Jump to content

is dhunda doing katha in delhi gurudwara anymore?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 130
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

See this is the thing. People who are against Dasam Bani have very superficial knowledge of Dasam Bani to begin with yet they will already make up their mind it is not bani. One must study about a sub

Most people who called him here in Fresno regret or will regret calling him because they are slowly starting to find out that youth, even those from the Gurdwaras they attend won't allow it and will o

Uklondonsikh I just forget to rebut one of your baseless accusations.You wrote how can Guru sahib write charitropakhayan at age of 9.When you were shown that he was 30 when he wrote charitropakhayan

this is the reason this duhnda is getting famous .............

no need to watch tv serials ( saas bahu ) .... coz dhunda cover all these stories in his katha.....

Delhi Gurudawara committee was under control of Congress thugs through their tout parmjit Sarna. He was doing what was said to

him to do.

He banned Dasam bani from Delhi gurudawaras.

He brought in Darshan Ragi to do propaganda against Dasam bani.

He made missionary Tarsem singh . a kala afghana and spokesman follower as head of Dharam parchar committee.

He brought all these unread missionaries dhunhda, ex policeman sabhra, old head Gurbachan panwan, jagtar jachak, shivteg etc etc. to spread venom from the stage of Gurudawaras for years on.

Previous to that kala afghana books were banned from Delhi gurudawara premises and surjit missionary was not allowed

to hold book stalls there to sell missionary literature. I think that time Avatar singh Hit was the man who banned them.

Sikh sangat taught Sarna and congress a lesson and gave them crushing defeat. Present President stated after election that ban of dasam bani in Delhi Gurudwaras was under a deep rooted conspiracy. he said that he used to read Dasam bani shabads himself in Gurudawras when he was a young boy. He seems to be a sensible man and will not allow cult of missionaries to carry out their nefarious anti sikh designs inside our Gurudwaras.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

i've tried listen his katha twice ( he have no rass or atmik shanti in his katha )

1st time wen i tried his katha ...he said eat meat ... even guru nanak never said no to meat ......BUS DIL SAAF RAKHO.....

2nd time ......he was telling how saas and bahu should behave and how kitchen should be run , how should they both live together and do shopping together and how they should make food ....and most important they should make husbands happy ......OMG

is this gurmat teaching?

thats why innocent people get trapped .....and dey belive DHUNDA SHAHIB is very awesome .....

and wen ppl are trapped ...they start brain washing process......

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

P9 = we all expected him not doing katha anymore in delhi gurudwara ( i think bangla sahib)

P9 = so in he still doing katha?

UK = He is there less at the moment as a direct consequence of the political calculations by which Sant Samaj (who oppose him) have to be kept sweet by Badal camp. However, he and others like him will be back at Sri Bangla Sahib by public demand from local Sangat - of that I'm pretty sure.

In my opinion not. Delhi committee president had issued statement that no disrespect direct or indirect will be allowed in Delhi Gurudawaras towards bani of Dasam Granth sahib.Also katha will be gurmat based and not slander or criticism based.

In my opinion their days are over.They are not kathakars but were promoted by congress agent Sarna against sikh principles.

UK = Obviously Paji it was inevitable in the short term that only those agreeable to Sant Samaj would be permitted after the (positive)changeover at DSGMC. I personally oppose Sarna and am glad that the far better Manjit Singh GK has come to the fore, as Sarna's links with Congress and Ponty Chadha clearly disqualified from holding such a post. The disgraceful scenes at Bangla Sahib in recent months were clearly Sarna's doing so good riddance. However, if kathakars are given an opportunity (most likely as you suggest by Sarna to ruffle Badal's feathers) then anti-Congress kathakars like Dhunda Sahib and Panthpreet Singh Khalsa can't be blamed for that.

P9 = 1st time wen i tried his katha ...he said eat meat ... even guru nanak never said no to meat ......BUS DIL SAAF RAKHO.....

UK = P9 Paji yet again you're misrepresenting his position. I don't eat meat despite having his heard his katha a few times and nor do I intend to change from that. All that is being said is that the Khalsa Fauj is not restricted to vegetarian bhojan in the absence of non-meat food being available. So if the Khalsa Fauj only have access to meat during battle or tribes living in the jungle without convenient supermarkets nearby eat non-vegetarian food, we shouldn't judge them over that but analyse what Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj's position was about those that avoid meat but make other human beings lives a living hell.

UK = As for the clip, yet again I see nothing anti-Sikh or atheist about it and good on Dhunda Sahib for criticising the musical dogs that deliberately promote jaath-paath, alcohol, disrespect for women etc in their records (often famously for a Muslim Jatt record label from Birmingham in the UK)

Link to post
Share on other sites

UK = P9 Paji yet again you're misrepresenting his position. I don't eat meat despite having his heard his katha a few times and nor do I intend to change from that.

