Why Do Pakistanis Support Khalistan?

[mrggg123 137]

I have been looking at twitter etc and i see more pakistanis supporting khalistan than apneh. What is the reason for this? Is there an agenda here?

Wouldnt khalistan include lahore and nanakana, im confused about this....

[Kira 1,447]

Weakening of India and a potential ally against them. Punjab is considered the "breadbasket" of India I believe, If Independence would happen then I'm guessing that it would end up weakening India's growing Populous.

[JagsawSingh 860]

I've been to Pakistan. There's an unbelievable love / affinty for Sikhs there. I'm not going to lie to you, it is mostly because they really do see Hindus as pagan devil / idol worshippers and they get a lot of news out there about anti-Sikh atrocities in India. When they see often what's happening to the Sikhs it makes them feel really relieved and grateful to have got out of there and made their Pakistan and deep down I think many feel that Sikhs have been left behind to suffer there (in India).

But what you mention about 'Khalistan' including places like Lahore etc is not really correct. I don't tend to use the word 'Khalistan' because I basically just want a free Punjab so whether or not its called 'Khalistan' or not is irrelevent. However iif you want to call it 'Khalistan' in this discussion than thats fine. we'll do that. So what you'll find is that its just a tiny 1% of 'Khalistanis' who are calling for territories within Pakistan to be included. 99% of we Khalistanis do wish they'd shut up because their stupid unrealistic pipe-dream call basically destroys any hope for real freedom. So get that out of your head. All Sikhs want is what is rightfully theirs: the natural right to self-determination.

[genie 1,714]

Pakistani's want to break up India but Sikhs should be wise to backstabbers of both the hindu and muslim faiths.

Khalistan WILL include Pakistan occupied punjab but that fight is not physical yet. They are scared of Sikh rebels taking over pakistan in future scenarios so want to keep Sikhs on side. Without various indian ethnic and religious minorities uniting and attacking the central Indian unionist government then india cant get dismantled so without the help of Sikhs they cant achieve their dreams.

What Sikhs need to understand is if India is to collapse as a state then pakistan must collapse also at the same time so that Sikhs can make a viable Khalistan otherwise it wont work and Sikhs will be trapped in a land locked state reliant on islamic pakistan for everything which will push its islamification agenda and use Khalistan as a puppet state to do its bidding in south asia.

[StarStriker 1,062]

Collaborate with the 1 nation india cacks its kacchi over.....china.

[genie 1,714]

Plenty of sikh loving punjabi muslims in pakistan but when push comes to shove they will be controlled by their more non-muslim hating fanatics amoung them and the mullahs and govt will eventually discriminate or hate on sikhs when/if the need arises to subjugate and persecute the non-muslim as has happened in all muslim societies since the advent of islam.

So yeah china is our best bet for a viable Khalistan but the political winds need to change before conditions are right for Chinese invasion and in turn getting help from the Sikhs of Punjab.

[mrggg123 137]

Collaborate with the 1 nation india cacks its kacchi over.....china.

explain this one pls paaji

[Jonny101 4,465]

Same reason why India supported Bangladesh. There is a cold war between between Hindus and Muslims of South Asia. Anyhow when Khalistan is made we should try to maintain friendly relations with both our Hindu and Muslim neighbours.

[Guest Jacfsing2]

They don't, (what it really is, is taking over the other parts of India). Maybe they just don't like Hindus or they don't know that Khalsa Raj will include all those Islamic territories. Maybe they'll be like Zakria Khan after giving them territory to Nawab Kapur Singh and then betray us.

[Jonny101 4,465]

They're still mad that we (Indians) freed Bangladesh from Pakistan, and want to break India apart in any means, which is wrong.

We just want our lost freedom which we lost in 1849.

1947 was just a transfer of one imperial power to another.

[lsingh 752]

Muslims are getting attacked for eating beef and you have the Kashmir situation. The Muslims know they have no future in India. Sikhs are under attack also , so Pakistan is highlighting this.

