Muslims View On Veg And Non Veg

[BABBAR KHALISTANI]

............ however zakir naik is very knowledgeable on islam and ............

Trust me, he's not.

Zakir Naik is indeed very Knowledgeable on Islam but i feel he's very cunning, dishonest and misleading. He often cites false figures to justify issues like Polygamy etc.

And i read his views on Sikhism in his study on comparitive religion where he says Guru Nanak patshah was influenced by Kabir Ji and satguru patshah would often go to muslims for advice.....i mean why would satguru patshah go to anyone for any advice when he himself was ek-jot with waheguru and on what evidence did Zakir Naik wrote all dat shyt?

And then Ali Sina of faithfreedom.org had also done a written commentary on Zakir Naik's debate with christian scholar William Campbell whom muslims site as a victory. Ali sina has revealed how Zakir Naik attributed a number of verses from quran in one go and said amidst thunderous claps from muslims that these verses explain water cycle in 'great detail' but when the verses were anaysed there was no rocket science or great detail. They were very basic things that are seen by naked eye but surely if i would have been present among the audience i would also have been impressed. Zakir Naik's surely a great orator and perfomer but hardly a honest propogator of truth.

[CaptainQ]

this post shud be renamed 'Muslims view on WEG and non WEG'

LOLOL brilliant

i actually thort he had made some fair points in the video.

[chatanga]

another thort that occured to me was, when the islamics execute sinners cos they beleive Allah wants them to, they always strike from the back. why when they have the backing of Allah? when they halal sheeps and stuff, they always pull the head back so the animal cannot see the blade the halaler is holding.

[Revolutionary]

when he commented about "cowards" and "brave" i dont know about anyone else.. but i felt... :S confused

I can't understand the concept of us being cowards and them being brave... i just..can't..

hmm too much reading Sikh History i suppose..

[SaRpAnCh]

quite a dew muslims hate him hope he gets whats comming to him then he can go see his 72 virgins @!GTR*** he s the one who looks like a coward

[Sayf Udeen]

i had this conversation with a muslim girl when i was in uni. I asked her "can a Muslim be a vegeterian"? she replied "its wrong for a muslim to be vegeterian because they are turning something that is halal (ie something that is right) into harram (ie something that is wrong)". So basically what she was saying was, if a muslim refuses to eat meat (even if it is halal), they can not be a muslim because God has made it permissible for them to eat it.

I challanged her opinion by asking "are vegetables halal (permissible to eat)?" she replied yes. I asked what if someone decided they dont like eating potatoas becasue they dont like them. potatoes are halal, so are they turning something halal (potatoes)into something haram? at this she changed her original opinion and said, it is the muslims individuals choice weather or not they chose to eat halal meat.

As for Dr. Zakir Naik, there is some truth in what he says but he does frequently pass of his false findings as fact. I will make an assumption that half the crowed that listen to him are uneducated as they just happily gobble up what ever he tells them without giving it a second thought.... if requested i will give examples in due course.

Pfft - I'm a Muslim and she doesn't seem so knowledgable on the matter. Just because something is Halal doesn't mean it's obbligatory!

[Khalsa04]

i had this conversation with a muslim girl when i was in uni. I asked her "can a Muslim be a vegeterian"? she replied "its wrong for a muslim to be vegeterian because they are turning something that is halal (ie something that is right) into harram (ie something that is wrong)". So basically what she was saying was, if a muslim refuses to eat meat (even if it is halal), they can not be a muslim because God has made it permissible for them to eat it.

I challanged her opinion by asking "are vegetables halal (permissible to eat)?" she replied yes. I asked what if someone decided they dont like eating potatoas becasue they dont like them. potatoes are halal, so are they turning something halal (potatoes)into something haram? at this she changed her original opinion and said, it is the muslims individuals choice weather or not they chose to eat halal meat.

As for Dr. Zakir Naik, there is some truth in what he says but he does frequently pass of his false findings as fact. I will make an assumption that half the crowed that listen to him are uneducated as they just happily gobble up what ever he tells them without giving it a second thought.... if requested i will give examples in due course.

Pfft - I'm a Muslim and she doesn't seem so knowledgable on the matter. Just because something is Halal doesn't mean it's obbligatory!

TO THOSE WHO ARE REPLYING TO THE CHATKA/GOAT ISSUE AT HAZOOR SAHIB, INSTEAD OF ARGUING AND BICKERING THEIR, ANSWER THE VIDEO..

HE SAYS THAT PLANTS CAN FEEL PAIN AND HAVE SENSES TOO, SO THEN IS EATING MEAT WRONG BECAUSE PLANTS ALSO FEEL PAIN WHEN YOU KILL THEM?

WE SIT THERE MAKING A MOCKERY OF THE VIDEO, LAUGHING AT THE ENGLISH, ETC BUT WHAT IF SOMEONE CAME HERE AND SAW THIS VIDEO?

LETS BEGIN TO ANSWER QUESTIONS WITHOUT BRUSHING THINGS UNDER THE CARPET..

[Paneer Monster]

i had this conversation with a muslim girl when i was in uni. I asked her "can a Muslim be a vegeterian"? she replied "its wrong for a muslim to be vegeterian because they are turning something that is halal (ie something that is right) into harram (ie something that is wrong)". So basically what she was saying was, if a muslim refuses to eat meat (even if it is halal), they can not be a muslim because God has made it permissible for them to eat it.

I challanged her opinion by asking "are vegetables halal (permissible to eat)?" she replied yes. I asked what if someone decided they dont like eating potatoas becasue they dont like them. potatoes are halal, so are they turning something halal (potatoes)into something haram? at this she changed her original opinion and said, it is the muslims individuals choice weather or not they chose to eat halal meat.

As for Dr. Zakir Naik, there is some truth in what he says but he does frequently pass of his false findings as fact. I will make an assumption that half the crowed that listen to him are uneducated as they just happily gobble up what ever he tells them without giving it a second thought.... if requested i will give examples in due course.

Pfft - I'm a Muslim and she doesn't seem so knowledgable on the matter. Just because something is Halal doesn't mean it's obbligatory!

TO THOSE WHO ARE REPLYING TO THE CHATKA/GOAT ISSUE AT HAZOOR SAHIB, INSTEAD OF ARGUING AND BICKERING THEIR, ANSWER THE VIDEO..

HE SAYS THAT PLANTS CAN FEEL PAIN AND HAVE SENSES TOO, SO THEN IS EATING MEAT WRONG BECAUSE PLANTS ALSO FEEL PAIN WHEN YOU KILL THEM?

WE SIT THERE MAKING A MOCKERY OF THE VIDEO, LAUGHING AT THE ENGLISH, ETC BUT WHAT IF SOMEONE CAME HERE AND SAW THIS VIDEO?

LETS BEGIN TO ANSWER QUESTIONS WITHOUT BRUSHING THINGS UNDER THE CARPET..

you're not gonna sing are you?