Even Giani Sant Singh Maskeen Says India Is Not Our Country

[Guest AjeetSinghPunjabi]

My piece of advice :: Learn from the jews !

Jews spent 2000 years without a homeland and its just been 200 years for us

Make yourself prosper in the countries you live in , let the people know what sikhism is .

Preach sikhism to non-sikhs , something which sikhs today don't do .

and First prosper and grow in foreign countries

[KARKOOSINGH23]

what kind of principles r u talking bout .

[Only five]

Don't know where our kaum is heading to !

1.Why not try to live in real world for a while and come to senses with reality ?

2.Ask yourself one thing : Did Guru Nanak believe in creating more borders ? or were they believing in one universal place , that is why he traveled entire of middle east , china , sri lanka and bangladesh .

3.Why would he have bothered traveling out of punjab or even india ?

1. When did you become jivan mukht? Give me your address bhai sahib, i wan darshan of a jivan mukht person.

2. Yes and no, in his Bani he tells people to become his Sikhs. Also he said Raj Karega Khalsa. IN his Tenth form he gave SIkhs a distinct look and in his Tenth form he said without a soveriegn nation a religion can't survive.

3. To help your great great great great great great great brothers out in other lands and bring them in the fold of the Khalsa. OMG......he was trying to change people.........hes same as the great great great great great great great Tenth Master that gave his four sons to the Khalsa......they are all evil.....I Bhai Sahib, Mr. Sardar Ajeet Singh Punjabi am the greatest......no one can beat me

because he considered himself not as panjabi or indian , but rather as a human beyond man-made borders .

The award for the smartest politically corrupt slave goes to.................Mr. Sardar Ajeet Singh Punjabi.............his award consist of one of a kind donkey with a beautiful necklace of polished shoes.........before the donkey ride around the beautiful city for all to admire Mr. Sardar ji, the cities people will massage him with their polished shoes and give their deeply humble greetings with big fist fulls of knuckles.

Congrats Sardar ji....your truly are one of a kind to take this donkey ride.

[JSinghnz]

Excuse my ignorance but can we have a background to who giani sant singh maskeen was and what his role and contribution has been in Sikhi? I've not heard of him before but he talks sense.

Gaini Sant Singh Maskeen was a Sikh scholar par excellence.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giani_Sant_Singh_Maskeen

[Harpreet_Singh]

R U OK . DO U EVEN NO WHATS HAPEEING TO SIKHS IN INDIA . OVER 4 MILLION SIKHS DISAPPERED SINCE 84 . OUR GURDUARAS BURNED DOWN BY HINUS N MUSLIMS , SO MANY RAPES , SO MUCH BEADBI OF SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB , RSS AND HINDU TERROIST WANT TO RUIN N ELIMNATE SIKH RELIGON N U WANT TO HELP THEM . SRI GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAID WITHOUT SOVERIGNITY RELIGON WILL PERISH WE NEED LAND TO BACK UP SIKHS TO KEEP SIKHISM ALIVE TO GIVE RIGHTS TO SIKHS WE R NOT MUSLIM TERROIST THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT R TERROISTS . WE DIDNT BOMB NY PLANE THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT DID THAT N BLAMED IT ON BABAR KHALSA TO GIVE SIKHS A BAD NAME AND IDENTITY U SO CALLED SIKH U RNOT EVEN SIKH BY DOUBTING UR OWN PPL HOW R CREATING BORDERS EVEN GURU JI HAD RAJ AND MAHARAJ RANJIT SINGH HAD RAJ WE LIVE AS SLAVES TO INDIA IN THE GOVERNMENT N THEN WE HAVE SO CALLED SIKHS LIKE U THAT SO NO KAHLISTAN Y . U R NOT EDUCATED ENOUGH U R THINKING OF US LIKE SOME MUSLIM TERROISTS THAT WANT LAND . WE WANT LAND BECZ HNIDUS R EMLINATING SIKHS EVERYDAY AND DESTROYING THEIR RELIGON AND NOT LETTING SIKHS LIVETHER LIVES . WE NEED KHALISTAN EVEN SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI SAID IT ONCE HARMANDER SAHIB GETS ATTACKED THE FOUNDATION OF KHALISTAN WILL BE LAID . U WHITEWASHED SIKH U R A WAHITEWAS HOR HINDU WASH FOR EVEN SAYING THAT U DONT EVEN CARE N R LUAGHN GET OFF THIS SITE U FAKE <banned word filter activated> PHONY

