Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
hgsingh

Warning To All Sikhs Do Not Waste Your Time With Shastar Vidya

58 posts in this topic

that niddar singh teach's cause look at this video

this <banned word filter activated> doesn't believe in keeping your hands up he believes in desi fighting keeping your hands down

get ready to laugh

anyone who defended shastar vidya please don't post in a martial art forum again cause you know nothing about martial arts and fighting

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ignorance is bliss I guess. Request to Sangat ji, please go train Muay Thai/BJJ/Boxing/ Wrestling. After go train SV, you'll realise Shaster Vidiya is about training with "Shaster" and the aim is usually to kill, much different then the other Arts listed above. Hgsingh veerji is failing to understand this.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have understood this but why not learn to use a gun then rather then knives

you can't carry knives like that anyways so why not train in krav maya

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ever heard of something called a Kirpan/Kard? Its that thing all Amritdhari Sikhs are supposed to carry.

If you think Krav Maga is the best, then stop trolling forums and practise. For someone who posts so much I doubt you even train in any art. For those who do SV, if they have understood its effectiveness then there is no need to convince someone on the net.

Anyone who doubts can come along to the akhara and test it out. This has always been the case. As SV opens up to the worlds martial artists, its ability to hold its own and receive acknowledgement speaks much more then some random singh on a forum who even doubts his own indiginous art, and licks the boot of the firangi.

When Nidar Singh comes to USA, i will let you know and you can go beat him yourself. Talking only goes so far, pick up your weapons and lay down your challenge.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Muay Thai, Boxers, Wrestlers, Silat students and all other forms of martial artists have come to the akhara to train and learn. If SV was rubbish, surely in the 15 yrs of Nidar Singh teaching there would be an incident where he got beaten or the flaws of the art were highlighted. This has not happened, and instead top martial artists are organising seminars with Nidar Singh. The question should be, as a Sikh, how much are you really searching for the truth?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

haha gurbar akaal their are thousands of martial arts schools in the west that are waste of time and money

i call them waste of time and money cause students could invest that time and money in good schools

gurbar akaal your another loser who doesn't know anything about fighting who has fallen for niddar singh's lies

hahahaha I'm going to expose how easy you are to scam

name me the martial arts teachers that are top in the world who want to do seminars with niddar singh????

now I'm going to expose how stupid you are go watch the video i posted on this thread and look at how stupid niddar singh's hand to hand combat is

this explains why niddar singh is such a coward and doesn't hold open challenges cause his hand to hand combat system is so stupid

gurbar akaal I've emailed niddar singh and I've posted his email address for anyone to email niddar singh and his school regarding competing and having open challenges sad thing is i can't go to his akhara and kick his butt cause their to scared to have open challenges

and i live in canada buddy

as well Gurbar Akaal I'm here to warn sikhs about this stupid martial arts teacher and not to waste their time

Tell me Gurbar Akaal how can i challenge niddar singh if he's to scared to have open challenges hahahahahahahaha

he won't compete with anyone cause he knows he'll get rocked

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

last thing you need to use is your kirpan against someone who doesn't have a weapon on them in a fight cause that will get the kirpan banned so grow a pair and learn to fight hand to hand for those situations

gurbar akaal you showed how stupid you are cause look at that video of the hand to hand combat system niddar singh teach's

why would real muay thai fighter or wrestler waste their time with niddar singh either your lying or stupid

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

for all singh's who visit this thread

please don't fall for simple minded people like gurbar akaal

email nihang@gmail.com and ask niddar singh and his students why they don't compete and why niddar singh doesn't have open challenges??

cause simple minded people like gurbar akaal are easy to scam and their the once who fall for these lies that niddar singh has open challenges and if he is defeated he would step down

when niddar singh is to scared to do such a thing

gurbar akaal this is why niddar singh hasn't bin beaten in 15 years of training

he's to scared to compete he has never fought anyone cause he know's his stupid hand to hand combat system would fail

dude if you knew anything about fighting you would watch that video and laugh

now watch that video on his hand to hand combat system and you'll know that people would have to be very stupid to believe real muay thai fighters and boxers go their to train

anyone who has bin in a fight or has trained in muay thai or boxing would know these techniques would never work

also in the other thread i posted how to know that your martial arts school is a scam

one way to know its a scam is when their to scared to compete or let their students compete against other schools

schools who are to scared to compete don't compete cause they would get beat

now look at the video and you'll understand why niddar singh is to scared to compete

watch 7 min mark to 8 min mark and 11 min mark to 12 min mark as to why he doesn't believe in keeping his hands up hahahahahahhahaahhaha

as well if you want their have bin tournments for decades with no rules fighting with top fighters from each martial art competing and from these martial arts you learn which martial arts work and which don't and thats why most traditional martial arts schools are going down and only stay in business by scamming people who know nothing about fighting and putting these lies into their heads as to how their martial art is so lethal that they train to kill with one strike but you cannot learn this strike till you have your second degree black belt and and that is why you don't see their martial art in ufc

even though the top fighters from their martial arts got their heads kicked in no rules tournments around the world and the lies were exposed about these so called martial arts having the ability to kill 6 attackers within 5 seconds with pressure points hahaha and other lies

if you want to learn to fight investigate and learn what the top fighters in the world learn

to show how stupid niddar singh is he can't tell the difference between hinduism and sikhism

