Fear For A Naxalite Attack On Takht Sri Patna Sahib?

[guptveer1469]

wow.. dint know sikhs had so much support for naxalites...

[Muzumdar]

wow.. dint know sikhs had so much support for naxalites...

Sunny,

For every Sikh, like myself, who has the utmost respect for the Naxalites and their struggle, you will find another Sikh who hates them.

I respect them because I know them, intimately. Members of my family were part of the Punjabi Naxalite movement in the 60s and 70s and believe me, they know their stuff and are very highly educated.

This is why many Sikhs respect them: they are staunch Socialists (to be precise, they are Marxist-Leninists) and, as such, they believe in the equality of the human race, an equal distribution of wealth and the abolition of distinctions of caste, creed, gender, colour etc.

Does that sound familiar? It should, because that is exaclty what Sikhs believe in.

The reason that some Sikhs may dislike them is because they are, in the tradition of Marxism, atheists. I have no problem with this and neither do the majority of Sikhs out there.

When children are dying because the State and society deems it fit to discriminate along the lines of caste, I do not care if a man or woman believes in God, shmod or the jolly green giant as long as something is done about it. And the Naxalites have been doing something about it for 40 odd years.

May the Gurus bless the Naxalites for doing what the Sikhs should be doing.

Apologies for the long rant.

[kaur_khalistani_lioness]

wjkk wjkf!

Sunny! hope u learned something jk

beautifully said Muzumdar.

its amzing how much we dont know about other leaders or organizations etc who are doin the same thing sikhs tryin to do for the past so many decades. i think these days only those whos family members were involved in that LAHAAR in punjab or else where are aware of the fact how powerful, educated, intelligent, positive, humanitarian, (sikh like) Nax members are and were. most of them never got married during that time, because they knew the tactics of the government and didnt want some other family(wife and her family) to get harassed or emotionally/physically abused for something the hubby chose to do with his life.

these people are down to earth!

when the lehar died in punjab...most of these people joined other organizations to do what they were passionate about. u will find most of these members(who are still alive) doing GREAT I MEAN REALLY GREAT SEVA for the human kind! they still respect who evr was involved and have a network which is so strong because they lived for each other and had a same goal.

oh and one thing for sure....yes people think these people dont believe in GOD BUT MOST OF THE PUNJABI(SIKH) who were part of this in 60's and 70's believed in Akal purakh and joined because of the reasons said above by Muzumdar..which matched Sikh ethics and lifestyle.

bhul chuk muaff karni and hope that helps us see whats being done by these people in india from a positive perspective! (and yes always know we all are human beings and tend to make mistakes...im sure there are some in Nax (members) now who are GOVT people involved to do wrong like they did before..so dont turn ur blind eye to those things)

rab rakh!=)

wjkk wjkf!

[saint-soldier]

Do not believe everything that comes from the mouth of indian media.

Indian Media = Propaganda

[Singhballer]

Most of the worlds media is propaganda :D

MOST

[DashmeshForce]

A lot of naxalites became Kharkoos during the Khalistan Movement.

I believe Wadhawa Singh Babbar was also a former Naxalite?

[guptveer1469]

muzumdar - thx very much for info

kaur khalistani lioness - also thx very much for the info

saint-soldier - this was in a 'punjabi sikh' newspaper des pardes

singhballer - agree

jsingh123 - i dont know bout wadhawa singh, but tarsem singh kalasinghian alias sema one of the key founders of bki and one of the first recruits by shaheed bhai talwinder singh babbar was a staunch naxalite before becoming a kharkoo

[hawk13]

To sum this ludicrous and pathetic story up: don't believe everything you read.

The Punjabi Naxalites, nor any other Naxalites, would even contemplate attacking a Gurdwara. Their ultimate aim is the creation of a Socialist Republic of India through violent revolution. Gurdwaras do not come into their equations.

They want to change the Indian political system, which they feel is corrupt, discriminatory and murderous. (Sound familiar?)

They are probably the bravest people fighting the State and, unlike the Sikhs, have a coherent political ideology behind them.

They have no issue with Sikhi or Sikhs per se, and in fact I remember a Naxalite resolution being passed supporting the post-Bluestar Sikh freedom fighters.

So please, lay off them. They are cool.

U r wrong my brother NAXALITES r as anti-sikh as RSS during sikh struggle in 80s their cadre joined cats and formed their own teror groups these were KARTAR SINGH SARABHA BRIGADE, INDIAN LIONS their leader sumit singh of PREETLARI was sent to to hell by singhs their leaders like balwinder singh still r allowed to carry and keep weapons like LMG ,AK 47S .they wear now panthic mask in 1993 in south they killed Punjab Police officers then did beadbi of their kesh as aresult their 8 villages were burned down by sikh policemen and 1000 socalled brave naxallites came and surrendered. We will be fooling ourself if we trust these bastards leftists H.S SURJEET WAS THE ONE OF THE FOUNDER OF NAXALITE MOVEMENT. Their other leaders r RAUANKI RAM profeessor of political science in Punjab university. Bhupinder brar both r the bigggest anti sikhs. They r trying to revive their movement in punjab through migration of bIHARI LABOURERS .These naxalites were involved in mass killings of sikh fighters famlies.

[guptveer1469]

wow

hawk13, has much info!!! thx for it...

so then these naxalites are against sikhi so anti-sikh?

and bhaiya karni of punjab shud be stopped at all costs

[hawk13]

Naxallites have failed poltical ideology and their track record in China ,RUSSIA is stained with blood of innocent people. One of top INDIAN Army official compares naxallites with sikh figters like this naxallites despite their numbers meekly runs away but sikh fighters fights like tigers and repulshes the superior forces. And leftists r anti religion if they dare attack the TAKHT PATNA SHAIAB. THERE WILL BE SEVERE RETAILIATION FROM HUGH SIKH UNITS SITUATED IN BIHAR as happened in1996 when a sikh army officer was abuducted and when sikh troops laid seige to their strongholds and 1500 naxallites surrendered and freed the officer. Rather sikhs have clear political idelogy and their track recod is clean even medival period. so dump leftist idology in garbage.