FFFF U AJEETSINGHPUNJABI U F K N TRAITOR

R U OK . DO U EVEN NO WHATS HAPEEING TO SIKHS IN INDIA . OVER 4 MILLION SIKHS DISAPPERED SINCE 84 . OUR GURDUARAS BURNED DOWN BY HINUS N MUSLIMS , SO MANY RAPES , SO MUCH BEADBI OF SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB , RSS AND HINDU TERROIST WANT TO RUIN N ELIMNATE SIKH RELIGON N U WANT TO HELP THEM . SRI GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAID WITHOUT SOVERIGNITY RELIGON WILL PERISH WE NEED LAND TO BACK UP SIKHS TO KEEP SIKHISM ALIVE TO GIVE RIGHTS TO SIKHS WE R NOT MUSLIM TERROIST THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT R TERROISTS . WE DIDNT BOMB NY PLANE THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT DID THAT N BLAMED IT ON BABAR KHALSA TO GIVE SIKHS A BAD NAME AND IDENTITY U SO CALLED SIKH U RNOT EVEN SIKH BY DOUBTING UR OWN PPL HOW R CREATING BORDERS EVEN GURU JI HAD RAJ AND MAHARAJ RANJIT SINGH HAD RAJ WE LIVE AS SLAVES TO INDIA IN THE GOVERNMENT N THEN WE HAVE SO CALLED SIKHS LIKE U THAT SO NO KAHLISTAN Y . U R NOT EDUCATED ENOUGH U R THINKING OF US LIKE SOME MUSLIM TERROISTS THAT WANT LAND . WE WANT LAND BECZ HNIDUS R EMLINATING SIKHS EVERYDAY AND DESTROYING THEIR RELIGON AND NOT LETTING SIKHS LIVETHER LIVES . WE NEED KHALISTAN EVEN SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI SAID IT ONCE HARMANDER SAHIB GETS ATTACKED THE FOUNDATION OF KHALISTAN WILL BE LAID . U WHITEWASHED SIKH U R A WAHITEWAS HOR HINDU WASH FOR EVEN SAYING THAT U DONT EVEN CARE N R LUAGHN GET OFF THIS SITE U FAKE <banned word filter activated> PHONY

FFFF U AJEETSINGHPUNJABI U F K N TRAITOR

Maybe this thread is a microcosm of why so many laugh at the idea of Sikhs having the organization to lobby and run an independant country. The man simply stated an opinion, and instead of respectful responses he gets that. The above msg is barely coherent, and these are the ppl advocating independance? So instead of calling him a donkey rider, white washed or whatever, respond in a respectful way and debate the issue. In fact, he lives in Punjab from what I gather, so his opinion should be that much more important. Because at the end of the day the rest of us are not even living (and probably never will live) in the land we want wish to liberate. I am not saying he is right or wrong, but the above comment would make any Khalistani seem like an <banned word filter activated>.

[Only five]

Maybe this thread is a microcosm of why so many laugh at the idea of Sikhs having the organization to lobby and run an independant country. The man simply stated an opinion, and instead of respectful responses he gets that. The above msg is barely coherent, and these are the ppl advocating independance? So instead of calling him a donkey rider, white washed or whatever, respond in a respectful way and debate the issue. In fact, he lives in Punjab from what I gather, so his opinion should be that much more important. Because at the end of the day the rest of us are not even living (and probably never will live) in the land we want wish to liberate. I am not saying he is right or wrong, but the above comment would make any Khalistani seem like an <banned word filter activated>.

Maybe instead of pretending to provide a balanced view about how the thread went, you should actually present a balanced view. It is obvious you are acting blind to the tone of the ajeetsinghpunjabi post to present your biased view. There is a video of Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa talking with a swami. In the video the swami try's to belittle Sant ji (Gurmat) by stating the Khalsa should back down (from wanting their demands for freedom). Before this Sant ji is answering the questions the swami has, but when the swami try's to pull his tricks on Sant ji. Then Sant ji slap the swami across the face with his words. He tells the swami if you feel like crying after seeing a innocent child being burnt alive then go cry, but we (KHalsa) don't cry, but act. Sant ji gave the swami a donkey ride around the town with his words. Now ask yourself why Sant ji used this way with the swami. It's because the swami came at Sant ji with an arrogant tone and was trying to belittle him. Ajeetsinghpunjabi came with the same tone as the swami in his post and Karkoosingh23 slapped him with two hands and sent him home. I don't agree with the swearing, but what Ajeetsinghpunjabi wrote is just the same as swearing, so any person without taking sides would tell both to stop swearing. But you only pick on Karkoosingh23. There is a time and place to give such people donkey rides. And this was one of the cases. So thanks to Karkoosingh23 for provide a service for which some don't have the heart to provide because they rather bow to political correctness.

