Question About The Rehat Maryada?

[kds1980]

wjkk

wjkf

just read this

How can the thought of those who eat meat, drink blood and suck bones become pure?"

(SGGSJ Ang 140)

please tell me where these lines are written in the original shabad

.also this shabad is written in meat section.please tell me where this shabad is dealing with meat issue.

bhul chuk maaf

[International Akaali]

taksal maybe in the days of baba deep singh ji had good interpertation of bani. But the bani they teach now and vichar is certainly not guru ji's. They misinterprete bani in various forms for example as the one givin above on meat. Its not just meat other ones as well.

[Gupt daasan daas]

jo rath peeveh maansa thin koi nirmal cheeth

how can th human who drinks blood, have a pur mind?

how has takal misinrpeted this shabad?

this is not only in sikhi dharm but many other dharms

and this has a sakhee behind it

i dunt remeber 100 percent

BUT

there was guru nanak dev je and bhai mardana je

and there was this qazi doing halaal

and the chicken started running around and blood got all over his clothes

and then the qazi had t change it or something cause hes like they impure now

so guru nanak dev je said if ure clothes are impure because ther is blood on them, then how cn ure mind be pure if u drink the blood of that animal, meaning eatting meat

and show daas the place where taksal has misinterpeted any shabad

taksal is known in the panth for one great thing

shudh banee and the best santhia

bhula chuka maf

[The Khalsa Fauj]

That translation of that Shabad is totally wrong. If someone knows Punjabi/Gurmukhi, then the person would know.

Here is the correct one:

If someone becomes impure by having blood on their clothing

Then how can those who drink blood of humans be pure?

This is a message to vegetarian brahmans who said meat eating is wrong.

This has also crept into Sikhism.

Who are human blood drinkers?

Those people who don't do kirt (hard work).

Those who live in mansions on money of sangat.

Those who take money from Gurudwaras and use it for person use.

These people usually run around in white clothing anf don't wear shoes. They also support round turbans.

Singh Sabha did parchaar of Sikhism and brought millions of people into Sikhism. Founder of Singh Sabha was Prof. Gurmukh SIngh. Singh Sabhians went from village to village, city to city and did parchaar. They did not take any money from people. They worked when they were not doing parchaar. They did eat food when they were doing parchaar. There is nothing wrong with that.

[Gupt daasan daas]

how did u get tha trnlation

im doing it from punjabee to

jo rath peevhi mansa think kio nirmal cheeth

jo rath peevhi mansa

the human who drinks blood

thin kio nirmal chet

how can they have a pure mind

if u REALLY dont belive me, BEST person for aarth, khalsa fauj je, u kno who, bhagth je

:wub:

bhula chuka maf

[The Khalsa Fauj]

how did u get tha trnlation

im doing it from punjabee to

jo rath peevhi mansa think kio nirmal cheeth

jo rath peevhi mansa

the human who drinks blood

thin kio nirmal chet

how can they have a pure mind

if u REALLY dont belive me, BEST person for aarth, khalsa fauj je, u kno who, bhagth je

:wub:

bhula chuka maf

114384[/snapback]

Bhagat Ji and you are same thing. Both oppose meat eating. Also Bhagat Ji got ticked off last time.

jo mean one

rat means blood

peevan means drinks

maansa means of humans (plural)

you got the second part

Also I don't need bhagat ji to do aarth. I know Punjabi. I have my dad to help me. I also have mahan kosh and Prof. Sahib Singh's teekah to rely on if I don't get someting.

[International Akaali]

:TH:

jo rath peeveh maansa thin koi nirmal cheeth

how can th human who drinks blood, have a pur mind?

how has takal misinrpeted this shabad?

this is not only in sikhi dharm but many other dharms

and this has a sakhee behind it

i dunt remeber 100 percent

BUT

there was guru nanak dev je and bhai mardana je

and there was this qazi doing halaal

and the chicken started running around and blood got all over his clothes

and then the qazi had t change it or something cause hes like they impure now

so guru nanak dev je said if ure clothes are impure because ther is blood on them, then how cn ure mind be pure if u drink the blood of that animal, meaning eatting meat

and show daas the place where taksal has misinterpeted any shabad

taksal is known in the panth for one great thing

shudh banee and the best santhia

bhula chuka maf

114373[/snapback]

why in world are you telling something that you are not even sure about. GET YOUR FACTS STARIGHT BEFORE U PRESENT SOMETHING. :TH:

[Guest Guest]

"These people usually run around in white clothing anf don't wear shoes. They also support round turbans."

thats a little harsh

but isn't the shabad is talking about people who suck HUMAN blood?

[Gupt daasan daas]

khalsa fauj je

look

jo rath peevhi mansaa

i agree that jo is one

rath is blood

peevhi is to drink

aand mansaa is humans

sooo jo rath peevhi mansaa

those humans who drink bloood

and rsingh je, when i meant i wasnt sure, was because i might miss 1 or 2 little detials

not that im making a bunch of crap up

if our clothes are polluted and unclean when blood touches them

unpure

guru je says o qazi

how can those humans who drink blood have a pure mind??

if our clothes are stained by blood, wat about our mind when we eat the blood of another animal?

jo rath peevhi maansa thin kio nirmal cheeth

it doesnt say maansa DA

or the blood OF humans

it has nothing to do with drinking HUMAN BLOOD

but if we look fromt he above thuk

how can thosse who drink blood have a pure mind?

it is talking bout the qazi, who complains his clothes have been stained by blood, but guru jesays wat bout those who drink it, how can there mind be pure?

bhula chuka maf

[kds1980]

wjkk

wjkf

gupt daasan ji just look at the lines from taksal

"If blood has stained your clothing you say your clothes have become impure. How can the thought of those who eat meat, drink blood and suck bones become pure?"

(SGGSJ Ang 140)

now look at the original line

Those who suck the blood of human beings-how can their consciousness be pure?

now please tell me why they have entered eat meat and suck bones in the shabad

any person who don't know punjabi can eaily be misguided.because from the above lines from taksal it clearly looks that that eat meat and suck bones are part

of shabad while they are not the part of shabad

bhul chuk maaf