Why Have Brar Kp Gill Bitta & Others Not Been Excommunicated From Sikhism

[jassa]

The second and last reply to this topic should be ONLY amritdhari sikhs can be excommunicated by akal takth sahib ...

[Guest PunjabSingh]

Fateh parwaan karro jiyo,

Lack of unity in the Panth. Imagine Chandhok who was the President of Delhi Gurudwara Prabhandak Committee gave a Siropa to Tytler! Not that Badal and gang are any less. All misuse religion to further their political goals.

The creation of a SGPC is Haryana will just compound the fractionism.

And if you ask me by their actions they excommunicated themselves.

Guru Rakha

The reason why Jhinda and others are demanding seperate Haryana Committee is this b l o o d y corrupt Badal.

The day Badal's chamchaas are removed from SGPC everything will be alright .

Badal has committed so many anti Sikh acts but he has never been called to Akal Takht.Badal has a habit of calling any Anti Badal person to the Akal Takht through Mukh sevadaar of Akal Takht who is chosen by him.Why are you silent on Badal ?

[lsingh]

Fateh parwaan karro jiyo,

Lack of unity in the Panth. Imagine Chandhok who was the President of Delhi Gurudwara Prabhandak Committee gave a Siropa to Tytler! Not that Badal and gang are any less. All misuse religion to further their political goals.

The creation of a SGPC is Haryana will just compound the fractionism.

And if you ask me by their actions they excommunicated themselves.

Guru Rakha

The reason why Jhinda and others are demanding seperate Haryana Committee is this b l o o d y corrupt Badal.

The day Badal's chamchaas are removed from SGPC everything will be alright .

Badal has committed so many anti Sikh acts but he has never been called to Akal Takht.Badal has a habit of calling any Anti Badal person to the Akal Takht through Mukh sevadaar of Akal Takht who is chosen bt him.Why are you silent on Badal ?

So basically the RSS controls Badal, who controls the AKali party, SGPC and Akal Takht. No wonder we are stuck in small controversies and fight amongst ourseleves instead of dealing with the source of the problems.

[Guest PunjabSingh]

Fateh parwaan karro jiyo,

Lack of unity in the Panth. Imagine Chandhok who was the President of Delhi Gurudwara Prabhandak Committee gave a Siropa to Tytler! Not that Badal and gang are any less. All misuse religion to further their political goals.

The creation of a SGPC is Haryana will just compound the fractionism.

And if you ask me by their actions they excommunicated themselves.

Guru Rakha

The reason why Jhinda and others are demanding seperate Haryana Committee is this b l o o d y corrupt Badal.

The day Badal's chamchaas are removed from SGPC everything will be alright .

Badal has committed so many anti Sikh acts but he has never been called to Akal Takht.Badal has a habit of calling any Anti Badal person to the Akal Takht through Mukh sevadaar of Akal Takht who is chosen bt him.Why are you silent on Badal ?

So basically the RSS controls Badal, who controls the AKali party, SGPC and Akal Takht. No wonder we are stuck in small controversies and fight amongst ourseleves instead of dealing with the source of the problems.

Yes,We Sikhs (particularly those living in foreign countries)must remember that each time we say something against any fellow Sikh any where whatever may be the reason we are in fact encouraging the baahmanvaadi agenda and moving a step forward to another genocide of the Sikhs here in Punjab.

[vikramjitsingh]

Fateh parwaan karro jiyo,

In my opinion Jinda ji has tacit support from the Congress. No wonders Hooda is all charged up to give in to his demand. I think many in Congress would like to see the authority of SGPC undermined. For two reasons.... one it affects Sikhs and secondly it hits out at Badal.

Congress and Akalis are two sides of the same coin. I say this because both can hurt Sikhi for political gains.

Badal and Amrinder same thing,

Dono hann nakli Singh.

Guru Rakha

[lsingh]

Santa Singh leader of the Budha Dal group of Nihangs was excommunicated in 1984 by the entire Sikh Community for working for Indira Gandhi after Bluestar. Sikhs were outraged that Santa Singh was working to help Indira after she had destoyed the Akal Takht and massacred thousands of Sikhs.

[vikramjitsingh]

Fateh parwaan karro jiyo,

Yes Santa a pal of Buta Singh undertook to rebuild Akal Takht. And the most hilarious sight was an overweight Santa moving about in the Parikrama with a flunky laborously moving a air cooler on wheels so that Santa could get some respite from the heat. And Dordarshan which was and is controlled by the Government showed as if the Government was rebuilding Akal Takht which was destroyed by the Sikhs themselves.

And words cannot explain the emotions of Sikhs when they were allowed to enter Darbaar Sahib.

Guru Rakha

[SarabhaPanjab]

I think you have to have been involved in the Panth, or involved in Panthic activities.. then you can be excommunicated. Otherwise the list would be endless of all those "self proclaimed sikhs" who have disgraced the panth.