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ever heard of something called a Kirpan/Kard? Its that thing all Amritdhari Sikhs are supposed to carry.

If you think Krav Maga is the best, then stop trolling forums and practise. For someone who posts so much I doubt you even train in any art. For those who do SV, if they have understood its effectiveness then there is no need to convince someone on the net.

Anyone who doubts can come along to the akhara and test it out. This has always been the case. As SV opens up to the worlds martial artists, its ability to hold its own and receive acknowledgement speaks much more then some random singh on a forum who even doubts his own indiginous art, and licks the boot of the firangi.

When Nidar Singh comes to USA, i will let you know and you can go beat him yourself. Talking only goes so far, pick up your weapons and lay down your challenge.

Muay Thai, Boxers, Wrestlers, Silat students and all other forms of martial artists have come to the akhara to train and learn. If SV was rubbish, surely in the 15 yrs of Nidar Singh teaching there would be an incident where he got beaten or the flaws of the art were highlighted. This has not happened, and instead top martial artists are organising seminars with Nidar Singh. The question should be, as a Sikh, how much are you really searching for the truth?

Two words: Well said.

To those who know about Martial arts (and who may be experts themselves), if you watch the SV videos you will be able to appreciate its authenticity, technique execution and history. The fact that this is our own indiginous art, and some of our own people do not except it annoys me. But to be honest it doesn't surprise me, as the will always be a few narrow minded individuals who are unwilling to forego their own ego and make a real effort to search for the truth.

Where there is a rose, there will be thorns.

Where there is honey, there will be flies.

To hgsingh, please view the video where Nihang Niddar Singh Ji is holding a training session with the Phialpino instructor (I forgot his name now, sorry). And also please view all of the seminar demo videos. My question is, if these masters of other martial arts and appreciate and praise SV, why can't you?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shaster vidya is a hindu martial art created over a thousand years ago

Anyone who knows how to fight sees shaster vidya as waste of time after watching that video

Watch 7 min mark to 8 min mark and 1 1 mind mark to 12 min mark

Sikhs should learn the best fighting systems out their

90's was famous for no rules fighting competitions and you had the best from all martial arts fight and from this the world saw muay thai always dominate over other martial arts in stand up and ji jitsu dominate the ground

Lot of ppl like buying stupid machines workout for 2 min and your in shape

Those people are once who get scammed into thinking shaster vidya works or lies told by traditional martial arts schools about how their martial art is so dangerous and have to lie to get students

Now people who know fighting go straight to mma school

Dan hardy uk fighter trained in the most famous chinese temples for traditional martial arts and said mma is the way to go if you want to be the best fighter on the streets

Traditional martial art schools lie just like these 2 min workout for being in shape

And ppl fall for them cause they don't want to work hard

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If SV was rubbish, surely in the 15 yrs of Nidar Singh teaching there would be an incident where he got beaten or the flaws of the art were highlighted.

That is a very good point.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eh there's no such thing as "Sikh martial arts". Sikhs shouldn't get attached to an art at all. Saying this is our indigenous art, blah blah blah- THAT is ego.

Whatever is best, train in that. End of story

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chatanga niddar singh refuses to spare and compete with anyone from any other martial art oif the to scared then how can anyone defeat him

As well real fighters see flaws have bin pointed out and 98 percent of martial arts schools have many flaws and are a waste of time when you could be training in mma and other modern martial arts

Dan hardy from uk is a profesional fighter who has trained in some of the most famous temples in china and he says it traditional martial arts are outdated and waste of time

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chatanga niddar singh refuses to spare and compete with anyone from any other martial art oif the to scared then how can anyone defeat him

I didnt know that. Maybe some of his supporters can shed some light on that?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SV originates from Kalarippayatu (see below) - just type it in youtube and see the similarities. Niddar talks about SV being so gupt and being passed down to only the worthy few, and that he just happened to come across a grand master whislt on holiday. I don't agree with this

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalaripayattu

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pal that is most traditional martial arts school that they know the real martial art and conspiracys how its bin kept secret for hundreds of years

I laugh cause niddar singh sounds like most traditional martial arts schools

And shastar vidya is practised by rajputs hindus

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hgsingh

You are a lair. When I Private Messaged you. You mentioned you live in Canada. Cover your tracks at least mate.

