Bbc Asian Network

[Khalsa Army]

Did u hear that pakistani guy who called in and said "Sikhs have no right to demand khalistan because sikhism has only existed for 500 years or so".

He kept sayin sikhs have no right for khalistan. Then some1 responded by asking him why was there a need for Pakistan for muslims then?

He couldnt answer back then.

Yeh what a fool. he could not even back anything up. I missed most of the show, but will listen to it on bbci player later on.

[SSB]

i think the debate went really well, the reason singh gave really good reasons using his great knowledge on the issue, and the discussion didnt go out of control which it usually on here

[warrior singh]

is there any way that i can listen to it agian? cuz i didnt even kno it was gonna come on

[Kumi2]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00fy1hd it will only be there for a few more days

[Guroo Guroo Jaap]

listenin 2 it now,

this "Gian Singh" sounds wkdddd!!! :D :D

[Trigger Happy]

Didn't the BBC have a similar debate just this April gone? or is it different?

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=36056

Maybe there will be a third, then a fourth and so on soon, because some people out there (BBC staff and certain sections of the UK public) aint getting the debate to go in their favour <_< .

What a waste of taxpayers money paying Mr Parrot to host yet another debate... you muppets . But the BBC enjoy doing that don't they...

To all those that held it down once again :vaheguru:

[Paneer Monster]

personally i feel bbc asian network is rubbish... i dont feel they represent the Sikh community at all... they raise the same old issues, sikhs and kirpans, sikhs and khalistan, the whole islamic conversion thing. afew years back a muslim girl insulted Satguroo Nanak Sahib Maharaj LIVE ON AIR AND WAS NOT CUT OFF. this says alot about the standards and tolerance levels of the show.

futhermore on their message board, generally insults towards the sikhi/ Indians / punjabi customs and (sometimes) jews are left up on display for the world to see. any posts which are not necessarily insulting but general queries or even reasonable and relevant national statistics which shows a negitive reflection on the islamic community are immediatly removed. I stoped ;listening to bbc asian network acpouple of years ago. its a total waste of time. Our Sache Guru Sahibaan have been insulted on countless occasios.

BBC asian network may have changed since then... but i doubt it. my view may be alittle out of date as like i said, i have not listened to the station / read the messageboard for some time.