their understanding of sikhi is below basics of sikhi, whereas on the links on the forum basics of sikhi are put as basic videos, and "gurmat" bibek are put as intermediate videos but they are really focussed only inside the jatha and only talk about specific personalities, not any wide thinking nor panthic!

[GurjantGnostic]

21 minutes ago, ipledgeblue said:

I will just re-

 

quote part of what I wrote.

 

Also I feel their understanding of sikhi is below basics of sikhi, whereas on the links on the forum basics of sikhi are put as basic videos, and "gurmat" bibek are put as intermediate videos but they are really focussed only inside the jatha and only talk about specific personalities, not any wide thinking nor panthic!

Thank you bro. Wasn't sure how big the list was. 

[ipledgeblue]

1 minute ago, GurjantGnostic said:

Thank you bro. Wasn't sure how big the list was. 

I mean lack of santhiya is quite a big thing as it means their understand of bani may be limited. And just from listening to one bani on their youtube I feel I can judge they are lacking in santhiya, so again not something deserving of intermediate level on this forum.

Also since they call themselves Sarblohi Singhs, I assume they claim to follow Sarbloh bibek, which requires water to be taken from a well. Would be interesting to see if they really do this. I know that some Budha Dal Tarna Dal Singhs in Canada follow a slightly different bibek due to lack of wells.