So now we are clear that you live in the UK, why don’t you go and visit Niddar Singh? As you have mentioned in one of the posts, you live in west london?

Born in West midlands?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kluivert your an <banned word filter activated> please tell were I said I'm from the westmidlands or west london

If I visited niddar singh he would start crying

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kluivert your an <banned word filter activated> please tell were I said I'm from the westmidlands or west london

If I visited niddar singh he would start crying

Youre a tard.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Singher23 are you trying to insult me cause I exposed how stupid people like you are for believing niddar singh's bs

But again why is he and his students such big talkers of how effective shaster vidya is yet run like cowards

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never believed his stuff. I'm not referring to him at all. I am referring to your immense ego and arrogance

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

YOO, EVERYONE JUST CHILLLL....

If Niddar Singh practices what he believes and what his student believe is Shastir Vidya, then let them be...If you don't agree that's fine. You don't have to denounce it. Im personally indifferent on this issue..but i really don't care......

Singho! when are we going to stop fighting amonst ourselves about petty isssues, look at the Khalsa Panth, we have no unity!....theres beadbi of our Guru going on! WAKE UP.... we can complain about small things like this, but we can't even uphold the respect our our GURU! We are all Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh! until we don't start acting like it, until we don't unite, its sad to say Singho... but our Sikhi we be reduced to nothing.

Remember the Khalsa Panth will always remain strong because there are some Gurmukh Piyaree who will forever hold onto its purity, the Guru's Khalsa can not have weaknesses only we as individuals can have weaknesses. Benti to the Sangat.....Stop fighting over small issues...your not 5 years old

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is everyone gassin? If you got a problem with shastar vidya..be the big man and go test it out against niddar singh...i dont agree with everything niddar singhs says...but the art from what i have seen seems authentic...you just have to read historical sikh granths and shastar vidya is mentioned in there...it is a part of our history and heritage if you like it or not...most of you against shastar vidya are against it becase of ideological differences with niddar singh..you just cant drop your ego....learn the martial art your ancestors practised and used against their enemies...if you ignore and oppose it..niddar singh will just give the art to non sikhs..and thats like handing a diamond over to a thief...you keep your jewels to yourself and well protected..but sadly most sikhs have been fed false propaganda about shastar vidya and willing to boycott just because of heresay ..

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is everyone gassin? If you got a problem with shastar vidya..be the big man and go test it out against niddar singh...i dont agree with everything niddar singhs says...but the art from what i have seen seems authentic...you just have to read historical sikh granths and shastar vidya is mentioned in there...it is a part of our history and heritage if you like it or not...most of you against shastar vidya are against it becase of ideological differences with niddar singh..you just cant drop your ego....learn the martial art your ancestors practised and used against their enemies...if you ignore and oppose it..niddar singh will just give the art to non sikhs..and thats like handing a diamond over to a thief...you keep your jewels to yourself and well protected..but sadly most sikhs have been fed false propaganda about shastar vidya and willing to boycott just because of heresay ..

exactly, i dont agree with the hindu-esque practises within shastar vidya (the tilak/aarti/chandi dance etc), but this is the same shastar vidya that was practised by the khalsa, by guru gobind singh, guru hargobind, maharaja ranjit singhs akali nihangs. it was banned by the british, who had never been sweated so much in a battle like they were during the sikh-anglo wars. remember the british banned this along with the dasam granth, because the fear of rebelliion that can come from it. wats wrong with niddar raising this back within our stupid fat roly poly sleeping community.

sahibzada ajitsingh, was known to be able to make 10 hits in 1 and a 1/2 secs, wat style do u guys think he was using, get real guys!

im led to understand, one of the main reasons shastar vidya hand combat cant exactly been done in practise is because the result is to KILL the opposition, not like other martial arts where u jus injure sum1 2 teach em a lesson.

watever niddars beliefs r regarding rules n regulations of being a nihang (meat alcohol etc), thats his belief, but i wud love to learn this martial art, and on a personal level, this shud NOT EVER be taught to non-believers! like gunman has sed above, givin this art to non-believers, is like givin a diamond to a thief. when a dodgy christian/muslim uses shastar vidya on a sikh on the streets, it shall be a sad day n us as laughin stocks

this forum needs to have pappu control by the mods

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gurfateh

Firstly Dasmeh Patshah told us to train in gatka, and he has done it in there times, and it may be practised by Rajput Hindu's but, our Guru said for us to lear it aswell so just understand and do what there Hukam says, dont argue, Fateh

Half of u guys have alot of ego man!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0