VEERJI I DISAGREE ... with u on meat ...but i've seen sikh sangat stopped doing amritvela simran... which they were doing for many years ...... all they were in guru's bana ...and now they stopped wearing dummale ......after listening DHUNDA SAHIB in canada .....

kise nu vi guru to todoge .... narak vich sadoge

UK = As for the clip, yet again I see nothing anti-Sikh or atheist about it and good on Dhunda Sahib for criticising the musical dogs that deliberately promote jaath-paath, alcohol, disrespect for women etc in their records (often famously for a Muslim Jatt record label from Birmingham in the UK)

i'm not saying its anti-sikh .... but this is not Gurmat katha ...... gurudwara is for gurmat katha ......... not for saas bahu stories .........

U KNOW i've never seen him doing deep gurmat veechar ........ ( jisnu sunn'na vi aukha hai )

speaking of all these subject is not kaatha ...... and he is famous ....coz he is a story teller............and not gurmat

AND ONE THING MORE .... let me type his exact words in meat katha ........

" guru nanak ne kithe keha hai ...ke meat na khao .........gurupyareo je meat khanna hai ta khao .....bus dil saaf rakho........"

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

P9 Paji you're my brother in the Panth so I won't argue with you on this subject but it may be that Dhunda Sahib did not use those exact words and may have instead been stressing that without keeping a saaf dhill, abstaining from meat becomes less meaningful (as Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj stated in Gurbani) and I might be a bigger Pappi than you if looked at it in that way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

UKlondonsikh writes

He is there less at the moment as a direct consequence of the political calculations by which Sant Samaj (who oppose him) have to be kept sweet by Badal camp.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________

My response

Again a big lie.What do you mean by less. He is not there at all now. A sikh should not tell lies.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

@ GPS Paji

Paji, you must obviously be aware that Avtar Singh Hit Ji was affiliated with the Badal camp and that explains why the pro-Gurmat position was not given access to the stage in those years. Paji if Dhunda is a cheat and anti-Sikh then can you point his anti-Sikh cheating positions where the Sangat was in full agreement with him below? So if Sangat agree with him on certain issues (but not everything) does that define the Sangat as being anti-Sikh or atheist? Surely, we should all focus on the points where everybody agrees (though we can respectfully debate minor points of polite disagreement)

Paji i mentioned that it would be the local Sangat that gets the kathakars from the pro-Gurmat camp back at Sri Bangla Sahib in the future. The opposite of more often is less (regardless if the occurrence is never). If Sikhs should not tell lies then why do some claim Guru Sahib had other lives or on who the author of Charitropakhyan tales was?

I believe where there is ready access to vegetarian bhojan we should not eat meat. Dhunda Sahib has not encouraged Sangat like myself to eat meat.

We need to join forces for Unity (rather than nitpick on any minor pretext)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • To me it is total weakness. Great to hear that girls in your family were brought up well but what about those who weren't and got caught up in western bullsh!t? People make mistakes and if it's possible to assist I would do it just because forced prostitution and trafficking sickens me to the core.
    • Bro its not weakness its just the logical response. We are able to do action that is instilling our sisters with proper values, if your not their for your daughter sister growing up imprinting our religion and moral values from an early age they will either get into gora/western culture where dating is the norm or influence by bhangra or bollywood culture. I have older sisters and none of them dated or went to clubs  and now one of them got married. This was due to my parents instilling proper values in them.  It also helped tht my cousins would keep wathcful eye on them during there school time.  and in regards to not being able to do anything about it i'm more then capable of confronting any guy tht would trie this on my sisters 
    • Precisely brother. It encourages them to carry on and target other stupid or vulnerable Sikh girls. Looking at it from a very realistic perspective, realizing our lack of muscle and representation in the Pak underworld,  for those girls already in that hellhole, I would assume after some years of non stop abuse and after a certain age their value goes down and are not that much in demand, do you think an arrangement could be made to buy the girls from their pimps and get them out of there asap? Using force would be futile and could backfire on the girls, but everyone loves money and an arrangement could be possible. First step would be an expeditionary team going on the ground doing a few months of research trying to locate these girls, unofficially, masquerading as businessmen looking for a good time etc. No contact should be made with Government officials as they would sabotage the whole effort to deny that such a thing even exists.
    • I don't blame you guys but this is usually the response you get from people who are unable to do anything even if they wanted to and cover up their weakness with statements like these. It's a semi face saving response to cover up the shame they feel from their inability to do anything at all about the current situation so they can carry on their life as normal without that burden on their mind. I agree, some girls are total b!tches, because of kaam and ahankar they got tricked, never listen and learn it the hard way when it's too late, but should we who claim to be Sikhs of the Gurus just ignore their suffering and hellish existence when they are desperately reaching out for help? People make mistakes,people change and regret past actions, who knows these girls could be daily praying to Waheguru to save them from this hell they have gotten themselves into. If not on a racial or religious perspective at least think about them on a humanitarian perspective.    
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use