Interview With Singh Who Attacked Jathedar

[hrman]

[jkvlondon]

They've rearrested him and taken his father also ...he has said that the jathedar's son was present at torture ...shows what circles these scum run in who have the titles in the kaum.

[Sa1nam]

what he did was wrong regardless of the reason, we cant take the law in to our own hands, as we all have a different level of intelligence and morality, what might be wrong to me may be fine to another person.

[jkvlondon]

what he did was wrong regardless of the reason, we cant take the law in to our own hands, as we all have a different level of intelligence and morality, what might be wrong to me may be fine to another person.

we can't the law into our own hands ? what planet are you on ...3 singhs get murdered...countless Kaurs get raped , over 300 get castrated and Ram Rahim has gone scotfree for 8 years ...are you totally mad?

The law has nothing to do with what is happening if it did he would not have been at liberty to castrate the men or rape more women but be serving a triple life sentence . No film deals etc .

If we stand up for those families which have lost their children this way or had their children's lives destroyed by this mafia thug , we are the ones hauled up , tortured and sent to jail for life on false charges ...do not EVER EVER EVER talk to me about law of the land . Guru Gobind SIngh ji told us if the law of the land is berahim , corrupt, and adharmic we have perfect right to disregard it . Singhs and Kaurs broke every law going just being Gursikhs ...are you honestly telling me that they were wrong ?? go crack a sikh Itihaas book then talk.

Sorry but I have no time for backsliding attitudes

[MisterrSingh]

Be careful what you wish for. And be careful who you throw your weight behind in support.

Whilst we can all safely agree that current Sikh institutions are infiltrated and compromised (can't even believe it's common knowledge, that's how helpless we are), there'll come a time when we'll have the Jathedar we all think is the correct appointment, but if someone were to come along and attack HIM for whatever ideological reason, then we'd all be up in arms in rage.

I'm not knocking the young Singh though. If anything, it sends a message to those opposed to us that Sikhs can see through the 5h1t being peddled to us on an ever increasing basis. Passions run high, etc, but I wouldn't make it a regular thing. Once it becomes common practice to lay your finger on a Jathedar, as I said previously, when Waheguru blesses us with a true Jathedar who'll do the right thing by Sikhs and Sikhi, that particular Jathedar will inevitably have enemies and when the other side wants to make their move they'll use the same tactics. Got to think 2 or 3 moves ahead of these devious fellows, not get caught in t1t-for-tat.

[Guest Jacfsing2]

Be careful what you wish for. And be careful who you throw your weight behind in support.

Whilst we can all safely agree that current Sikh institutions are infiltrated and compromised (can't even believe it's common knowledge, that's how helpless we are), there'll come a time when we'll have the Jathedar we all think is the correct appointment, but if someone were to come along and attack HIM for whatever ideological reason, then we'd all be up in arms in rage.

I'm not knocking the young Singh though. If anything, it sends a message to those opposed to us that Sikhs can see through the 5h1t being peddled to us on an ever increasing basis. Passions run high, etc, but I wouldn't make it a regular thing. Once it becomes common practice to lay your finger on a Jathedar, as I said previously, when Waheguru blesses us with a true Jathedar who'll do the right thing by Sikhs and Sikhi, that particular Jathedar will inevitably have enemies and when the other side wants to make their move they'll use the same tactics. Got to think 2 or 3 moves ahead of these devious fellows, not get caught in t1t-for-tat.

The last legit Jathedar was Ranjit Singh, (the guy who brought Justice go Gurbachana), I highly doubt we will those type of Jathedars again, we also had Manochal who was also an important figure. The current Jathedar was not picked by Sarbat Khalsa, but rather Badal.

[Jonny101]

Be careful what you wish for. And be careful who you throw your weight behind in support.

Whilst we can all safely agree that current Sikh institutions are infiltrated and compromised (can't even believe it's common knowledge, that's how helpless we are), there'll come a time when we'll have the Jathedar we all think is the correct appointment, but if someone were to come along and attack HIM for whatever ideological reason, then we'd all be up in arms in rage.

I'm not knocking the young Singh though. If anything, it sends a message to those opposed to us that Sikhs can see through the 5h1t being peddled to us on an ever increasing basis. Passions run high, etc, but I wouldn't make it a regular thing. Once it becomes common practice to lay your finger on a Jathedar, as I said previously, when Waheguru blesses us with a true Jathedar who'll do the right thing by Sikhs and Sikhi, that particular Jathedar will inevitably have enemies and when the other side wants to make their move they'll use the same tactics. Got to think 2 or 3 moves ahead of these devious fellows, not get caught in t1t-for-tat.

I think Nihang Joga Singh's actions should not be seen as an attack which can cause harm. His attack should be seen as a protest in the same spirit as when Jarnail Singh threw the shoe at the Home Minister, Mr. P. Chidambaram. Same way when Joga Singh made the attack, the attack was not intended to kill the Jathadar or even cause him any harm. But it did send a strong message to our corrupt leaders that the Panth is not buying their Bull$hit anymore.

When we have real Dharmi Jathadars, no one will attack them. Instead Singhs would bow in respect and Satkar to them.

[MisterrSingh]

When we have real Dharmi Jathadars, no one will attack them. Instead Singhs would bow in respect and Satkar to them.

I agree, brother. But remember the Black Cats from the 80's? Who's to say that instead of respecting and bowing to a true Jathedar someone masquerading as a Singh will stick a knife into him instead? It's not beyond the realms of possibility. That's why I said that whilst our grievances are justified and genuine, when the enemy makes their move they'll use our tactics for their ends. If we set a precedence, they'll take the ball and run with it.

These are the chalakhiyan we should keep in mind. The enemy is resourceful and can get at us in many ways. We are not so fortunate. When we make the direct approach we leaves ourselves open in other areas.

[jkvlondon]

I think Nihang Joga Singh's actions should not be seen as an attack which can cause harm. His attack should be seen as a protest in the same spirit as when Jarnail Singh threw the shoe at the Home Minister, Mr. P. Chidambaram. Same way when Joga Singh made the attack, the attack was not intended to kill the Jathadar or even cause him any harm. But it did send a strong message to our corrupt leaders that the Panth is not buying their Bull$hit anymore.

When we have real Dharmi Jathadars, no one will attack them. Instead Singhs would bow in respect and Satkar to them.

point is the newspaper say he attacked the jathedar but the truth is he was prevented from getting anywhere close to injuring him just scared the bejeesus out of him because he was subdued by the attendant bodyguard detail provided by Badal. Any court in this country would just call it a disturbance of the peace and leave it at that. The media is making more of a meal out of it to make the sheep-minded bleat about how bad and evil any Singh or Kaur is ...oh how bad amritdhari people are etc etc they can't be trusted with deciding what is needed for panth....