Poll: Best Sikh Leader Right Now In India?

[dasmesh_regiment]

sarpanch with all due respect, do you know anything about sikh political history in late 1980's and early 1990's?

Mann, with a backing of the majority of people who voted in punjab did NOT call for Khalistan. Instead after he was released by RAJIV GANDHI in 1989 he won an election and subsquently he went to talk to the government for peace. In 1991 he held talks with VP Singh government - hence the Babbar Khalsa called him a sell out.

From a position of power - he let us down. Badal was then able to take control of the majority of Akali voters who saw Mann as unable to be strong and "extreme". Akali voters then became moderates as they saw that Mann did not have the stomach for a fight.

How many shaheed families has Mann been to meet? Bittu sees them every week.

Did Mann support Shaheed Beant Singh's family? No, the Taksal did.

think before you speak.

[S1ngh]

How he was able to come out of jail ??

[er_gurjot]

sorry for goin off the track.. but is it necessary that the leader who sees the families of millitants aka jujharoo singhs is better leader?

humble benti.. can sangat find difference between

Mohammad Ali Jinah and master tara singh?

nehru and badal?

if yes so is the difference between mann and bittu.

[dasmesh_regiment]

I mention the fact that Bittu visits ex militants houses because, for example - family of Shaheed Major Baldev Singh Ghuman openly have said that Mann did not visit them at any time.

Other shaheed families have said the same. Mann alientated many shaheed families who should have been honoured. this way he lost their support.

Bittu goes to see them - gives them pride in what their families did for us.

Mann does not. Mann has no grass roots connection.

[Inder Singh]

I mention the fact that Bittu visits ex militants houses because, for example - family of Shaheed Major Baldev Singh Ghuman openly have said that Mann did not visit them at any time.

Other shaheed families have said the same. Mann alientated many shaheed families who should have been honoured. this way he lost their support.

Bittu goes to see them - gives them pride in what their families did for us.

Mann does not. Mann has no grass roots connection.

Biuttu gets married,A dead cat Sukhwinder Sukhi who has killed many sikh boys in collabaration with police attend s his marriage.What does it say?

[suchasingh]

I mention the fact that Bittu visits ex militants houses because, for example - family of Shaheed Major Baldev Singh Ghuman openly have said that Mann did not visit them at any time.

Other shaheed families have said the same. Mann alientated many shaheed families who should have been honoured. this way he lost their support.

Bittu goes to see them - gives them pride in what their families did for us.

Mann does not. Mann has no grass roots connection.

you said bittu gives them pride in what their families did. This is load of bull, bittu has given up on the cause for which those Singhs became Shaheed for so infact he has given those families a slap on the face.

When bittu came into Akali Dal Amritsar his first wish was for the party to drop the demand of Khalistan.

And tell us was it not bittus so called panthic committee which slandered Shaheed Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal? called him agent of the congress. I think his Shaheedi proves otherwise.

Some History on bittu:

First Panthic committee was formed by Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal by Sarbat Khalsa in 1986. bittus boys didnt like this so went against Sarbat Khalsa and made their own.

Known traitor and member of bittu panthic committee dr. sohan singh gives up and lives normal life in punjab. when bittu was first arrested whos house was he arrested from? thats right the traitor dr. sohan singh who had already given up. what was bittu doing there?

Then bittu gets outta jail. can you tell us how this happened? Is the explanation of rulda singh of the rss true? or this that just lies, because everything he said in that recording has happened word for word. these recording can be heard on Panthic Weekly News. www.panthic.org

now he forms KAC, which you say is another panthic committee, what was need for this when majority of the members of his panthic committtee are alive and well and some even settled in foreign countries.

can bittu explain his relation with police cat sukhi? we all know how the story was put out in the newspapers, to date there hasnt been a logical explanation.

can bittu explain the panga he cause in Akali Dal Amritsar. bittus whole dirty game was explained by a close associate of his, Bhai Resham Singh. Can you please comment on this video:

http://www.sikhclips.com/view_video.php?vi...e0ca9a15b615367

there are also many complaints on bittus dealing during the first uprising againt dera sauda guys. when sangat had surrounded the dera at night it was bittu and dhumma the homo sexual saadh who had reached there and convinced the sangat to wait till morning to attack the dera. why was this? cause they were causing a delay so that crpf, police, and bsf could show up and save the baba.

also didnt bittu and dhumma group go have talks with ram rehim?

there is much more that you as a die hard supporter of bittu and bittu himself needs to explain before majority of sangat can accept him as a clean supporter of the Panth. Because u can see there are one too many allegations againt him.