Thank you for posting and being part of the demostration Harpreet Singh. :biggrin2:

[ks55]

My piece of advice :: Learn from the jews !

Jews spent 2000 years without a homeland and its just been 200 years for us

Make yourself prosper in the countries you live in , let the people know what sikhism is .

Preach sikhism to non-sikhs , something which sikhs today don't do .

and First prosper and grow in foreign countries

100% spot on top advice -for the upcoming sikh generations

[gpav6]

R U OK . DO U EVEN NO WHATS HAPEEING TO SIKHS IN INDIA . OVER 4 MILLION SIKHS DISAPPERED SINCE 84 . OUR GURDUARAS BURNED DOWN BY HINUS N MUSLIMS , SO MANY RAPES , SO MUCH BEADBI OF SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB , RSS AND HINDU TERROIST WANT TO RUIN N ELIMNATE SIKH RELIGON N U WANT TO HELP THEM . SRI GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAID WITHOUT SOVERIGNITY RELIGON WILL PERISH WE NEED LAND TO BACK UP SIKHS TO KEEP SIKHISM ALIVE TO GIVE RIGHTS TO SIKHS WE R NOT MUSLIM TERROIST THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT R TERROISTS . WE DIDNT BOMB NY PLANE THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT DID THAT N BLAMED IT ON BABAR KHALSA TO GIVE SIKHS A BAD NAME AND IDENTITY U SO CALLED SIKH U RNOT EVEN SIKH BY DOUBTING UR OWN PPL HOW R CREATING BORDERS EVEN GURU JI HAD RAJ AND MAHARAJ RANJIT SINGH HAD RAJ WE LIVE AS SLAVES TO INDIA IN THE GOVERNMENT N THEN WE HAVE SO CALLED SIKHS LIKE U THAT SO NO KAHLISTAN Y . U R NOT EDUCATED ENOUGH U R THINKING OF US LIKE SOME MUSLIM TERROISTS THAT WANT LAND . WE WANT LAND BECZ HNIDUS R EMLINATING SIKHS EVERYDAY AND DESTROYING THEIR RELIGON AND NOT LETTING SIKHS LIVETHER LIVES . WE NEED KHALISTAN EVEN SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI SAID IT ONCE HARMANDER SAHIB GETS ATTACKED THE FOUNDATION OF KHALISTAN WILL BE LAID . U WHITEWASHED SIKH U R A WAHITEWAS HOR HINDU WASH FOR EVEN SAYING THAT U DONT EVEN CARE N R LUAGHN GET OFF THIS SITE U FAKE <banned word filter activated> PHONY

FFFF U AJEETSINGHPUNJABI U F K N TRAITOR

Well said, why should we be puppets of the system.

Everyone has their right to their own views and it should stay that way, there should be no trying to tell people khalistan is wrong or right, theres no point, humans are naturaly stubborn, the people who don't agree with khalistan will one day agree with it and promote it , I guarantee that.

The people who support khalistan are mainly the people who suffered in 1984 / had family/relative/ who the saw the masacre there or who belive in freedom of speach.

I am neutral in the arguement/debate but I do agree with freedom of speach, so everyone who is saying if you belive in khalistan then your not a sikh is trying to promote oppresion of speach.

[Guest KopSingh]

Maybe instead of pretending to provide a balanced view about how the thread went, you should actually present a balanced view. It is obvious you are acting blind to the tone of the ajeetsinghpunjabi post to present your biased view. There is a video of Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa talking with a swami. In the video the swami try's to belittle Sant ji (Gurmat) by stating the Khalsa should back down (from wanting their demands for freedom). Before this Sant ji is answering the questions the swami has, but when the swami try's to pull his tricks on Sant ji. Then Sant ji slap the swami across the face with his words. He tells the swami if you feel like crying after seeing a innocent child being burnt alive then go cry, but we (KHalsa) don't cry, but act. Sant ji gave the swami a donkey ride around the town with his words. Now ask yourself why Sant ji used this way with the swami. It's because the swami came at Sant ji with an arrogant tone and was trying to belittle him. Ajeetsinghpunjabi came with the same tone as the swami in his post and Karkoosingh23 slapped him with two hands and sent him home. I don't agree with the swearing, but what Ajeetsinghpunjabi wrote is just the same as swearing, so any person without taking sides would tell both to stop swearing. But you only pick on Karkoosingh23. There is a time and place to give such people donkey rides. And this was one of the cases. So thanks to Karkoosingh23 for provide a service for which some don't have the heart to provide because they rather bow to political correctness.

Thank you for posting and being part of the demostration Harpreet Singh. :biggrin2:

wjkk wjkf, wow, 1st time ive ever agreed with u, big up!