Akj Stance On Sri Dasm Granth Sahib Jee

[Gurmat Sangeet]

when the foundations of dharm are rocked, it is righteous to rais the sword. Questioning Adhi and Dasam Maharaj is questioning and rocking dharam its self.

Akaaaaaaaal!

[Guest militant singh]

end of da day akal thakht maryada was broken -

CHAPTER IV

Sec E

No book should he installed like and at par with the Guru Granth Sahib

[singh987]

when the foundations of dharm are rocked, it is righteous to rais the sword. Questioning Adhi and Dasam Maharaj is questioning and rocking dharam its self.

Akaaaaaaaal!

But in this thread no-one has questioned Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji or Dasam Granth, just maryada was questioned. Is it still righteous to raise the sword? - we are 2% of the world population, shall we raise the sword on the other 98% that doesn't agree with us? - or better still, lets raise it on the other 1.8% of us which are lost and mis-guided, that'll fix the problem!

I don't understand what people are bragging about - what's the worst that can be done? You'll beat each other up? Break a few bones? Kill one another? - aaho that's how you'll wash your sins and help you fellow human being/sikh veer wash theirs. Plus, these kind of hollow threats don't scare off everyone.. some people have no fear of expressing their views, and they don't need to advertise it. Jadon guru da danda varna ah, koi awaaj nahi auni. Anyhow, I won't hijack this thread any longer. I'm sorry I just had to get that out of my system.

Gurfateh.

[Inder Singh]

when the foundations of dharm are rocked, it is righteous to rais the sword. Questioning Adhi and Dasam Maharaj is questioning and rocking dharam its self.

Akaaaaaaaal!

But in this thread no-one has questioned Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji or Dasam Granth, just maryada was questioned. Is it still righteous to raise the sword? - we are 2% of the world population, shall we raise the sword on the other 98% that doesn't agree with us? - or better still, lets raise it on the other 1.8% of us which are lost and mis-guided, that'll fix the problem!

I don't understand what people are bragging about - what's the worst that can be done? You'll beat each other up? Break a few bones? Kill one another? - aaho that's how you'll wash your sins and help you fellow human being/sikh veer wash theirs. Plus, these kind of hollow threats don't scare off everyone.. some people have no fear of expressing their views, and they don't need to advertise it. Jadon guru da danda varna ah, koi awaaj nahi auni. Anyhow, I won't hijack this thread any longer. I'm sorry I just had to get that out of my system.

Gurfateh.

So you have abandoned that thread and come here. It is you who was doubting Dasam granth sahib in the otehr thread.

Here you are stating something else.

Both granths are from our Guru sahibs and hence no violation of maryada

[AK-47]

end of da day akal thakht maryada was broken -

CHAPTER IV

Sec E

No book should he installed like and at par with the Guru Granth Sahib

No it wasnt, since no book was 'installed like and at par' with maharajhs saroop. A saroop of Dasam Granth Sahib Ji was parkash next to Maharajh. And Dasam Granth Sahib Ji is not a "book" it is the gurbani written by guru gobind singh ji and is recognised by the same akal thakhat as such.

Harry potter is a book, Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji cannot be considered a book and anyone who wishes to call themselves a Sikh needs to consider if they really view the tenth gurus writings as being in merely a 'book'. Same way we would not call a gutka sahib a book, or call a senchi a book etc. If someone did parkash of a book, then that is entirely different thing, but here and at many other places around the world, we have parkash of a saroop of dasam granth sahib ji.

And Militant Singh, you have a picture of Sant Jarnail Singh in your profile and you claim to have a lot of respect, in another thread you even said that someone who doesnt believe/follow sant ji is not a sikh ... well do you follow sant ji and are you a sikh? Because the maryada that was done at willenhall was what sant ji practiced. So is sant jarnail singh ji guilty of breaking maryada and an rss etc? You cant sit on the fence, you cant say you follow sant ji and at the same time speak against dasam granth. So you will have to choose at some point.

