what do you think?

[kaur_khalistani_lioness]

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

I was listening to radio..and this old bajurg(baba ji) said that on Visakhi..all those people have taken amrit, it should be reviewd...are they keeping up with what they said to Guru sahib when they took amrit? if not then take that outer look(fake look) away from that person! Pakhandi..

and said "Natak cheetak..." need to be stopped!

[navdeep kaur]

waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

i think that it is a pretty good idea, but then it shud also be taken into consideration whether they are trying to do the rite thing or not...just my do paisay

waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

[`KuMi´]

I Know yea, its seems like if that happens, wow it'll be a bit stressing thou

[smartsingh24]

Who decides if " they keeping up with what they said to Guru sahib when they took amrit"? This is stupid. It's not our responsibility to make sure others are keeping rehat. The only ones who can decide that are our gurus and waheguru. We are NEITHER. Stupid comment, stupid idea, just plain stupid. It isn't up to us to do this kind of crazy stuff. Taking away people's sikhi? Think about it. That makes you even worse than the person who has failed their "review". That means that you're going to take away their kirpan, their kara, their kesh, their kanga, and their kachera. Remind you of anyone?

[ms514]

Sat Sri Akal:

You make your own mistakes, learn from them and grow. This is the idea behind Sikhism. The Punj Pyare dictate the Rehat and it is your responsibility to follow it to the best of your abilities. It is your own path and you are the only one who is going to benefit from it. But it is up to you to go as far on that path as you desire.

[Ambrosia]

I understand that it may be frustrating to see people who have the appearance, and took amrit, but who do not keep rehat...

But, it is not up to us to judge. It would be worse of us to take away their own rights...

We should not think anyone to be higher or lower, but even better would to see our own self as the lowest... then not judge anyone as lower than us...

Remember, that only by his grace, some will follow the path, and also by his own command, others wander around aimlessly.

No one is above his command.

[naam_jap]

same as above ^

[kaur_khalistani_lioness]

Waheguru JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JIKI FATEH

yea i agree with above as well!

its soo true

...it does frustratez many of the people i know...cuz they expect everything from an Amritdhari person that he/she represents...

but question comez to mind... should they...imean why shouldn't they? and what should be done?

[Ambrosia]

What to be done?

Gently, and nicely, and even without shouting or bitterness... Bring awareness around you... about rehat, about real sikhism, about the lifestyles of the pure ones.

Play some kirtan, be an example of a good gursikh, inspire others around you...