Jhatka - The Sikh Method Of Slaughter Vs Halal/kosher...

[Mahakaal96]

can someone please tell me what the last atrocity or crime the nihangs stopped is? im sure they must be stopping lots of evil doers considering how many goats they kill for practicing their awe-inspiring warrior skills.

Can someone tell me the last time amritdhari singhs who wear a kirpan stopped any major crime or atrocity. I'm sure they stop lots of evil doers seeing as they walk around with a shaaster on? Should stop wearing kirpans as we are in peace times or time of political war so might as well take our kirpans off mindset will be spread by missionaries and their supporters soon.

If Nihang singhs and their maryada bothers others so much then why not do something, they don't hide or hold Nihang only smagams or akhand paths, they openly do jhatka at anandpur sahib every holla mohalla and openly do jhatka almost daily at hazoor sahib.

I guess Giani thakur Singh who spent years learning at taksal under baba gurbachan Singh, baba kartar Singh and lived alongside baba jarnail Singh must not know what he is talking about? He has studied gurmat his whole life and has a wider spectrum that incorporates SGGS, Dasam granth, bhai gurdas ji, puratan rehitnamas and historical Granths not to mention countless other sources of gyan but I suppose his view doesn't count.

[Singh559]

I agree with dasamsarblohgranth veer ji. Current sri akaal takth sahib maryada need to be revamped regarding meat..It's need to reformed from making jhatka meat available to all to only nihangs as there is martial/ deep philosophical/symbolism behind nihang doing jhatka rather than some uncle tom harry doing jhatka and eating jhatka.

No it shouldn't, it's not only for Nihangs. Read puratan sources it wasn't just people in Nihang Dals who did jhatka. I agree householder should be vegetarian ideally for many reasons including ethical and environmental.

If someone isn't a nihang and they're in a survival situation or in war they aren't going to be like; "flana singh said only Nihangs are allowed to."

Labels are ridiculous. Only true real Nihang Singhs in the latter part of last century was Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindranwale and the shaheed Singhs.

At the end of the day for me Gurbani is supreme and I don't think we should debate this as Akaal Takhat sahib already resolved this issue.

[MOD]

Please read the forum rules. This thread is now closed.