[MisterrSingh 8,407]

Why do Pakistanis support Khalistan?

It'll be easier for them to invade it when it's in our hands. That's the gist of the situation.

Plus, they like egging us on in order to annoy the Indians. Anyone who believes their support originates from a place of fraternal benevolence is mistaken. Pakistan cares for Pakistan.

We fail to see the number of absolutely key, albeit few in number, advantages we have on our side when dealing with India. It's in India's interests to keep us sweet, but they've got us fighting amongst ourselves so that they don't even have to bother with any of that.

[jkvlondon 6,850]

The muslims in Punjab are with us because even they know if we fall now they will die too . The ones in pakistan however want us to get azaadi because we would be a relatively unarmed(of course India would have to give arms and Money to us initially), untrained army force protecting a large region of ex-India which they could overrun with their superior air and land forces.

[genie 1,714]

The muslims in Punjab are with us because even they know if we fall now they will die too . The ones in pakistan however want us to get azaadi because we would be a relatively unarmed(of course India would have to give arms and Money to us initially), untrained army force protecting a large region of ex-India which they could overrun with their superior air and land forces.

Exactly, that is why to trust the pakistani muslim snake is worser than to trust the devil you already know (brahmin ruled indian union).

Lets not forget that Sikhs in pakistani dont have any freedom of religion they cant exactly go out and preach and give parchar for muslims to convert, they cant open up new gurdwara's they cant get key jobs within the establishment, they are mocked alot in drama shows, their girls are groomed and kidnapped by muslim zealots hence why most pakistani sikh parents want their kids to marry indian sikhs. Pakistani Sikhs are tolerated by the huge muslim majority they are not seen part and parcel of pakistani society or state because they are non-muslims. In education books muslim kids are taught to hate the kafir non-believers and that hindu's and sikhs are enemies of Islam.

In 1980s behnezir bhutto betrayed the Khalistan movement by giving the details of all the Khalistan armed groups based in pakistan and India that had american CIA / pakistani ISI backing to rajiv gandhi's government, the very government that was responsible for the genocide of Sikhs in New Delhi 1984. She also stopped the flow of arms and funds and stopped giving refuge to Sikhs fleeing Indian state persecution.

So amoung all this backdrop we can see we can never trust the pakistani muslim snake once bitten twice shy should be our motto

[jkvlondon 6,850]

Exactly, that is why to trust the pakistani muslim snake is worser than to trust the devil you already know (brahmin ruled indian union).

Lets not forget that Sikhs in pakistani dont have any freedom of religion they cant exactly go out and preach and give parchar for muslims to convert, they cant open up new gurdwara's they cant get key jobs within the establishment, they are mocked alot in drama shows, their girls are groomed and kidnapped by muslim zealots hence why most pakistani sikh parents want their kids to marry indian sikhs. Pakistani Sikhs are tolerated by the huge muslim majority they are not seen part and parcel of pakistani society or state because they are non-muslims. In education books muslim kids are taught to hate the kafir non-believers and that hindu's and sikhs are enemies of Islam.

In 1980s behnezir bhutto betrayed the Khalistan movement by giving the details of all the Khalistan armed groups based in pakistan and India that had american CIA / pakistani ISI backing. She also stopped the flow of arms and funds and stopped giving refuge to Sikhs fleeing Indian state persecution.

So amoung all this backdrop we can see we can never trust the pakistani muslim snake once bitten twice shy should be our motto

we are sitting in a pit of vipers I see no difference between the kattards of both factions , maybe we have the benefit of the blustering arrogance of the pakistani to thank as they announce their intentions quite clearly before their actions, the more deadly is the Brahmin kattard viper , as they are so charming and smile looking into your eyes while they stab you in the back. But why trust them at all from Gangu until now all they've been doing is trying their damnedest to destroy Sikhi from the roots up.