Sikh Channel And Thier Studio Cameras

[Jujhar Singh]

But was Guru Nanak Sahib in Human form?

And without the 6 Guru's Bani + Bhagatan bani, there would be no Guru Granth Sahib right?

So those human gurus were needed as well as the bhagatan... Does that mean that we forget our 10gurus and Guru Granth Sahib is just our guru?

See that is where you seem to contradict yourself, There were the Guru sahibs and bhagat etc that were in human form that contributed and created Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. But your forgetting that Guru Granth Sahib Ji has been COMPLETED and the Jot of the 10 Guru Sahibs is now eternally in Guru Maharaj. There leaves no room for baba x to come in and pretend to run the show.

Good answer...

[darasingh]

The Akal Thakt is a management body for the running of the Gurughar, yes. But the decisions made by the Akal Thakt are taken by the Jathedar on behalf of the WHOLE Sikh Panth, including the SGPC.

How do we know the jathedar of the Akal Thakat is not controlled by RSS?

[1kAuR1]

The Akal Thakt is a management body for the running of the Gurughar, yes. But the decisions made by the Akal Thakt are taken by the Jathedar on behalf of the WHOLE Sikh Panth, including the SGPC.

How do we know the jathedar of the Akal Thakat is not controlled by RSS?

How do we know your not RSS or that I am not RSS, we dont!

Thats not to say that this person is just plucked out of thin air. Perhaps if you researched into how the jathedars are selected you would have your answer, like I said before I dont pretend to know everything about the selection of Jathedars.

[Jujhar Singh]

Sital Singh Sitara has a mona violinist and a turban trim sikh on tabla, should they be blanked out because they dont follow Guru Gobind Singh's hukam?

[Jujhar Singh]

No one got anything to say about this?

I guessed not

[Sikh Channel]

The executive commitee at the Sikh Channel have been discussing this issue for a couple of weeks - there have been various reasons as to why it has taken a little bit longer than we had hoped to sort this issue out. As a result of these discussions, Naamdharis have been banned from appearing on air. Raj Academy have been informed of this decision and have agreed to comply by this ruling.

We know it may not please everyone, but the Sikh Channel took the step that anyone associated with groups or sects that go against the belief that Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the living Guru of the Sikhs or who may have betrayed our Guru in the past will not be allowed on air.

We ask you all to support us in this decision and hope we can now let this issue rest and continue spreading the Word of Gurbani far and wide using this popular media format.

Please note, Naamdharis are not the only ones who have been banned under this ruling - Meene, Masand, Ram Raieeay, Dhir Maleeay and Gangu Shaheeay have also been banned along with others at our discretion.

The Sikh Channel reserves the right to refuse guests any air time at any time.

A request to admin / mods to now close this thread.

[aeroo]

*edited*

[Jujhar Singh]

Thank God!

Thanks Sikh Channel *edited*

[mala]

The executive commitee at the Sikh Channel have been discussing this issue for a couple of weeks - there have been various reasons as to why it has taken a little bit longer than we had hoped to sort this issue out. As a result of these discussions, Naamdharis have been banned from appearing on air. Raj Academy have been informed of this decision and have agreed to comply by this ruling.

We know it may not please everyone, but the Sikh Channel took the step that anyone associated with groups or sects that go against the belief that Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the living Guru of the Sikhs or who may have betrayed our Guru in the past will not be allowed on air.

We ask you all to support us in this decision and hope we can now let this issue rest and continue spreading the Word of Gurbani far and wide using this popular media format.

Please note, Naamdharis are not the only ones who have been banned under this ruling - Meene, Masand, Ram Raieeay, Dhir Maleeay and Gangu Shaheeay have also been banned along with others at our discretion.

The Sikh Channel reserves the right to refuse guests any air time at any time.

A request to admin / mods to now close this thread.

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh!

Many thanks to the Sikh Channel for feeding this back to Sangat.

Dhan Guru Dhan Guru Pyaray!

[chatanga]

why insist on closing this thread?

surely the debate should continue about why if naamdharis can be exluded for thier stand on Guruship, why shud akj who reject the present saroop in its entirety be allowed to be on Sikh Channel?

Also Sikh Channel, were the NaamDhari Singhs aware that they would not be covered by the cameras before the prog? PLease clarify.