What Nonsense Is This

[Guest]

classical/blues yes they do. but not rock /metal

they take over your body and your mind loses control over it. your soul no longer enjoys it

your body enjoys it, which is what we do not want.

My soul enjoys rock and metal as much as if I was listening to blues or classical...They all have beauty...A person doesn't need to start a mosh pit or start jumping around like a mad man to appreciate rock and metal...It's at a certain stage that a person can enjoy rock/metal without going crazy(when I mean crazy I mean jumping up and down etc)...Bands like led zeppelin for example have such beautiful songs that touch my soul...

[Only five]

So you feel dancing, music is entirely haram ?

You asked where Rehat said you can't clap and cheer. Now I presented Gurbani that says that it is wrong. Be satisfied with what Satguru is telling you and come to terms with Gurbani. I knew from the start this was going to happen, hence I asked you to do the hard work of finding the shabad. You would have appreciated the Shabad and it shows you really did not look for the shabad.

[Only five]

So you are against children skipping, hopping and dancing the nursery rhymes?

What prescribed punishment do you recommend by the shariah... oh I mean by gurmat?

Hold on a minute. Why bring children into this discussion. By bringing children into this discussion you are implying that your mind and others minds who want to dance are not yet fully able to understand what is right and wrong. Children do many silly things. They play with their food. So do you also play with your food like a child? Children at times will pick up dirt and put it in their mouth. Do you put dirt in your mouth to see what dirt is? Gurmat does not base it's actions on what children do and don't do.

IF anything you sound like a Muslim scholar that says Muhammed was correct on marrying a 6 year old because three years later she got her first period. If you want to have an honest discussion about this, then present Gurbani. Instead you ignore the pauri I presented.

[DalbirSingh]

Hold on a minute. Why bring children into this discussion. By bringing children into this discussion you are implying that your mind and others minds who want to dance are not yet fully able to understand what is right and wrong. Children do many silly things. They play with their food. So do you also play with your food like a child? Children at times will pick up dirt and put it in their mouth. Do you put dirt in your mouth to see what dirt is? Gurmat does not base it's actions on what children do and don't do.

IF anything you sound like a Muslim scholar that says Muhammed was correct on marrying a 6 year old because three years later she got her first period. If you want to have an honest discussion about this, then present Gurbani. Instead you ignore the pauri I presented.

There is a huge difference between a child's innocence where they dance and a pedophille who rapes a child and calls himself perfect not just perfect but the perfect man till the end of times who should be mimicked. It was him he condemned dancing and music to begin with.

[savinderpalsingh]

My soul enjoys rock and metal as much as if I was listening to blues or classical...They all have beauty...A person doesn't need to start a mosh pit or start jumping around like a mad man to appreciate rock and metal...It's at a certain stage that a person can enjoy rock/metal without going crazy(when I mean crazy I mean jumping up and down etc)...Bands like led zeppelin for example have such beautiful songs that touch my soul...

bin there done that.

find raag's and old style kirtan more moving and bairaagi then rock/metal

body stays still as rock - the soul takes flight

[Guest]

bin there done that.

find raag's and old style kirtan more moving and bairaagi then rock/metal

body stays still as rock - the soul takes flight

We have different opinions then...By the way I have been studying music for over 13 years...

[Only five]

We have different opinions then...By the way I have been studying music for over 13 years...

Singh are you being serious. Nothing can equal to Raag Kirtan. Do you think maybe it is because of personal shortcomings that you still find rock/metal as enjoying for the atma? I have listened to all sorts of music. But after Raag kirtan, nothing has matched it. I mean how can anything beat or match Sachi Bani! Everything else just sounds like a person chewing on some really crunchy cereal.

Some like listening to that Sartaj fellow. But I don't get what is so fascinating about what he says. It's him singing kachi Bani. If I want to hear a song about Waheguru or about the atma, then why listen to false material. I mean we don't go to half baked teachers to learn about medicine or law. Satguru tells Sikhs to come and sing Satguru's Bani and says don't sing Kachi Bani. They can sing about God, but it is fruitless.

[savinderpalsingh]

also what maakes raag kirtan more better then western is that it as more nodes

where as western has only CDEFGABC

u will be surprised how many nodes classical has, maybe more then 21 nodes
u might be knowing this as you've been studying music for 13 years

[DalbirSingh]

Would you give your children timeouts if you saw them dancing and skipping to the evil demonic ways of the kuffar?

[savinderpalsingh]

if they are brought well and the wife cleans her utensil up with bani before having child .

then that child will never resort to anti sikhi ways.

and no, there is no need as long as child is brought up well. and understands he wont do such thing.
and the parents should be willing to guide him well