Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Sarangi has no frets so it takes ages to learn to find the correct position of the notes.

Also on sarangi have to find the notes by the edge of your nail so quite hard to learn.

Dilruba has frets and you pick out the notes by just pressing behind each fret to easier to learn.

like veer ji says and Professor Surinder SIngh confirmed to me when I asked him personally which order/instrument to study first that dilruba is best starting point because of fret positions being marked then Saranda will be easier .

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

I love the sound of the Sarangi, also Playing dilruba, esraj, taus, my finger tips used to ache pushing down on the strings (it pains avoid lol). So i preferred the sarangi. With the sarangi you push your nails against the strings causing no pain. The strings are not wires so they dont mess up the nails as they made from sheep intestines.

Also to get around finding the notes as theres no frets. I used a pencil to mark lines for Sa, ra, ga, ma notes just below and by the side of the strings, once the instrument is tuned up that is. This helps a great deal if you are beginning.

The saranda if i can remember correctly, is similar to sarangi so if you know one the other is not hard to play. But i believe its harder to see where your fingers are placed.as its a wider bodied instrument compared to sarangi. So you have to pop your head around more to see strings. Saranda looks beautiful little harder to hold as its round on the bottem where as Sarangi has edges.

Hope that helps

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks to everyone for replying. It seems most people are learning dilruba. I have noticed very few people learn the Sarandha which was Gurus own instrument or even rabab which was Sikhism's first instrument.

Sarangi, we have so many Singhs in the Panth who can play this instrument due to the Dhadis. But surprisingly no one ever uses it for Kirtan even though it has the most beautiful sound. Wonder why..

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

main reason is it began to be associated with tawaif nachna in post sikh raj era in Indian minds (bollywood) instead of dhadi vaaran, funny how the harmonium also became foisted on us(from those nefarious uses) by the firangi in place of our own deep expressive instruments . I prefer the sound of the Saranda as it is mellow and rich although the dilruba is beautiful too . It is sad to think that even whilst in the midst of wars the Guru's SIkhs learnt full raag Kirtan on Tanti Saaz and Pakwaj , and we has no such pressures on life and limb and we say it is too hard to take time to learn and play kirtan in Guru ji's intended way .

We should promote itihaas learning through dhadi vaaran , by showcasing the style and give the youth an idea how our ancestors preserved history through poetry and music . This will counter the anti -maa boli rhetoric going on I've heard apne saying stupid things like Punjabi is so rough a language , it has no true great literature written in it , only illiterate villagers speak Punjabi.

Dhadi Vaaran are like our rapping ...without the foul language and misogynistic angle...we should help our panth understand just how sophisticated our musical heritage level was and is. Perhaps do Local language translations of famous Dhadi vaar performances .

Yes you are right penji.

Punjabi in pure (theth) form is the Punjabi that I've been brought up with and its a shame the upcoming generations belittle it. But what do they know, hey? ? Modern de lagde. Nowadays people are mixing Hindi with it, trying to be all Bollywood.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes you are right penji.

Punjabi in pure (theth) form is the Punjabi that I've been brought up with and its a shame the upcoming generations belittle it. But what do they know, hey? Modern de lagde. Nowadays people are mixing Hindi with it, trying to be all Bollywood.

problem is Bollywood is openly a prostitution industry now , do we really want our youth taking cues from them ?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Wanted to bump this topic.

Does anyone know where to get affordable instruments on a budget while not sacrificing quality of instrument? Also I have been casually on the lookout for local teachers for last couple years in central valley, but so far I haven't really seen anyone who teaches Gurmat Sangeet Vidya properly.

Would love to try to get into it as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I never said anything about life for Sikhs in the UK in the 70s, I was talking about the present day. I understand and respect the struggles that you all went through to get to the position where you are today. But I hope you all don't lose sight of the fact that the freedom and status that Sikhs enjoy in the UK today is very far from the norm. Sikhs in the US today are fighting battles that were settled in the UK decades ago (and without the benefit of a population density that gives Sikhs in the UK at least some visibility and political sway). But forget about the US. You don't have to go that far, you can just cross the English channel and see how precarious the position of Sikhs is in continental Europe. Thanks for giving details about the grooming issue. Do you think this had to do with Labour being more concerned about the Muslim vote (as Muslims former a larger voting block than Sikhs) or political correctness? Or both? I concede that leftists sometimes go to far with political correctness and "canceling" in order to try to show how "fair" and "unbigoted" they are. I am not going to question your take on the whole grooming issue. You know more about that than I do. But that seems to be a very specific situation in the UK. I stand by my general point that left-leaning people are by far the most likely to support the rights of vulnerable minorities (which is the category that Sikhs fall under almost everywhere).   I don't buy your point about a backlash to "wokeness" at all. I don't think that that is what is causing the growing popularity of far-right movements. The way information is shared and distorted today is radically different from what was the norm not very long ago, and that has been the game-changer that has led to today's division and polarization. You seem to think that if the "woke" people would just be quiet, the racists would not have a "rallying cry". That is simply not true. First of all, those people will ALWAYS find something to complain about. (That has certainly been true throughout American history. If it has been less true in UK history, that is probably because the white British majority did not feel threatened by a sizable minority until relatively recently. See my second point.) Second of all, the complaints of the more hardcore right-wing racists increasingly resonate with the more "passive" racists as the majority community diminishes in size and feels more threatened. And third of all, as I alluded to before, today's media/information landscape will allow for any complaints to blow up and go viral.   Any time anyone from the non-majority community asks for anything, no matter how reasonable, there is going to be a backlash from the majority community. And in many instances, the non-majority community doesn't even have ask for anything or complain about anything to provoke a backlash. Their mere existence is enough. This is what history has shown us.
    • Guest free
    • And people want to talk about poverty, look at how India was stripped of wealth. Here 2800 silver bars were taken for ww2 but didn't make it back here. Now that they've found it, look at what they are doing with it. The pillaging is still going on.      Treasure from the deep: Thousands of silver bars that were meant to fund Britain's WWII effort but were sunk by German U-boat FINALLY reach their destination - and will be sold as coins Merchant ship carrying silver from India for the war effort was sunk in 1941 Its cargo of 2,800 bars of silver has sat on the bed of the Atlantic ever since Record-breaking bid to salvage the silver from three miles down a success The Royal Mint is now making the metal into coins to remember the tragedy https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2596785/Thousands-silver-bars-sunken-WWII-ship-sold-coins.html
    • I was reading something on the internet and came across this article and thought it may be of some interest to everyone here regarding their perspective on the impact of brutalities of colonisation upon India and its people.  Here is the link:-   https://www.myindiamyglory.com/2019/03/10/atrocities-on-indian-women-and-india-by-british-during-their-rule/     Atrocities on Indian Women and India by British During ... - myIndiamyGlory 10 Mar 2019 — Raped Indian women were forcefully made prostitutes by British Christians. Prostitution houses were set up by the Britishers in 350   
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use