Jump to content

Lessons to be learnt from the Khalistan Movement


Recommended Posts

8 minutes ago, KhoonKaBadlaKhoon said:

You may not want it, but vast majority of Punjabis did/do want music. Women not being allowed to put their hair down? Once again, vast majority of women aren't going to wear a pagg or chunni 24/7. These silly rules was a major factor people turned their backs on kharkus. 

And it is our responsibility to analyze what happened, it'd be a shame if we didn't point out the pros and cons. This is how you learn. And there's nothing wrong with saying they made mistakes. 

I somewhat agree with your points above. Analysing is good and yes i also agree it is a way forward. And yes spotting mistakes is a good quality to have. However personally I don't feel these rules were wrong. I think they showed us an example of how many things should be in regard to weddings and so forth. In my eyes, I see it as parchar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Jacfsing2
1 hour ago, KhoonKaBadlaKhoon said:

You may not want it, but vast majority of Punjabis did/do want music. Women not being allowed to put their hair down? Once again, vast majority of women aren't going to wear a pagg or chunni 24/7. These silly rules was a major factor people turned their backs on kharkus. 

From what I heard only Babbar Khalsa had a Rehat requirement, while the others were more open to Maryada. (Also they seemed to be the only ones who required their group to have Amritdhari only requirements as well as having a minimum Nitnem memorized requirement). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 04/08/2017 at 0:35 AM, Prokharkoo84 said:

Cheers brother for replying, I was hoping you would provide an input as I can see from your previous posts you know the score regarding what was reality during the Sangaarsh as opposed to some of the fairy tale stories that are in circulation. I agree fully that actions by some kharkoos which was interpreted as 'taliban' style behaviour pushed a lot of common folk away, while as much as I rate Gurnek Singh Neka and co for popping Chamkila off, it did cause the Sangaarsh to be pushed back. Regarding Dhanna Singh, I think whilst it is easy for mans like me to sit in my own luxury Khalistan aka the UK and diss him, his kurbani is still massive considering he did what he did in his youth which is more than what most 'Khalistanis' particularly in the disapora have achieved. 

In regards to my opening post, can you shed light on the roles of individuals such as Zaffarwal, Rode, Bittu and Mann to who their seems to be a lot of clouds over? Personally I still rate all those mentioned apart from Rode (to all readers - do not turn this into an argument). Also brother, any information on those who switched sides and had top Singhs such as Baba Manochahal, Gurjant Singh Budhsinghwala, General Labh Singh etc killed?

Thanks in advance brother.

All have tons of controversy. Is it possible govt let bygones be bygones and told zaffarwal he can come back, without having to provide info etc? Could be. Rode, I'm not sure what to believe, while some people say he cut a deal got released, couple members here say he was scapegoat. Bittu, some folks even say he was behind Budhsinghwala killing, others say he is solid and till day is doing Seva of Shaheed parvaars. Serious accusation throw anyways, without evidence. Mann to me seems like a good man, but a bit foolish.  

 

General Labh Singh was apparently going to Pakistan, night before he was killed. His wife said she saw who she thinks was Labh Singh and someone unknown to her leaving in a jeep. Next day his body was found, alone. So perhaps whoever was with him had him set up? Although I'm not sure who it was. Manochahal it's commonly known Sukhwant Vaarchiree, an associate of his switched, probably for cash, I don't believe he was tortured and flipped. 

 

For a lot of things, we will never find out the truth now. Its gone with the shaheeds. 

28 minutes ago, JS79 said:

I somewhat agree with your points above. Analysing is good and yes i also agree it is a way forward. And yes spotting mistakes is a good quality to have. However personally I don't feel these rules were wrong. I think they showed us an example of how many things should be in regard to weddings and so forth. In my eyes, I see it as parchar.

Parchar is fine bro, but not when done by force. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Jacfsing2 said:

From what I heard only Babbar Khalsa had a Rehat requirement, while the others were more open to Maryada. (Also they seemed to be the only ones who required their group to have Amritdhari only requirements as well as having a minimum Nitnem memorized requirement). 

Yeah, that's true. They were also the ones who were strictest on civilians, while other groups were generally a bit more relaxed. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, KhoonKaBadlaKhoon said:

Parchar is fine bro, but not when done by force. 

I am not khalistani but for example, imagine if suddenly we got khalistan. Would we say 'it is unnecessary to ban tobacco, barbers, cinemas, pubs, meat shops, wessing parties etc'. Of course everything would have to transform and live according to khalsa regulations only. Back then the singhs made it the closest thing to khalistan. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Jacfsing2
1 hour ago, JS79 said:

I am not khalistani but for example, imagine if suddenly we got khalistan. Would we say 'it is unnecessary to ban tobacco, barbers, cinemas, pubs, meat shops, wessing parties etc'. Of course everything would have to transform and live according to khalsa regulations only. Back then the singhs made it the closest thing to khalistan. 

The Sikh Empire as well as Banda Singh Bahadur's rule, (who was selected by Guru Sahib himself), didn't create rules for civilians that would effect their daily lives. Also what will you do about the 40% Non-Sikhs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, Jacfsing2 said:

The Sikh Empire as well as Banda Singh Bahadur's rule, (who was selected by Guru Sahib himself), didn't create rules for civilians that would effect their daily lives. Also what will you do about the 40% Non-Sikhs.

Wouldnt everyone live according to their religion. Im not sure. But most likely people other than sikhs wouldnt want to live in khalistan anyways. Even some sikhs may not want to. 

