Hypothetical Question about Khalistan

[Guest]

If Khalistan became independent tomorrow, what would daily life be like within the country?

[sat]

Better Question who would run it, government Badal/ sgpc ? !!

I still want Khalistan dont get me wrong, your own home is always better than renting !

WJKK WJKF

[TheFancyBanana]

If Khalistan became independent tomorrow, what would daily life be like within the country?

Like anyother country....?

Better Question who would run it, government Badal/ sgpc ? !!

I still want Khalistan dont get me wrong, your own home is always better than renting !

WJKK WJKF

That is a good question. WHO would run it? We can't control a gurdwara without fighting. What do you think would happen if they had a country?

[Akal Warrior]

Honestly, I don't think this is going to be a reality any time soon. Let's think about this logically, not emotionally. Sikhs make up less then 2% of the population of India. Minus the radhaswamis, nirankaris, dera worshippers, non religious punjabi... The numbers are down to less then 1%. Out of them, consider how many people actually want their own homeland... And I bet you are down to 0.001 percent of the Indian population who want it.

Now thinking logically and with reason, the chances of this being a reality because of a very small group of individuals, is next to impossible. It's just not possible. Making a new country is not a small thing. I think focus needs to be put on better education, fighting drug addiction, poverty, corruption etc. Instead of wasting time on something that will probably never happen.

[Jonny101]

Honestly, I don't think this is going to be a reality any time soon. Let's think about this logically, not emotionally. Sikhs make up less then 2% of the population of India. Minus the radhaswamis, nirankaris, dera worshippers, non religious punjabi... The numbers are down to less then 1%. Out of them, consider how many people actually want their own homeland... And I bet you are down to 0.001 percent of the Indian population who want it.

Now thinking logically and with reason, the chances of this being a reality because of a very small group of individuals, is next to impossible. It's just not possible. Making a new country is not a small thing. I think focus needs to be put on better education, fighting drug addiction, poverty, corruption etc. Instead of wasting time on something that will probably never happen.

Right now the way things look, Khalistan seems next to impossible. But circumstances can occur which can make the establishment of Khalistan possible. Just look at the examples of the former Soviet Union(a super power!) and Yugostavia, no one in those countries would have thought that those countries would break apart, but they did creating many new countries. We should not be surprised to see multi ethnic nations like India and Pakistan break up in the future even if things do not appear as so currently. This has been the cycles of multi ethnic countries since the start of history. Who knows, maybe one day all of India might become Khalistan when Hindus and Muslims of India become Sikhs.

[Mehtab Singh]

one day all of India might become Khalistan when Hindus and Muslims of India become Sikhs.

That is bound to happen.

[Gurpreet14]

Khalistan would be heaven if n only if GURU GOBIND SINGH G runs it :D :D

[Guest]

I believe that Khalistan isnt gonna happen anytime soon...I wish it would happen but in all reality it ain't.

What I do believe is that there will be a Khalistan but it won't be limited to only Punjab.It wall span across the whole world.My reference is Karninama and a sakhi in sau sakhi.

I do not know when this will happen though.

I also despise the word Khalistan...It rhymes with Pakistan or Afghanistan etc lol

[Guest]

Another thing is...Are we really deserving a Khalistan?What have we done to earn it?Most of the punjabis are not even Amritdhari...Tge punjabi kids are shooting drugs in there veins..Are they deserving of a Khalistan?Even if we do have a khalistan where would you put the druggie kids?What rules would we have?Would we have a government?

If we have a government then it will be the same as badal...I want a Khalistan which has no government,no elections,no jobs but listening to gurus bhachans etc.Is my vision of khalistan possible?

You tell me these couple of things:Are we deserving?Would we have a government?Wiuld everyone be an amritdhari?

I think we defiantly are not deserving but I would love to hear your input.

[Gurkukar]

Khalistan is not too far if u hv sabat surat gursikh youth but unfortunatly is it there in india ??