Why Do Some Sikhs Dismiss The Sikh Call For Independence From India

[Guest]

7 hours ago, KhoonKaBadlaKhoon2 said:

Nuclear super powers of the world will not go to war anytime soon. They'll have a skirmish, battle here and then, chest thumping essentially. 

That's what we often think. But I think world is increasingly becoming volatile

[KhoonKaBadlaKhoon2]

3 hours ago, AjeetSingh2019 said:

That's what we often think. But I think world is increasingly becoming volatile

Are you not the same Ajeet from Delhi or something who used to complain that his coworkers bullied him?

[puzzled]

14 hours ago, KhoonKaBadlaKhoon2 said:

Pakistans different regions also have their own spoken languages however, sindhi etc. People of those provinces do attach to their regional identity, which has also led to the militant movements there. That's a whole different issue though. 

I will admit they are losing Punjabi language. But, the anthem is not in Persian. Urdu as a language is quite hybrid, hence the similarities. 

Amritsar came to be a few centuries ago. Western Punjab had most of the early day settlements. If anything, Punjabi was from modern day Pakistan. I'm trying to say dividing their history is ludicrous. Their histories are very much tied in together. Their histories being tied, the border not having existed before the creation of Urdu makes it silly to say Urdu is foreign. It existed there for centuries prior. 

Areas such as Sind have their own legendary historical figures as well. Indians having pride in their region isn't quite Indian pride then, especially in you consider the conflicts it has created. 

In the end, yes Pakistan does have many issues. But, so does your India. Especially as they modernize, turn to English and Western culture. 

The entire Paki Punjab does not even have a single Punjabi news paper, even the "punjabi" news channels are in urdu. Punjabi is considered the language of unpadhs and pendus. There videos of Lahore uni students saying how their friends laugh at them when they speak Punjabi and that even the lecturers at the uni tell them it doesn't look nice when you speak Punjabi. Instead they are replacing it with Urdu.

In 2018 Punjabi Pakis were still debating if they should name a chowk after Shaheed Bhagat Singh, yet they have missiles named after foreigners who invaded their land.

Paki Punjabis see the invasions and achievements of foreigners like Ghazni and Abadali as their own achievements and accomplishments! They are so deluded that all over the internet they are hyping over the foreign invasions as their own    they genuinely believe the invasion of Abdali was a pakistani invasion lol! 

You dnt see the Persians or afghans hyping over Ghazni   whys that?   in fact the iranians are still butt hurt over the arab invasion. 

Most paki Punjabis claim to be descendants of arbas, persians, turks, mughals etc.   A Qureshi ex paki muslim on youtube took a DNA test and he didnt even have 1% Arab in him despite paki Qureshis claiming to be Arab descendants 

The Basant kite flying festival of Pakistan is Banned and under debate because it is not Islamic, yet their ancestors been celebrating Basant for 1000s of years, Yet they have a entire mohalla called heera mandi with dancing kanjris on sale. 

Jinnah, the father of Pakistan was a Sunni and today Sunnis are persecuted in pakistan and considered kafirs lol

And the anthem is in Persain, though they like to say it is Urdu. So your telling me you understand the anthem? read the roman translation. 

If this is not a identity crisis then what is it? 

are you a Khalistani?