If everything in terms of wrong things were to carry on then why do they need to call it khalistan. Isnt that a bit misleading. The name will not change whats going on at ground level in punjab. Maharaj tells us the definition of a khalsa and say if we miraculously got khalistan shouldnt they atleast try to promote how to live according to a khalsa lifestyle?  For sikhs anyway. E.g. they should really sieve throigh every field and for example stop bhangra groups in colleges and preach dharam. I dont know what other religions would do they might get bored and leave. Khalistan is probably never going to happen its a bit unrealistic but lets see. If they think khalistan is about human rights and equality that is a good idea but that could then happen anywhere. Sikhs dont need land named khalistan we need corruption out of the current system. Khalistan could also become corrupt. It most likely will because the leadership in khalistan will probably be no different to our current leadership. The only difference would be that the current leaders will become stronger and more corrupt. Again, my personal view and i could be totally wrong. Maybe khalistan will have a chardikala panthic singh in charge who is not biased at all and strong to stand by the truth regardless.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest AjeetSinghPunjabi

Sometimes I wonder if we as a community are in the mess today that we're in because of killing of innocent hindus in 80's 

Like you know the stories of khadkoos bringing out hindus from buses and killing them .And hindu murders elsewhere in punjab back then. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Jacfsing2
30 minutes ago, AjeetSinghPunjabi said:

Sometimes I wonder if we as a community are in the mess today that we're in because of killing of innocent hindus in 80's 

Like you know the stories of khadkoos bringing out hindus from buses and killing them .And hindu murders elsewhere in punjab back then. 

Only Black Cats were killing innocent Hindus, and even if 1 or 2 Hindus were wrongfully brought to justice in your view, how many Sikhs were wrongfully killed? Way more than even the best number for the other side.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Its called a “fifty” becuase when Singhs were fighting in the British army, they would recieve an 8 metre pagg, with a cour four base, because the base layer was half (50%) of the main turban, it’s called a fifty. The practise of tying a keski under your main one is now seen as pretty weird (except for a patka), but the small coloured strip inder the pagg is still used as a fashion statement since its pretty visually appealing. And so, people now just tie a small little “kung-fu strip” sort of thing under their pagg to imitate that effect.
    • Found how to do it. For anybody else wondering, heres how. No one even helped me btw. So much for Guru Ji’s lhalsa always ready to help (and having their Singhs’ backs smh). (Notes: Aim to do this on a hot summer’s day, and dedicate a full day to this, since you only have to do this once every 4 months at least (normally the turban will stay in shape until you wish to untie it and physically pull it open again). This helps it to dry faster, since you have to starch it, HALF DRY IT, pooni it, tie it and then wear it for around four hours for the rest of it to dry, all in the same day. It’s a one day process but it serves you for months). This works for both the UK/Kenyan style (starch is best for this style) as well as the normal Punjabi paghs (such as Patiala shahi, wattan wali and morni paghs). Not sure about dumallas though. Probably not . Pagg Starch: 1) Boil 6 cups of water in a saucepan on low heat (always low heat) 2) Seperately dissolve 4 tablespoons of maida (all purpose flower) with a little water until it is 100% smooth.  You could also use rice or corn starch. Add more water if it is not a smooth liquid 3) Once completely smooth, pour this mixture through a strainer (to make it even smoother) into the boiling water. 4) Now continuously stir it until it goes completely see through. Keep on stirring it on the low heat until it goes totally transparent (it can take a little while to cook, but the pagg will last you for months!) It will at become a thick paste first, but keep stirring until it becomes see through and thinner.    5) Once it’s transparent, pour the starch (again through a strainer) into a big enough, clean bucket to cool down. 6) Once cool, take a clean, dry turban and completely and mix it in with the starch for around 5 minutes. Make sure that it is all evenly and completely soaked and wet with the starch. (Most people use mal-mal material, but I use full voile and I have used Rubia too. They’re all fine. Maybe use Rubin for smaller turbans and mal mal for larger ones) 7) Leave it out in the sun to HALF DRY ONLY!!!!!!! (Don’t ever let your starched turban fully dry before you tie it. If you do, then you will have to spray/ sprinkle water on it which will weaken the starch and ruin the turban) ONLY HALF DRY THE TURBAN IN THE SUN!!! 😎 Once HALF DRY ONLY take the now semi damp turban, and fold/pooni and then tie it like normal (straight on your head, with no base layer such as a Keski or patka underneath). Leave it on your head for around 4 hours just to fully dry and it will be ready and set for months now. Like I said, do try to tie your dastar every day, but if you can’t or really don’t want to, I hope this helps! Like I said this works on both the traditional Punjabi/Indian style paggs, and the more recent UK/Kenyan style paggs. It does for my morni pagg, but the first larr slips up in to the pagg. This is normal dw. Wjkk, Wjkf
    • I guess easier ways of learning have taken precedence. There are so many Youtube channels and podcasts available that people are more ready to listen for knowledge at their own leisure. There are so many great kathas available online that take months to listen, so that people may not really get the time to come here and write.
    • *Bump The current conflict (w/ Iran getting involved) is being orchestrated by a 3rd party in my opinion. We all are going to blame the Jewish community (how they run the banks, how they are brutal and etc.) but they have a point in this conflict.  As soon as people start finding about the truth that's when the real movement will begin. 
    • https://www.youtube.com/live/FcXcuvkIT9I?si=qzOSWY7EEOXDaNv2
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use