[Guest shastr]

singho, how many times are we going to get into these types of arguments over dasam bani? how many threads on this board have be locked cuz of this jibber jabbar that goes on? half of us like to be internet giani's yet dont even do nitnem in the morning.

all these people crying oh beadhbi of maharaj, where were u when saroops of maharaj were being burned? where were u people when bullets where being sprayed on maharaj saroops ?? where were u people when saroops of maharaj were being urinated upon? where were u people when maharaj saroop was taken apart ang by ang and laid across a 14 km distance? how come none of you big defenders of maharaj saroop did anything at that time?

all these people crying about guru ji, how many hours a day do we spend in maharaj's hazoori doing nitnem? how many hours of chaur sahib do we do? since we have soo much respect for maharaj saroop, how much seva have we done for maharaj?

these people only want to create fights among people. they know nothing about sikhi, nothing about rehit maryada, nothing about sikh history, nothing about bhagati. the only thing they know how to do is how to create a scene and make it look like they are true sikhs of maharaj. im not going to start naming people, but you guys know who you are. and this stuff is really nearing its end.

and for the people who oppose taksaal, tell me, which taksaal was it where entire maharaj's saroop was written and compiled? which taksaal was it that kalgidhar patshah guru gobind singh ji started himself and did katha of entire guru granth sahib ji? which taksaal was it where gurmat sikh rehat maryada was all written and started? which taksaal was it where akand paaths started? which taksaal was it where santhiya was started? which taksaal was it that distributed maharaj saroop over various takhats? which taksaal was it that walked 5 koh with their head in their hand ? which taksaal was it that did sukhmani sahib while being cut into pieces?

the one and only, DAMDAMI TAKSAAL.

so before you go and say wat ever u want about guru sahibs taksaal, i suggest u check ur self, and have a look at sikh history, as this taksaal is where maharaj's saroop was made pargat in the whole sansaar.

shame on all those people who talk badly about kalgidhar ji's taksaal. anybody who says anything about taksaal or sri dasam granth sahib, needs to get banned no questions asked. period

[Guest jaachak]

You know what, you can become a good preacher. And by the way, just to remind you, Gurujee started ONLY Khalsa Panth. Taksal started as a school to teach Gurbani. AKJ started out as Gursikhs gathering to do keertan. The entire jathebandi concept came a lot later. The SIKH hisory you talk of, thats right, its SIKH history, NOT Taksal history. The Gurmukh piyaare you talk of, they knew themselves only and ONLY as Singhs of Dasmesh Pita, nothing more than that.

[Lion of Punjab]

i always thought the goray started AKJ?

[BhForce]

i always thought the goray started AKJ?

???!

Anyway, Dhan Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Dhan Sri Dasmesh Ji di Bani

[Southall Youth]

end of da day akal thakht maryada was broken -

CHAPTER IV

Sec E

No book should he installed like and at par with the Guru Granth Sahib

No it wasnt, since no book was 'installed like and at par' with maharajhs saroop. A saroop of Dasam Granth Sahib Ji was parkash next to Maharajh. And Dasam Granth Sahib Ji is not a "book" it is the gurbani written by guru gobind singh ji and is recognised by the same akal thakhat as such.

Harry potter is a book, Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji cannot be considered a book and anyone who wishes to call themselves a Sikh needs to consider if they really view the tenth gurus writings as being in merely a 'book'. Same way we would not call a gutka sahib a book, or call a senchi a book etc. If someone did parkash of a book, then that is entirely different thing, but here and at many other places around the world, we have parkash of a saroop of dasam granth sahib ji.

And Militant Singh, you have a picture of Sant Jarnail Singh in your profile and you claim to have a lot of respect, in another thread you even said that someone who doesnt believe/follow sant ji is not a sikh ... well do you follow sant ji and are you a sikh? Because the maryada that was done at willenhall was what sant ji practiced. So is sant jarnail singh ji guilty of breaking maryada and an rss etc? You cant sit on the fence, you cant say you follow sant ji and at the same time speak against dasam granth. So you will have to choose at some point.

If you want to bring sant ji into this then lets to it with truthfullness. Sant ji did katha of dasam bani, but did he do prakash on same level and under the same palki as SGGS.

If you have proof otherwise then please show me. Thankyou.

I can't really speak to anything k-z has posted in other threads, but in this thread, he hasn't said anything against AKJ.

I agree with t_singh's post that Sikhi isnot a numbers game and we don't have to have a competition for most members in such and such a jatha or group.

Khalistan_ z is one of the most behaved singhs i have seen on this forum.

Lets let admins decide that.

on another note, ive noticed alot of people get put under quality control once they get into an argument with you (inder).

is that just a mere coincidence? i hope so. For the sake of the forum...i really hope so.