Note: I dont have anything personal against him nor am i with any opposing party just some things need to be cleared up.

[sikhizindabad]

The political battles are won based on strategy. Not on emotional narrya bazi or ranting on small issues.Any person who delivers is winner. It can be Mann sahib or it can be bittu or anyone. Let see how things develop in future.

In sikhsiyasat site. I did see lot many videos the way bittu is in fore-front in applying balm on the families who give theirs sons. That's appear good. It makes people confident. I see bittu conducting Seminars in Chandigarh with students & intellectuals . Again is thoughtful collective approach.

I wish similar strategy could be being pursue by Mann sahib. At the moment all I see in their videos at akalidalamritsar site Is street fighting in anandpur sahib or rally where their blasted everyone.

One thing both sites can do is to put English translations in each of the videos so that wider audience at international level can Understand as what is happening.

[SaRpAnCh]

Maan is the Man,

SS Maan will make his return big time very soon a true lion

[Inder Singh]

<<<<The political battles are won based on strategy. Not on emotional narrya bazi or ranting on small issues.Any person who delivers is winner. It can be Mann sahib or it can be bittu or anyone. Let see how things develop in future.>>>

What political experienece this bittu the act has.He is a kid of yeasterday.Can he match Mann .Did you watch video that shows Mann thundering in Parlaiment when presenting sikh case.I put it a few days back.

[dasmesh_regiment]

mann's recent speeches have shown he has lost it. those speeches in parliament are meaningless now and were mainly laughed at by other MP's - in any case what did they actually achieve? what did he achieve by not going into parliament without his kirpan - what did he do when he went to USA in 2000? did he get on the plane with his kirpan?

what did he achieve by saying bad things abou bhagat singh? all he did was alienate the majority of normal punjabis who see him as a hero - how can this guy be elected if he is prone to saying stupid things like that?

we all know mann's family history -we all know what his grandfather did and how mann is related to captain arminder singh. mann is landed gentry - full of ego.

mann screwed his chance over 18 years ago. HE IS THE ONE WHO WENT FOR TALKS WITH VP SINGH GOVERNMENT not Bittu when the Singhs had the majority of votes - so who messed up? WHY DOES NO-ONE mention that Mann went for talks with the government in early 1990's? THIS IS FACT. Read any book - Pettigrew mentions it, Mahmood mentions it. The Babbar Khalsa in Wangar June 1991 edition specifically say Mann has SOLD OUT Khalistan. BKI still say this to this day - are you saying BKI and Wadawa Singh are traitors?

you accuse Bittu of all these things without any actual evidence - sukhi cat went to his wedding - what does this actually show? Arminder Singh has visited Mann several times in the past few years - so what?

Bittu was released from jail, so was MANN!!! HOW MANY TIMES HAS MANN BEEN RELEASED FROM JAIL in the past 24 years!!!!???!?!

Sohan Singh, Bittu and Panjwar were part of the 2nd Panthic Committee - Sohan Singh is sitting happy in Chandigarh I accept this, Bittu was in jail for 15 years, Panjwar is in Pakistan - what does this show? Nothing! Satinderpal Gill was also a member of the 2nd Panthic Committee - he is leader of ISYF in Canada - is also a traitor then? Avtar Brahma was also a member of the 2nd Panthic Committee - dare you to call him a traitor!!

When Bittu was released from jail, he didnt go to Sohan Singh's house, in fact he was never arrested there. I dont know how or from where you have made this up! According to panthic.org he stayed at the same house that Sohan Singh had stayed in. Gama who was with him is brother in law to sukha and jinda - are you calling Gama a traitor too?!!!?! someone who has spent 10 years in jail for no crime whatsoever? In any case do you accept panthic.org as gospel?

You believe RULDA ? good for you. Tomorrow he could say Mann is RSS and he secured his release from jail all those times?!!! on this logic, Mann is Congress as Chandra Sekhar released Mann in 1980's and 1990's.

Bittu has praised Manochahal in a speech recently - he went to his shaheedi smagam this year. goto his website and have a look and listen. Was MANN there? NO!

Resham Singh video is his opinion - Bittu has openly called for Khalistan just like Mann - both have been to jail recently for this - so what Resham Singh says does not really tie in with this.

At the end of the day, Mann wants to promote his OWN SON JUST LIKE BADAL and got jealous when Bittu became popular when Mann was in jail.

Why is Mann's SON so prominent in his party? What has HE done?

Just as you have many qns about BITTU, the list is endless for Mann.