Guroo Granth or Guroo Panth

[Guest rsingh]

Gurfathe,

I got a question, which if any can be deemed as more important, Groo Granth sahib ji or Guroo Khalsa Panth, (form of Akaal Takath Sahib)!

[Singhstah]

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!

Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

Guro Granth Sahib Ji

[DhadiMania]

i would say both. Guru Gobind Singh gave equal status to the panj pyare, which compared to himself. if you turn to guru granth sahib for help, your answers will be solved.

but if there was no guru granth to see, phir ki?

then guru panth, in which the guru said you would see me in (as well as saying if there were 5 pyare, you also see maharaj as well).

now in regards of akal takhat sahib, akal "god" takhat "throne", meaning the throne of god. where god sits (political matters). So as a result, the panj pyare make the decisive roles at the akal takhat, in which guru gobind singh said they were equal to him.

so they are just as both as important as one another jio.

bhol chukke muaff

Das

[Guest rsingh]

k well from that ould ask you. w have no rght to challenge the hukaam of Guroo Granth ad thereore we have no rgt to challenge the Hukaam of Guroo pnth(Akaal Takath).

[ms514]

Sat Sri Akal:

Guru Granth Sahib is the unchangable truth of the Guru Sahiban. It is the guiding Guru of the Panth and guides the Sikhs to path of Gursikhi. It IS the reference point by which Sikhs are to behave, live and act. The Guru Panth's Hukam has a very high status and has the power to make Panthic-wide decisions, BUT the Guru Panth is that body of people that follows the Guru Granth Sahib. If the "Guru Panth" begins to make decisions that are against the Guru Granth Sahib, then it is no longer the Guru Panth.

Now that I have confused you... :wub:

[Akaali]

I heard that the speech of "Guru Granth ji manyo pargat gura kee deh" was changed from "Guru Khalsa panth manyo pargat gura kee deh", I might be wrong though.

[gyani]

vwihgurU jI kw Kwlsw!

vwihgurU jI kI &iqh!!

IMHO the Akal Takhat is the "takhat" of Akal ( Waheguru )...and Waheguru is in the SHABAD GURU JYOT in the GURU GRANTH JI...

And that follows that the ONLY HUKMNAMA from GURU JI should come from the Vaaks of GURU GRANTH JI..in other words NOTHING and NOBODY can Supercede the GURBANI in the Shabad Guru.

jarnail Singh