I Want Peoples Views - Should There Be A Khalistan Or Not?

[Kitaure]

Hello there, I am Harpreet Singh Kitaure a web designer from United Kingdom, I also do alot of blogging and just have started a new Sikh Blog, check it out http://sikh-blog.co.uk

I want peoples feedback, should there be a Khalistan or not?

Please get back to me.

[SevadaarEKhalsa]

Yes.

Why?

Read this link and you'll get your answers:

http://www.searchsikhism.com/khalistan.html

[dashmesh1984]

yes!

[VanHelsingh]

Yes of course. It is the only way Sikhs will be able to live in peace. But the quality of Sikh we have today is not capable of delivering us Khalistan.

The good are too few. Yes, I know about "sava laakh se ekh laraow" but in practical terms, we need more than mighty warriors to gain our own homeland. We need great thinkers and movers and sadly we don't have enough of those.

[JasSinghKhalsa]

Yes -

But we don't want people like Badal to lead Khalistan.

We need PURE KHALSA role models like Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, Baba Deep Singh Jee, Jassa Singh Ahluwalia, Jassa Singh Ramgharia, Hari Singh Nalwa, Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale etc. to lead Khalistan. Till the time we don't have these role models, it is difficult to (a). Get our Khalistan (b). Run it smoothly and efficently and make it a prosperous democratic/secular/honest Khalistan.

Khalistan to be ruled by Pure Khalsa and no hereditory family dynasty based system.

[JawandaWiggins]

There should definitely be a referendum to let the Sikh people decide this. In fact, there should be referendums in Kashmir/Tamil Eelam etc.

[Khalasthan86]

Khalistan Zindabad

[Hammertime007]

whats the point in putting this question to people who are not going to live there?

isnt it better to put the question to the people of Punjab ?

[JSinghN]

Why does it have to be called Khalistan why cant we call it Sikhistan so that all sikhs religious or not can be included, calling it khalistan wud kinda exclude sikh who arent amritdahris though i know it doesnt mean that but thats what sikhs will think.....if you understand where im coming from.

[guptkuri]

Why does it have to be called Khalistan why cant we call it Sikhistan so that all sikhs religious or not can be included, calling it khalistan wud kinda exclude sikh who arent amritdahris though i know it doesnt mean that but thats what sikhs will think.....if you understand where im coming from.

It is called Khalistan because it is going to be run by the Khalsa. Not by Sikhs that have not taken amrit and aren't khalsa. Everyone is welcomed in khalistan but it will only be run by khalsa.