do we know Lt .Gen Sinha who refused to take part in Ghallughara Bluestar

[khalistan_zindabaad]

Yh gen sinha even had a sop in place for such times but no one followed

[chatanga]

It makes it even more outstanding that General Sinha stood upto Indira. He sounds a bit like the Nawab of Malerkotla who advised the Mughal ruler against the execution of the Sahibzadas, whilst the Hindu Ministers were in favour of the Sahibzadas execution. You can put Brar and Dyal in their place.

an excellent observation.

also, i would like to add that indira also approached a Sikh infantry unit, which were wholly from a "low-caste" because she thought they would hate the "jatt Sikhs" and attack Darbar Sahib. But their commanding officer refused to carry out an attack on "his own people" and his "own gurdwara".

[lsingh]

The evidence that Gen Sinha has provided proves that the Bluestar was an avoidable massacre, information that could be used for a ware crimes convition for those that are still alive.

When Gen Sinha mentions Gen Sunderji rubbed his chin just before he died as a beard gesture, this could be due to the Shaheed Singhs that he could see waiting for him.

[GuptUnknown]

The evidence that Gen Sinha has provided proves that the Bluestar was an avoidable massacre, information that could be used for a ware crimes convition for those that are still alive.

When Gen Sinha mentions Gen Sunderji rubbed his chin just before he died as a beard gesture, this could be due to the Shaheed Singhs that he could see waiting for him.

Jam Dhoots you mean......

[lsingh]

Jam Dhoots you mean......

Or the Shaheed Singhs that were waiting to deal with him also.

Gen Sinha also refers to Gen Shabeg Singh as his dear friend, shows humility and he does not resort to the insults that the hysterical Indian media use. Gen Sinha's plan for a peaceful resolution of the siege by using a using a security cordon, having everything filmed, using Sikh leaders to negotiate a solution were scrapped by Indira who wanted to massacre Sikhs.

[Mehtab Singh]

I read an account where it said that Indira had consulted 11 senior army officers before preparing for Bluestar. 8 of them flatly refused from attacking a place of worship. The 3 whose names will be condemned in history are the ones who came forward.

[JasSinghKhalsa]

can this video be downloaded and upoaded 3/4/5/10 times on Youtube with different titles? How to do this? If somebody know, please guide me, I will do it myself.

[MrDoaba]

can this video be downloaded and upoaded 3/4/5/10 times on Youtube with different titles? How to do this? If somebody know, please guide me, I will do it myself.

Download with Youtube Downloader and then the easiest way will be to use accounts of family and friends to upload it as many times as you need to.

You could do the same with the video from this thread as well.

[chatanga]

Gen Sinha also refers to Gen Shabeg Singh as his dear friend, shows humility and he does not resort to the insults that the hysterical Indian media use. .

If you read the story of Gen Shahbeg SIngh, you will see that he, had a very honest character, and was also looking for postive, mature progress in the indian society and its institutions. But men like him and sinha are rare, in that they refuse to compromise their principles.

It was because of Gen Shahbeg Singh's principles, that led to frivolous charges being brought against him, and his subsequent dismissal from the army. Even then he fought his case with patience, and won.