Question Bout Khalistan - Technicalities

[Hammertime007]

Lets say Khalistan is made. Lets say a Sikh living in Khalistan wants to visit a Gurdwara in Delhi would he or she need a passport to cross the boarder ? and go through immigration control ??

[proactive]

I think we need to get away from assuming that when Khalistan is created then the rest of India will remain united. The likelihood is that any state that secedes from India will create a ripple effect which will see the creation of a number of other independent countries out of India. Th edges of the Indian state will secede, states like Assam, the north eastern states like Meghalaya, Tripura, Bengal etc. In the West will be Khalistan, Gujarat. In the South Maharashta, Tamil Nadu, Andhra etc. What will be left will be a rump India made up of UP, Delhi, Bihar, Madhya, Haryana and possibly Rajasthan.

Sikhs will need passports to go and do a yatra to Delhi and Patna Sahib from the rump India. They will need another visa to go to visit Nander from a Maharashtra state etc. Same as Hindus from the rump India will need a Khalistan visa to visit Durgiana Temple and possibly Kurukshetra if the Sikh manage to include that into Khalistan.

[Hammertime007]

^^^

Fair comment ...

Also a concern is who will run our Gurdwara outside of Khalistan ie in dehli Mumbia etc, as all Sikhs living in these cities will leave dehli and Mumbia and Move to Khalistan, and Hindu Punjabis will have to leave what was Punjab. what wil happen to their Mandirs ??

I guess a simple one is housing, the Sikhs who come from dehli and mumbia to live in Khalistan can have the houses that Hindu Punjabis have vacated and vicer versea.

[proactive]

This all depends on how India breaks up. Whether it goes the Yugoslavia way, in which case different nations in each state will fight against each to get the maximum amount of territory, or it could the way of the USSR when the states declared themselves independent and there was no mass migration from one state to another. The likelihood is that the Indian establishment which is so corrupt and evil that it will make sure that when it goes down that it takes as many innocent lives with it as possible. The best outcome would be an orderly disintegration of India and minorities allowed to stay or leave without an coercion. This takes care of the question of who will look after the Gurdwaras and Mandirs.

[SikhWorldTv]

Lets not overlook Pakistan as this nation will change its relationship with Khalistan hopefully for the better and we will have more relaxed travel to our important gurdwaras in that country - and by having them as back-up India would be daft to kick off ( sorry just woke up from a fanciful dream )

[VanHelsingh]

This all depends on how India breaks up. Whether it goes the Yugoslavia way, in which case different nations in each state will fight against each to get the maximum amount of territory, or it could the way of the USSR when the states declared themselves independent and there was no mass migration from one state to another. The likelihood is that the Indian establishment which is so corrupt and evil that it will make sure that when it goes down that it takes as many innocent lives with it as possible. The best outcome would be an orderly disintegration of India and minorities allowed to stay or leave without an coercion. This takes care of the question of who will look after the Gurdwaras and Mandirs.

I think you give too much credit to the people of those states that you're hoping will want to break away from India IF Sikhs manage to wrestle into a position for gaining Khalistan. Most people are more worried about being fed and keeping a roof over their head than any idealistic fight for freedom, which'll most probably lead to years of unrest and instability. Indians are an apathetic lot.

[Hammertime007]

This all depends on how India breaks up. Whether it goes the Yugoslavia way, in which case different nations in each state will fight against each to get the maximum amount of territory, or it could the way of the USSR when the states declared themselves independent and there was no mass migration from one state to another. The likelihood is that the Indian establishment which is so corrupt and evil that it will make sure that when it goes down that it takes as many innocent lives with it as possible. The best outcome would be an orderly disintegration of India and minorities allowed to stay or leave without an coercion. This takes care of the question of who will look after the Gurdwaras and Mandirs.

Are you saying its not compulsary for Delhi Sikhs to leave delhi and live in Khalistan ??

Alot of Sikhs would have to live mumbia dehli hayranya up etc to boost up Sikhs numbers in Khalistan and non Sikhs to leave Khalistan.

Would Sikhs be prepared to leave Dehli as they have big business there like transport etc

[13Mirch]

When the movement starts than a quite a lot of individuals will jump on the pro-bandwagon. For now most of them are concerned about surviving the Indian state's power cuts.

[JasSinghKhalsa]

Lets say Khalistan is made. Lets say a Sikh living in Khalistan wants to visit a Gurdwara in Delhi would he or she need a passport to cross the boarder ? and go through immigration control ??

Delhi will be part of Khalistan . Please read history of Baba Baghel Singh, Lal Kila pehlaan vi FATEH kita si, read history of Mori Gate, Mithai Pul etc. We fought and won back land where existing Gurudwara Sis Ganj Sahib, Gurudwara Rakab Ganj stands.

All Land where Guru Sahiban (from 1st to 10th either lived or visited) would be part of KHALISTAN, including Hazur Sahib, Bidar Sahib, Patna Sahib and even land which has been siezed from us such as Nankana Sahib, Panja Sahib etc. Aim at STARS. I am not being thereotical, but just trying to say, let's not constrain ourselves to a 250 KM territory.

[Hammertime007]

I cant see khalistan going as far as patna sahib. I wod around haryna. As for dehli who wants it anyway its a smelly dump !""