Sikhs And Gaatraa

[Bundha]

Balbir Ji,

You have posted this topic on a number of forums but I still fail to understand what you are trying to ask? You seem to be making an issue where none exists.

What are you asking ?

[Balbir Singh]

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!

Dear Bundha Ji!

I know some Sikhs who got angry because someone touched their turban by mistake. For them the turban, gaatraa, hair-fixer etc. are also holy. And holy things are untouchable.

I find God all holy. Imagine God does not allow anyone to come near to HIM.

My question is to discuss the topic and become aware of our true values.

In my view, Gurdev gave us Kakaars to be aware of our actions and spiritual growth.

Kakaars and their keep up are not to become fanatic and expect favor belonging to a minority.

Balbir Singh

[ms514]

Sat Sri Akal:

"Janayu, dhotee, gaatraa and kachchehraa all are made of thread. Also, those are worn similarly on the body."

So...you are arguing that the Gatra and Kachera, which do have practical purposes is the same as a Janeoo, which is basically a Brahmin dog collar on a human, just because both are made of thread.

Let's extend your logic. A Kirpan and spoon are both made of metal...does that mean that I can replace the Kirpan with a spoon and deem it a Kakkar?

[Balbir Singh]

Sat Sri Akal:

Ask your helper minds and come back with a logical example.

[Akaali]

Its practical as most people have said, end of story.