Someone Saying Bibek Is "Bull****

[Guest Gupt]

Can someone please shed some light on this?

Another benti is to post this link on gurmat bibek so we can get more input from gursikhs. Daas would put it there but does not have an account there yet.

It is Guruka Singh " Eating Jhoota Food "

Sarbloh bibek has a meaning or bhai randhir singh ji would not have done it and starved himself. This video seems to think so different.

[Singhstah]

A simply disgraceful video. He clearly has no understanding whatsoever of bibek.

Caste discrimination is based on someone's birth, bibek is based on someone's actions.

He says following bibek makes people seperate, it does so no more than having a dastar and wearing the kakkars. Does he also think we should stop that?

People should refrain from acting as authorities on issues they have no clue about.

When talking about Guru Nanak Dev Ji's sakhi of the blood from food, he says Guru Nanak Dev Ji was doing it to teach those particular people, absolute rubbish as Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj says:

ਪਰਥਾਇ ਸਾਖੀ ਮਹਾ ਪੁਰਖ ਬੋਲਦੇ ਸਾਝੀ ਸਗਲ ਜਹਾਨੈ ॥

Parthā▫e sākẖī mahā purakẖ bolḏe sājẖī sagal jahānai.

Great men speak the teachings by relating them to individual situations, but the whole world shares in them.

That sakhi is proof that bibek is Gurmat, so all he can do is try to disprove that we should strive to follow it.

And on top of that hes saying Singhs ate horses when they ran out of food. Someone with such views should not be making videos, atleast on these topics. He is only correct in saying we should not eat meat.

[VanHelsingh]

There is another thread about this video. I was quite disturbed about it too.

[xtremesingh18]

I thought he was a cool guy before I saw this

[Guest 321]

If thats his view then its fine, as hes clearly backed it up ususal perfect logic.

I can also understand why so many of you took offence because you may follow food bibek or follow those who kept this, but really you should learn to respect other peoples view because otherwise when people get angry at those who dont believe in Raagmala then that it fine too.

So, people make up your mind? If its okay to get angry because someone has a different view to you on food, then it is ok to get angry on those who believe in different kakkars or Bani aswell.

Lets not be hypocripts, jaap naaam.

[Guest Guest]

If thats his view then its fine, as hes clearly backed it up ususal perfect logic.

I can also understand why so many of you took offence because you may follow food bibek or follow those who kept this, but really you should learn to respect other peoples view because otherwise when people get angry at those who dont believe in Raagmala then that it fine too.

So, people make up your mind? If its okay to get angry because someone has a different view to you on food, then it is ok to get angry on those who believe in different kakkars or Bani aswell.

Lets not be hypocripts, jaap naaam.

There is no problem in not believing in something or having a different intepretation, but to call someone else's Rehat "bull****" or "brahminism" is not acceptable. Those who do not read Raagmala do not refer to Raagmala as being "bull****" in that manner so your argument is void. Neither do those who believe Kesh as Rehat call the Keski "brahminism". Those who have differences in beliefs in Rehat do not belittle those who do differently to themselves. The key is to be respectful of others despite difference.

His logic was not "perfect" as by the Maryada of all Amrit Sanchars, regardless of the Panj's position on Bibek, consuming the Jhoota food of an Amritdhari is "acceptable", whilst consuming the Jhoota food of a non-Amritdhari makes one a Patit.

It is disappointing to see someone of the age of Guruka Singh resorting to foul language with regards to what many to believe to be a Gurmat Rehat. Only those who have practised Sarbloh Bibek will know its true value, however most Sikhs nowadays are either too attached to their convenient, tasty food, or do not have enough devotion and love for Gurmat to even try following this Rehat for some time.

[Guest h]

his view is against rehtnama, guru sahibs hukam. so how is his logic right in terms of gurmat

I'm glad I didn't show my kids this. his swearing and talking about having fun with tongues is not what I would like my kids exposed to.

loads of gursikhs from baba deep singh to modern day baba gurbachan singh kept bibek sarbloh. no doubt.

gurmuksta singh has done sangat with bhai fauja singh. he use make his only prashada etc in sarbloh. interesting how peoples views change.

[chatanga]

And on top of that hes saying Singhs ate horses when they ran out of food. Someone with such views should not be making videos, atleast on these topics.

so why should he lie about singhs eating horses, when it is established historical fact?

someone with such biased views such as yours shouldn't be a moderator either in my opinion.

i see you shut down that other thread, when people started to question your beleiefs.

[VanHelsingh]

The issue I have with the video is the aforementioned 'poo-pooing' of Nihang bibek (even though he doesn't mention names). I'm surprised at how such a huge part of Sikhi could be overlooked and reduced to 'ritual' status. As I said before, I've seen a few of Gurukha Singh's other videos and he speaks a lot of sense, but I was very surprised in this instance. I guess its his opinion and nothing more.

[Kharkooartsy]

the point of bibek is to please waheguroojee... - everything i eat is going to be food i cooked with saas giraas simran. i am not bibeki not even close... but i would never say to a bibeki that what they are doing is wrong..

i am not one of those people that bash gora sikhs concentrating more on yoga because they do more paath than i do i cant judge but this is really disturbing to see them say bibek has no meaning he is a bit too blunt about something he has no idea about..

he doesnt have to believe in it but he shouldnot be saying this (onyoutube imposing his opinion and doubts on others that listen to him) and acting as an authority..

this is beadbi!! i respect those that are bibeki!! vahegurooo...

dhan guru dhan guru pyare...